Martha Moxley case: Kennedy cousin breaks silence on troubled upbringing, arrest warrant in murder mystery
Share and Follow

Five decades after the tragic death of Martha Moxley, a young girl from a wealthy Connecticut family, a member of the Kennedy clan who was once embroiled in the case is breaking his silence.

Michael Skakel, a cousin of Robert F. Kennedy Jr., served 11 years in prison for the 1975 murder of Moxley. Released in 2013, his conviction was subsequently overturned, yet Skakel continues to fight to clear his name in a case that has gripped the public’s attention for years.

Skakel has finally decided to share his story in depth through the NBC News podcast, “Dead Certain: The Martha Moxley Murder.” This marks the first time he has spoken extensively since his conviction was vacated, offering insights into his childhood and presenting his perspective on the infamous murder case.

Martha Moxley was just 15 years old when she was brutally beaten and stabbed with a golf club in the yard of her family’s Greenwich home on October 30, 1975. She was last seen enjoying “Mischief Night,” a local tradition where children engage in harmless pranks the night before Halloween.

Martha Moxley when she was 14 years old

File photo of Martha Moxley at age 14. (Erik Freeland/Corbis via Getty Images)

An autopsy later revealed Moxley had been killed with the golf club, which was ultimately traced to the Skakel family’s home. 

Investigators initially began looking into Thomas Skakel, Michael’s older brother, and the family’s live-in tutor, Kenneth Littleton, before ultimately turning their attention to Michael, who was 15 at the time of Moxley’s death.

For decades, Skakel had remained largely silent. However, he is now speaking out to tell his side of the story, while recounting painful details about his traumatic childhood. 

Skakel detailed how his family’s Catholic religion played a large part in his upbringing, while recalling how he was hit over taking Playboy magazines when he was a child.

Michael Skakel reacts to being granted bail

Michael Skakel reacts to being granted bail during his hearing at Stamford Superior Court November 21, 2013, in Stamford, Connecticut.  (Bob Luckey-Pool/Getty Images)

He went on to discuss how his parents primarily showed affection toward his brother, Tommy, when the brothers were growing up. Skakel also pointed to how his parents hardly visited him after he was hospitalized with a broken neck when he jumped off a desk in his childhood home. 

When Skakel’s mother was dying from cancer, the young boy was told her hair was falling out due to her shampoo – not the treatment – and was ultimately blamed for her illness by his father, he said.

Skakel recalled a time in which his father, whom he had not seen in weeks, told him, “You make me sick. If you only did better in school, your mother wouldn’t have to be in the hospital.”

“I just wanted to die,” Skakel said in the episode, as he recalled how his father barely addressed his mother’s death.

Martha Moxley with her father

File photo of Martha Moxley at 13 with her father David Moxley.  (Erik Freeland/Corbis via Getty Images)

As his mother struggled with her illness, Skakel began drinking when he was just a teenager. On the day she died, he finished off an entire bottle of Smirnoff on his family’s lawn, he said. 

“His alcoholic, abusive father tortured him physically and psychologically throughout his boyhood, including beating him and telling him he was responsible for killing his mother,” Dr. Carole Lieberman, a forensic psychiatrist, told Fox News Digital.

Lieberman pointed to how the psychological damage inflicted on Skakel likely impacted him in his adult life as his drinking eventually escalated. In 1978, he borrowed his brother’s car and, while driving with a few friends, smashed into a telephone pole. 

In exchange for not being charged with a DUI, the family’s lawyer concocted a deal in which Skakel was sent to the controversial Élan School in Maine in an effort to correct his unruly behavior. 

Martha Moxley when she was 14 years old

File photo of Martha Moxley when she was 14.  (Erik Freeland/Corbis via Getty Images)

Individuals from the boarding school traveled to Connecticut to pick him up, with Skakel recalling how he “was dragged out of there like an animal,” before being loaded onto a plane where he was thrown into “a world of utter insanity.”

The Élan School had roughly 300 live-in students who were often subjected to harsh physical punishments, prolonged screaming and occasionally wearing dunce caps, according to the podcast. Headcounts were carried out every 15 minutes to keep residents from escaping, which Skakel attempted multiple times. 

In an emotional recounting, Skakel described how he was subjected to various punishments, including the “general meeting” and “boxing ring” where students would face forms of physical brutality. 

