Shooting at an Oklahoma State University residence hall wounds at least 3 people
Share and Follow

On Friday, a federal judge critically examined the Trump administration’s justification for continuing to oversee California National Guard troops, initially sent to Los Angeles in June due to violent demonstrations.

During a hearing in San Francisco, U.S. District Judge Charles Breyer pointed out that the situation in Los Angeles has evolved since the troops were first deployed. He questioned the administration’s authority to maintain control over state Guard forces indefinitely.

“Crises are not eternal,” Judge Breyer remarked, adding, “Our experience shows that crises emerge and eventually subside. That’s the natural order.”

He challenged the government’s attorney to provide proof that state officials were either incapable or unwilling to ensure the safety of federal personnel and property. Judge Breyer also mentioned that President Donald Trump had access to a large number of active-duty troops in California.

The state of California has requested that Judge Breyer issue a preliminary injunction to return control of the remaining California National Guard troops in Los Angeles back to state authority. Although Judge Breyer did not make an immediate decision, he has previously ruled against the administration’s control over the California National Guard, deeming the deployment unlawful.

Trump initially called up more than 4,000 California National Guard troops in response to the protests over his stepped-up enforcement of immigration laws, but that number had dropped to several hundred by late October, with only a 100 or so troops remaining in the Los Angeles area.

Justice Department Attorney Eric Hamilton said federal law gives the president the power to extend control of state Guard troops as long as he deems that necessary.

The remaining troops in Los Angeles were allowing immigration agents to continue their mission and protecting federal property, he said, noting someone threw two incendiary devices into a federal building on Monday.

The court did not have the authority to review how the president manages a Guard mission that is in progress, but even if it could, it had to consider the violence this summer, Hamilton said.

“We cannot turn a blind eye to what happened in Los Angeles in June of this year,” he said.

Trump’s call up of the California National Guard was the first time in decades that a state’s national guard was activated without a request from its governor and marked a significant escalation in the administration’s efforts to carry out its mass deportation policy. They were stationed outside a federal detention center downtown where protesters gathered, and later sent on the streets to protect immigration officers as they made arrests.

California sued, and Breyer issued a temporary restraining order that required the administration to return control of the Guard troops to California. An appeals court panel, however, put that decision on hold. Breyer was nominated to the bench by President Bill Clinton, a Democrat.

California argued that the president was using Guard members as his personal police force in violation of a law limiting the use of the military in domestic affairs.

The administration said courts could not second-guess the president’s decision that violence during the protests made it impossible for him to execute U.S. laws with regular forces and reflected a rebellion, or danger of rebellion.

In September, Breyer ruled after a trial that the deployment violated the law. Other judges have blocked the administration from deploying National Guard troops to Portland, Oregon, and Chicago.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Disgraced ex-Sen Bob Menendez banned from holding any public office in New Jersey

Former Senator Bob Menendez Prohibited from Public Office in New Jersey Amid Scandal

Former Senator Bob Menendez, once representing New Jersey as a Democrat, has…
Meghan Markle leaves royal fans baffled with her $12 chocolate bars

Meghan Markle’s $12 Chocolate Bars Spark Curiosity Among Royal Fans

Meghan Markle has recently introduced a line of $12 chocolate bars, sparking…
Prince Harry should be stripped of his titles. says expert

Expert Calls for Royal Title Removal: Prince Harry’s Status Under Scrutiny

Prince Harry’s title should be reconsidered to clear up potential misunderstandings among…
Glen Powell has been dating Michelle Randolph for 'two months'

Glen Powell and Michelle Randolph Confirm Two-Month Relationship

Glen Powell is reportedly in a budding romance with actress Michelle Randolph,…
Loyola New Orleans TPUSA chapter denied again after 'absolutely appalling' student government meeting: student

Controversial Denial: Loyola New Orleans TPUSA Chapter Faces Rejection Amid Heated Student Government Debate

The student government at Loyola University has once again rejected a bid…
LeBron James' 10 points a game streak ends after eye-popping 1,297 games

LeBron James’ Remarkable 1,297-Game Streak of Scoring 10 or More Points Comes to an End

After an incredible run, the legendary LeBron James’ streak of scoring at…
Dear Abby: My best friend is no longer a part of my life, but my wife is still in contact with him

Navigating Friendship Fallout: What to Do When Your Spouse Stays Friends with Your Ex-Bestie

DEAR ABBY: My long-time best friend, “Ian,” has unexpectedly cut all ties.…
Texas A&M cheerleader Brianna Aguilera gleefully poses with boyfriend weeks before witnesses heard pair argue ahead of her fatal plunge

Texas A&M Cheerleader Brianna Aguilera Seen Joyfully with Boyfriend Weeks Before Tragic Incident Following Alleged Dispute

Brianna Aguilera, a cheerleader from Texas A&M, was recently seen beaming with…