OU student’s zero for Christian-based gender critique triggers congressional pushback over academic bias
Share and Follow

EXCLUSIVE TO FOX: The controversy over a University of Oklahoma student’s class assignment has made its way to the U.S. Senate. The student claims she received a zero on her work due to her “Christian kind of worldview,” which questioned prevailing gender norms.

This incident has caught the attention of prominent senators, including former presidential candidate and Senate Banking Committee Chairman Tim Scott from South Carolina, as well as Oklahoma Senator Markwayne Mullin, who represents the university’s state. Both senators have voiced their concerns over the situation.

“This is absolutely outrageous,” Senator Mullin remarked to Fox News Digital. “Especially here in Oklahoma, educators should not be allowed to impose their political biases and penalize students unjustly. We must ensure that education remains focused on learning, not on pushing a harmful agenda.”

Oklahoma student Samantha Fulnecky and the United States Capitol.

The student at the center of this dispute, Samantha Fulnecky, a junior at the university, was penalized with a zero out of 25 points on her psychology essay. She chose to write a critique from a faith-based perspective on gender identity, rather than adhering to the evidence-based analysis required for the assigned scholarly article titled “Relations Among Gender Typicality, Peer Relations, and Mental Health During Early Adolescence.”

Samantha Fulnecky, a junior at the university, got a zero out of 25 on her essay after turning in a faith-based critique of gender identity instead of responding to the assigned scholarly article, “Relations Among Gender Typicality, Peer Relations, and Mental Health During Early Adolescence.”

The scholastic piece analyzes a case study of middle schoolers who may have seen “gender‐based teasing” among other experiences associated with not conforming to gender norms.

“College professors should be focused on core subjects — not woke political indoctrination. The First Amendment, including religious freedom, should be at the core of higher education,” Mullin added. “A student was given a ZERO for citing the Bible and stating reality: that there are only two genders.”

Sen. Markwayne Mullin

Senator Markwayne Mullin told Fox News Digital “there should be zero tolerance for woke activists disguised as ‘educators’ who punish students for no reason and put their toxic political agendas ahead of our kids’ education.” (Tom Williams/CQ-Roll Call, Inc via Getty Images)

Part of the grading criteria included five points for the paper simply being “clearly written.”

“Gender roles and tendencies should not be considered ‘stereotypes,’” Fulnecky’s essay read. “Women naturally want to do womanly things because God created us with those womanly desires in our hearts. The same goes for men. God created men in the image of His courage and strength, and He created women in the image of His beauty. He intentionally created women differently than men, and we should live our lives with that in mind.”

The teacher’s assistant who graded the assignment, Mel Curth, uses she/they pronouns.

Scott, who is an outspoken Christian and widely known as a man of faith, called the TA’s decision to give Fulnecky a zero “pathetic.”

Tim Scott, Donald Trump

Sen. Tim Scott told Fox News Digital the TA’s decision to give the student a zero was “pathetic.” (Reuters)

“I think it’s pathetic that a young lady gets a zero on her work because the instructor has a different opinion,” he told Fox News Digital. “Students should be able to express themselves on a college campus and be judged on how well they performed, not based on whether one likes what the student has to say.”

“The question is, ‘Do we have freedom of expression on college campuses?’ If not, they should not be getting federal funding and frankly, it’s not a school at all — it’s an indoctrination camp,” Scott added.

Fox News Digital interviewed Fulnecky earlier this week, who said that the TA “left submission comments saying that my work was offensive, that I need more empathy in my writing, things like if I’m going to argue against the consensus of every medical field, in every medical association in the United States, then I need empirical evidence to back that.”

University of Oklahoma campus.

The University of Oklahoma placed the TA on leave following Fulnecky’s complaint. (Brian Bahr/Getty Images)

Fulnecky filed a discrimination complaint claiming she was graded for her Christian beliefs, prompting the university to place the graduate instructor on leave while investigating.

The University of Oklahoma did not respond to Fox News Digital’s request for comment, but did post to social media that the public college takes “concerns involving First Amendment rights, certainly including religious freedoms” seriously.

Fox News Digital reached out to Curth but did not receive a response.

Preston Mizell is a writer with Fox News Digital covering breaking news. Story tips can be sent to Preston.Mizell@fox.com and on X @MizellPreston

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Brian Walshe told cops his missing wife left for a flight on Jan 1, JetBlue records keeper says otherwise

JetBlue Records Contradict Brian Walshe’s Claim About Wife’s Jan 1 Departure, Police Report Indicates

On Wednesday, the murder trial of Boston art fraudster Brian Walshe continued…
Chicago Public Schools reaches $17.5M settlement over Little Village Lawndale High School Dean Brian Crowder sex abuse case

Chicago Public Schools Settles $17.5M in Landmark Little Village Lawndale HS Abuse Case

In a significant development, Chicago Public Schools (CPS) has reached a settlement…
Gwen Stefani can't get enough of husband Blake Shelton in bed

Gwen Stefani Gushes Over Blissful Bedtime Moments with Husband Blake Shelton

Gwen Stefani and Blake Shelton have recently ignited rumors of a possible…
Adams issues orders blocking NYC from boycotting Israel as clash with Mamdani grows

NYC Mayor Adams Blocks Israel Boycotts Amid Intensifying Feud with Councilman Mamdani

In a decisive move to confront antisemitism and resist the anti-Israel Boycott,…
Dead Texas college student's phone was 'thrown in the woods,' grieving mother says

Shocking Discovery: Texas Student’s Mysterious Death Unveiled as Phone Found Discarded in Woods

The mother of a Texas A&M University student, whose body was discovered…
Cowboys-Chiefs Thanksgiving game draws record-shattering 57 million viewers

Thanksgiving Showdown: Cowboys vs Chiefs Game Smashes Viewership Records with 57 Million Fans Tuning In

The Kansas City Chiefs and Dallas Cowboys delivered a Thanksgiving showdown that…
State attorney finds actions by officer who shot 14-year-old in stolen car pursuit were justified

State Attorney Rules Officer’s Actions Justified in 14-Year-Old’s Shooting During Car Chase

A “communication breakdown” was cited by the State Attorney’s Office as the…
Josh Shapiro rips Kamala Harris for 'blatant lies' about him in her memoir

Josh Shapiro Calls Out Kamala Harris for Alleged Falsehoods in Her Memoir: A Political Feud Unfolds

Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro has launched a fierce critique of former Vice…