“They sent maybe 10 guys upstairs to get me,” Skakel said, as he recalled a failed escape attempt. “And they literally picked me up over their heads and carried me down the stairs like I was a crash test dummy. And when I was probably 10 feet from the stage, they threw me and I thought I broke my back on the stage.”

The Moxley residence

The Moxley residence in the Belle Haven section of Greenwich, Connecticut, in 1975.  (MediaNews Group/Boston Herald via Getty Images)

After Skakel left the school, he was diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and spent a month at a residential care facility in California. 

He got married in 1991 and established a skiing career. However, his new life in Hobe Sound, Florida, came crashing down in 2000, when authorities issued a warrant for his arrest in Moxley’s murder. 

“My Uncle Tommy rented me a private jet the next morning,” Skakel said. “And I flew from [the] Jupiter jet port, the private jet port, to Teterboro, and I’m looking on the news the next morning and it’s all over every station.”

Skakel did not immediately return Fox News Digital’s request for comment. 

On Jan. 19, 2000, Skakel turned himself in to authorities after police issued a warrant for his arrest, 25 years after Moxley was killed. Skakel, who was 39 at the time, was initially arraigned as a juvenile, with the case later ending up in regular court. 

He was convicted of murder by a panel of 12 jurors in Norwalk Superior Court on June 7, 2002, and later sentenced to 20 years in prison. 

In 2013, following multiple failed attempts to appeal his conviction, Skakel was granted a new trial after a judge ruled his attorney, Michael Sherman, did not adequately defend him in his original case.

Skakel’s conviction was ultimately vacated by the Connecticut Supreme Court on May 4, 2018, with prosecutors later deciding to not seek a second trial for Skakel on the murder charge.

“Michael Skakel should never have spent one day in prison because there was no way to determine that he was guilty beyond reasonable doubt,” Lieberman said. “Many threads were left hanging. From a questionable police investigation to a questionable attorney who didn’t bring the alibi witness in to testify, to media sensationalism and no forensic evidence.”

“Michael was a victim of torture throughout his life, from his childhood to the court system,” Lieberman said, adding Skakel “has continued to unconsciously play out this victim role until today.”

While the mystery surrounding who killed Moxley continues to loom over the case, Skakel’s bid to assert his innocence in the podcast adds a new voice to a story that has been marred by decades of silence. 

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Luigi Mangione pumps his fist as he gleams during court hearing

Luigi Mangione Triumphs in Court: Celebrates Victory with Fist Pump

Murder suspect Luigi Mangione exuded confidence as he punched the air with…
Soon no Pearl Harbor survivors will be alive. People turn to other ways to learn about the bombing

With Pearl Harbor’s Last Survivors Fading, Alternative Ways to Learn About the Historic Event Emerge

HONOLULU (AP) — For many years, those who survived the 1941 Japanese…
Murdaugh trial court clerk pleads guilty to showing sealed crime scene photos to photographer

Court Clerk Admits Guilt in Sharing Confidential Murdaugh Crime Scene Photos with Photographer

A former court clerk in South Carolina, Mary Rebecca “Becky” Hill, admitted…
Top Armed Services Rep. Adam Smith says Sept. 2 Caribbean boat strike video would show Republicans' description 'completely false'

Rep. Adam Smith Challenges GOP’s Narrative with Crucial Sept. 2 Caribbean Boat Strike Footage

WASHINGTON — In a recent development, the leading Democrat on the House…
Tucker Carlson announces he is 'buying a place in Qatar'

Tucker Carlson Reveals Plans to Acquire Property in Qatar

Tucker Carlson recently disclosed his plans to invest in property in Qatar…
State Department reportedly orders visa denials tied to speech censorship as Trump team slams Europe

State Department Allegedly Blocks Visas Over Censorship Issues Amid Trump’s Criticism of Europe

The Trump administration has allegedly instructed U.S. consular officers to intensify their…
Man with 12 arrests this year busted again after allegedly attacking doctor in hospital elevator: report

Man Arrested for 13th Time This Year Following Alleged Assault on Doctor in Hospital Elevator: Report

In a troubling incident in Chicago, a man with a history of…
Pretrial hearing for Luigi Mangione to resume Monday after court releases new evidence in CEO murder case

Pretrial Hearing for Luigi Mangione Reopens with Fresh Evidence in High-Profile CEO Murder Case

The courtroom in New York is set to reconvene today as Luigi…