Share and Follow
In New York, the leading federal prosecutor in Manhattan announced on Friday that a judge does not have the power to appoint a neutral expert to manage the public dissemination of documents related to the sex trafficking investigation involving financier Jeffrey Epstein and British socialite Ghislaine Maxwell.
U.S. Attorney Jay Clayton communicated through a letter to Judge Paul A. Engelmayer, advising him to dismiss a recent request made by the congressional cosponsors of the Epstein Files Transparency Act for the appointment of a neutral expert.
The request came from U.S. Representative Ro Khanna, a Democrat from California, and Representative Thomas Massie, a Republican from Kentucky. They expressed “urgent and grave concerns” over the sluggish release of what is only a small fraction of millions of documents, a process that began last month.
The congressmen, in their filing to the judge, asserted that they suspect “criminal violations have taken place” in the way the documents have been released.
However, Clayton argued that Khanna and Massie do not possess the legal standing required to request the “extraordinary” action of appointing a special master and independent monitor to oversee the release process.
Engelmayer “lacks the authority” to grant such a request, he said, particularly because the congressional representatives who made the request are not parties to the criminal case that led to Maxwell’s December 2021 sex trafficking conviction and subsequent 20-year prison sentence for recruiting girls and women for Epstein to abuse and aiding the abuse.
Khanna said Clayton’s response “misconstrued” the intent of their request.
“We are informing the Court of serious misconduct by the Department of Justice that requires a remedy, one we believe this Court has the authority to provide, and which victims themselves have requested,” Khanna said in a statement.
“Our purpose is to ensure that DOJ complies with its representations to the Court and with its legal obligations under our law,” he added.

Epstein died in a federal jail in New York City in August 2019 as he awaited trial on sex trafficking charges. The death was ruled a suicide.
The Justice Department expects to update the court “again shortly” regarding its progress in turning over documents from the Epstein and Maxwell investigative files, Clayton said in the letter.
The Justice Department has said the files’ release was slowed by redactions required to protect the identities of abuse victims.
In their letter, Khanna and Massie wrote that the Department of Justice’s release of only 12,000 documents out of more than 2 million documents being reviewed was a “flagrant violation” of the law’s release requirements and had caused ” serious trauma to survivors.”
“Put simply, the DOJ cannot be trusted with making mandatory disclosures under the Act,” the congressmen said as they asked for the appointment of an independent monitor to ensure all documents and electronically stored information are immediately made public.
They also recommended that a court-appointed monitor be given authority to prepare reports about the true nature and extent of the document production and whether improper redactions or conduct have taken place.
Copyright © 2026 by The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.