Share and Follow
In a tragic turn of events, the key witness in the controversial shooting of Ruben Ray Martinez by a federal immigration agent has died. Joshua Orta, who was in the car with Martinez at the time of the shooting, passed away in a fiery car crash in San Antonio over the weekend, as confirmed by the attorney representing the Martinez family.
Orta had provided an account that contradicted the official narrative from the Department of Homeland Security regarding the incident that took place last year. During a Spring Break trip, Orta and Martinez encountered a group of local police officers and federal agents managing traffic at a busy intersection due to an accident. The Department of Homeland Security claimed that Martinez had “intentionally run over a Homeland Security Investigation special agent,” prompting another agent to fire “defensive shots to protect himself, his fellow agents, and the general public.”
However, in a draft affidavit derived from interviews with Orta conducted in September, he painted a different picture. Orta stated that Martinez did not strike any officer with the vehicle. Instead, he described their car as “just crawling” while attempting to make a turn. He alleged that a federal agent fired into the driver’s side window from a mere two feet away, without issuing any warnings or giving them a chance to comply.
The loss of Orta, a 25-year-old man, occurred when he crashed into a utility pole after losing control at a high speed on a highway exit. While passengers managed to escape the ensuing flames, they could not rescue Orta from the burning vehicle, according to San Antonio police reports.
San Antonio Police said a 25-year-old man was killed Saturday when he drove into a curved highway exit at a high rate of speed before losing control and slamming into a utility pole. Passengers were able to escape as the vehicle caught fire, but they were unable to pull out the driver.
Lawyers for Rachel Reyes, Martinez’s mother, said Orta was the man who was killed in the car accident. The draft affidavit indicated Martinez’s family is preparing to file a wrongful death lawsuit in the earlier shooting.
“First and foremost, Joshua’s death is an awful tragedy for his family and friends,” said Alex Stamm, one of the lawyers representing the family. “In terms of Ruben’s death, the world has also now lost a critical eyewitness.”
DHS on Monday said: “We stand by our original statement.”
The Texas Rangers confirmed last week they are investigating Martinez’s shooting. The agency did not respond to questions Monday about whether they had interviewed Orta prior to his death.
Orta’s account contradicts DHS
Orta and Martinez decided to take a spontaneous trip to Texas’ South Padre Island to meet up with friends, according to Orta’s draft affidavit. After hanging out in a condo and having a “few drinks,” then a pool party and a trip to Whataburger, they arrived at the scene of an accident and slowed the car down, Orta said.
A local police officer approached their car, saw an open alcohol container in the back, but told the two young men to turn around and leave, he said. As they tried to turn in the traffic, another officer walked up to their car and slapped the hood and “seemed to be trying to get in front of the car,” said Orta.
Martinez “did not hit anyone,” Orta said.
Then several more officers surrounded their vehicle, yelling at them to stop and drawing their guns, Orta recounted. “This was crazy to me because we were only crawling,” he said, adding that Martinez never hit the gas and the officers weren’t in any danger.
An officer standing by Martinez’s open driver’s side window then pulled his weapon and fired without warning, so close the bullet casings ejected from his weapon landed inside the vehicle, he said.
Orta recounted hearing his friend say “I’m sorry” as he slumped backward unconscious after being stuck in the chest. He said agents then pulled Martinez from the car and handcuffed him, waiting at least 10 minutes before providing any medical aid.
Reyes, Martinez’s mother, told AP last week her son was shot three times. She also said an investigator from the Texas Rangers had obtained videos of the shooting that she said undercut DHS’s claim her son tried to run over the agent.
Similarities to other shootings
According to an internal incident report from Immigration and Customs Law Enforcement that was released earlier this month after a Freedom of Information Act lawsuit, the HSI agents involved in the shooting were part of a maritime border enforcement security task force typically focused on combating transnational criminal organizations at seaports. Over the past year, however, officers from across multiple federal agencies have been reassigned to prioritize immigration enforcement.
In January, Renee Good, a 37-year-old mother in Minneapolis, was killed in the driver’s seat of her SUV by an ICE officer. Trump administration officials initially attempted to paint Good as a “domestic terrorist” who tried to ram officers with her vehicle before multiple videos emerged of the incident that cast doubt on the government’s narrative.
Law enforcement officers are typically trained not to step in front of vehicles due to the danger they might be struck. Like Good, Martinez had no criminal record.
Stamm, the family’s lawyer, said Orta’s account confirmed Martinez’s car was barely moving before the HSI officer opened fire.
“He also told us unequivocally that Ruben did not hit anyone,” Stamm said. “We believe Joshua’s account, and, as we have seen recently in Minneapolis, Chicago, and elsewhere, it is critical that the public be shown every piece of evidence in the government’s possession, and that any witness come forward.”
___
Bedayn reported from Denver.