Foreign terror labels curb ISIS, but US radicals face fewer limits online, study finds
Share and Follow

In the United States, extremist groups are taking advantage of the current disarray in social media to spread their violent ideologies, according to a recent report and security specialists. They caution that this issue is no longer confined to foreign terrorist organizations but is a growing domestic concern.

Research conducted by the Stern Center for Business and Human Rights at New York University, titled “Digital Aftershocks: Online Mobilization and Violence in the United States,” highlights how the online presence of violent Islamist factions has diminished. This reduction is attributed to the effectiveness of terrorist designations coupled with platform enforcement, which has successfully driven these extremists into less visible parts of the internet, thereby curbing their ability to recruit and disseminate propaganda.

The report notes, however, that the same legal mechanisms are not applied to domestic extremist groups. This discrepancy, described as an “enforcement asymmetry,” allows far-right, far-left, nihilistic, and antisemitic groups to flourish on mainstream social media platforms without similar constraints.

antifa protester

In the image provided by Reuters/Jim Bourg, Antifa members are seen marching during a rally in Washington on August 12, 2018, marking the one-year anniversary of the Charlottesville “Unite the Right” protests.

Dr. Casey Babb, a professor specializing in terrorism and the director of the Promised Land Project at Canada’s Macdonald-Laurier Institute, shared with Fox News Digital that lawmakers already possess the necessary authority to address and mitigate the threat of domestic extremism.

“Despite the First Amendment, and, of course, some of this is in a gray zone, but not all speech is protected,” Babb said. “There are already tools there that enable policymakers, law enforcement, intelligence agencies and so on to crack down on domestic extremists.” “Statements that are intended to provoke unlawful action, incitement, that’s not protected speech. Or statements where the person making [them] intensely communicate[s] some sort of intent to commit an unlawful act or violence, or says something that could be perceived as a legitimate threat, that’s not protected.”

The NYU report mirrors that frustration, concluding that the U.S. has “ample tools” to confront extremism but applies them unevenly. It found that when foreign terrorist designations restrict groups like al Qaeda and ISIS, their online reach collapses.

“The ability to designate organized nations and individuals as terrorist entities is a very useful tool,” Babb said. “It’s a tool that policymakers should really lean into and think about, possibly modernizing and reforming to better address a lot of what we’re seeing domestically.”

Babb said extremists are “learning from one another,” adopting propaganda and recruitment methods once pioneered by Islamist organizations.

“Groups like ISIS, al Qaeda and the Muslim Brotherhood were some of the early adopters of these platforms,” he said. “They recognized many, many years ago the power of these social-media outlets to recruit, to disseminate harmful messaging and to really undermine the populations that they target.”

Antifa protest in Portland, Oregon on June 19, 2019

Antifa protesters in Portland, Oregon, on June 19, 2019. (Moriah Ratner/Stringer)

He also blamed social-media companies for enabling the spread of hate.

“There’s frankly no reason that I should be seeing much of what I’m seeing online,” Babb said. “Free speech is one thing; giving a platform for nefarious state and non-state actors to spread divisive language deliberately with the intent of dividing Americans and endangering certain minorities, that’s something else entirely. These platforms reward outrage and they reward divisive content. A lot of people are monetizing this.”

“You shouldn’t be making thousands of dollars a month by spreading the same messages that Adolf Hitler or Yahya Sinwar would spread,” he added.

WATCH: Trump takes Antifa fight abroad with foreign terrorist designation

President Trump once floated designating Antifa a domestic terrorist group, an idea Babb believes deserves renewed attention.

“Designation opens a whole suite of tools,” he said. “It makes adversaries’ lives much more difficult.”

The Digital Aftershocks report concludes that U.S. policymakers and tech platforms must coordinate more aggressively to combat online extremism.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Shamed Andrew is formally stripped of his last remaining royal titles

Prince Andrew Loses Final Royal Titles in Official Decision

In a significant turn of events, Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor has been officially stripped…
Accused CEO assassin Luigi Mangione asks judge to toss evidence from his arrest

CEO Murder Suspect Luigi Mangione Seeks Dismissal of Arrest Evidence in Court

On Monday, Luigi Mangione, the alleged assassin, made his way back to…
Luigi Mangione fights to exclude evidence as anniversary of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson's murder nears

Luigi Mangione Challenges Evidence as UnitedHealthcare CEO’s Murder Anniversary Looms

NEW YORK — As the first anniversary of the death of UnitedHealthcare…
Notorious dine-and-dasher sparks all out WAR at ritzy apartment block

Epic Showdown: Infamous Dine-and-Dasher Ignites Chaos at Luxury Apartment Complex

Brooklyn eateries might be breathing a collective sigh of relief now that…
Reporter's Notebook: Thanksgiving weekend in Turkey with an American Pope, next stop Lebanon

Thanksgiving in Turkey: An American Pope’s Journey to Lebanon Unveiled

Early Sunday morning, it was confirmed that the Vatican’s chartered Airbus 320,…
Girl 'tied up and drowned in honour killing had upset her father'

Tragic Honor Killing: Father Allegedly Drowns Daughter in Disturbing Family Dispute

Prosecutors in the Netherlands have brought to light the tragic case of…
I was drinking 130 units a week. Then I discovered a miracle solution

From 130 Units to Sober: Discover the Miracle Solution Transforming Lives

Be honest—when was the last time you told your doctor exactly how…
Trump invites families of two National Guard members shot in DC to White House, plans to honor soldiers

Trump to Honor Families of National Guard Members Shot in DC with Special White House Invitation

West Virginia honors fallen National Guard soldier Governor Patrick Morrisey of West…