Share and Follow
RATING: 8 / 10
In today’s crowded landscape of TV Westerns, viewers have an abundance of options to choose from, thanks in part to Taylor Sheridan’s prolific contributions to the genre. “The Abandons” emerges as an enticing new contender, set in 19th century rural Oregon, where the tension between two feuding families takes center stage. Starring the talented Gillian Anderson and Lena Headey, both showcasing their finest Western personas, the series draws comparisons to “Deadwood” with its compelling ensemble of supporting characters that add depth and emotion. With its captivating narrative, there’s hope that Netflix recognizes the gem they have on their hands, allowing the series to flourish and engage audiences further.
- Strong performances from Lena Headey and Gillian Anderson
- Focused, well-written narrative
- Excellent supporting cast
In the evolving town of Oregon depicted in “The Abandons,” power resides with the Van Ness family, led by the formidable matriarch Constance Van Ness (played by Anderson). She governs both her children and the town with a firm hand, yet remains accountable to influential investors like Cornelius Vanderbilt, who have invested heavily in her mining ventures. When the determined Fiona (portrayed by Headey) and her group of orphans reject selling their increasingly lucrative land, the already strained relationship intensifies, especially as their children become entangled in the feud. As boundaries are crossed, their conflict escalates beyond property disputes to a perilous battle of principles.
- At only seven episodes, it’s over far too soon
From the outset of “The Abandons,” it is evident that Gillian Anderson and Lena Headey command the spotlight, each rising to the challenge with aplomb. Their characters bear immense responsibility for those around them, displaying fierce love that simultaneously highlights their distinct imperfections. They stand as two contrasting forces—one impulsive, the other calculated—both striving to assert control amidst chaos. The ability to empathize with their characters, even when their actions are questionable, is a testament to the writing and performances.
While Anderson and Headey are the central figures in “The Abandons,” the series boasts a rich tapestry of characters that keeps the narrative fresh and dynamic. The complex relationships within the Van Ness family draw viewers in, with siblings (Lucas Till and Toby Hemingway) vying for maternal approval while their sister Trish (Aisling Franciosi) remains unimpressed. Fiona’s surrogate family adds further intrigue, featuring siblings (Nick Robinson and Diana Silvers) she cared for before their father’s passing, alongside Black and Indigenous children (Lamar Johnson and Natalia del Riego) adopted on their journey west. Though Fiona raised them, as they mature, they begin to push back against her controlling nature. Beyond these families, a host of neighbors and business associates add layers to the plot, each with their own memorable moments that are best discovered firsthand.
Society in “The Abandons’” burgeoning Oregon town is dominated by the Van Ness family, and more specifically by Constance Van Ness (Anderson), the clan’s matriarch. She rules over her children — and the town, for that matter — with an iron fist, but she’s also beholden to her investors like Cornelius Vanderbilt, who have poured money into her mining concerns. When the strong-willed Fiona (Headey) and her band of orphans refuse to sell their increasingly profitable plot of land to her, their already tense relationship grows ever more hostile — especially when their children become embroiled in the drama. As they find themselves crossing more and more lines from which there is no return, their conflict becomes about something more dangerous than land: a matter of principle.
A showdown between mothers
The moment “The Abandons” begins, it becomes clear that Gillian Anderson and Lena Headey are going to dominate the proceedings, and both prove themselves more than up to the task. Their characters take on a tremendous amount of responsibility for those around them, and while they love fiercely, this love comes through in ways that makes their own unique flaws obvious. Throughout the story, they operate as two sides of the same coin, one impulsive and one methodical, but both desperate to maintain control in a chaotic world. That we can understand and to a certain extent sympathize with them even when they’re behaving abominably is a testament to both the writing and their performances.
But while they’re the cage match of “The Abandons,” there’s an impressive deep roster of other characters in the show that keep things engaging; we imagine a relentless battle between just Constance and Fiona would get dull rather fast. There are complex dynamics between the Van Ness siblings, each brother (Lucas Till and Toby Hemingway) desperately seeking their mother’s approval while their sister Trish (Aisling Franciosi) is none too impressed by their behavior. Fiona’s found family is more interesting still, between the pair of siblings (Nick Robinson and Diana Silvers) she nannied for before their father’s death and the Black and Indigenous children (Lamar Johnson and Natalia del Riego) they took in on their journey westward. Fiona raised all four of them, but now that they’re mostly grown up, they’re each in their own way beginning to chafe against her frequently controlling attitude. In addition to the two families, there’s a crop of neighbors and business relations, some of which get delightful moments of glory that we would not dare spoil here.
The series is filled with potential
Although there are a lot of different characters in the mix — many of whom we would love to see have their storylines expanded, should Netflix give “The Abandons” a second season — the show never makes the mistake of overcomplicating its central narrative. For the most part, we stay zeroed in on the conflict between the two families, how each decision they make draws them deeper into a potentially dangerous situation, and the various ways that Constance and Fiona attempt to rig the game. Constance has money and power on her side, but Fiona is scrappy and unafraid to do anything to protect what’s hers, whether it’s her land or her adopted children. We’re constantly reassessing who has the upper hand in the relationship, although at times both seem wantonly destructive.
“The Abandons” stands up against the best that the Western TV genre has to offer, and for our money, it can go toe-to-toe with the expanded “Yellowstone” universe. Although the first season is relatively short, we would happily watch the series evolve over the course of several years. In many ways, it feels like we’re only beginning to scratch the surface of what “The Abandons” has to offer. But as long as Gillian Anderson and Lena Headey are involved, audiences can expect fireworks.
“The Abandons” premieres on Netflix on December 4.