Share and Follow
Left inset: Ruth Miller (Tuscarawas County Sheriff’s Office). Right inset: The boat dock at Atwood Lake in Tuscarawas County, Ohio, where a woman allegedly drowned her 4-year-old son after causing her husband’s death, cops say (WKYC/YouTube). Background: Ruth Miller in court for her Monday bond hearing in Ohio (WKYC/YouTube).
A mother from Ohio faced with accusations of instructing her husband and young son to leap into a lake under a supposed “spiritual delusion,” leading to their tragic deaths by drowning, has been declared not guilty by reason of insanity.
On Tuesday, Tuscarawas County Common Pleas Judge Michael J. Ernest delivered this verdict following the examination of three mental health evaluations regarding Ruth Miller. She had faced charges including aggravated murder and child endangerment for the tragic events of August 2025. The reports concluded that Miller was unable to comprehend the wrongfulness of her actions, prompting the judge’s decision.
“Ruth Miller is not guilty by reason of insanity,” Judge Ernest stated in the courtroom. “This verdict is the only logical conclusion based on the evidence presented.”
The case and its outcome were reported by Law&Crime. As a member of the Old Order Amish community, Miller is now expected to be transferred to a mental health facility, with a hearing set for March 13 to finalize the arrangements.
As detailed by the local news outlet Canton Repository, Ohio law permits judges to ensure that individuals found not guilty by reason of insanity receive necessary mental health treatment. This confinement generally corresponds to the length of the sentence they would have faced if convicted. Release from such facilities is contingent upon a judicial determination that the individual no longer constitutes a threat to themselves or others.
Miller, who is from the Millersburg area, waived her right to a jury trial on Feb. 24.
Prosecutors said Tuesday that the state will ask for Miller to be confined to a secure mental health facility. Defense attorney Ian Friedman told the Canton Repository that Miller’s family wants her back with them as soon as possible. She has been in jail without bail since her arrest on Aug. 23, 2025.
Miller allegedly admitted to killing her husband, Marcus Miller, and son, Vincen Miller, at Atwood Lake in east-central Ohio “because God was speaking to them” and wanted the pair to “prove their worthiness,” cops said.
She was previously held at a secure hospital for a mental health evaluation before being booked into the Tuscarawas County Jail in September 2025 and charged with two counts of aggravated murder, two counts of domestic violence and one count of endangering children.
“God spoke to her and told her to throw Vincen into the lake and she did,” alleged Detective Adam Fisher, with the Tuscarawas County Sheriff’s Office, at a September bond hearing streamed by NBC affiliate WKYC.
“She described watching Vincen go under the water and pop back up,” Fisher said. “At that moment, God spoke to her, questioning why she was still looking for Vincen after she had given him to God.”
Miller allegedly told cops she was “hearing voices that she believed were God,” according to Tuscarawas County Sheriff Orvis Campbell, who revealed details about the drownings at a press conference after Miller’s arrest.
“That led her and her husband to go out and jump in the lake first,” Campbell said.
Police officials also accused Miller of crashing a golf cart into the water with her three other children inside. Fisher and others described how witnesses allegedly saw the golf cart crash and Miller praying on the dock.
“It was very intentional,” Fisher alleged. “They witnessed her drive through the lighthouse and the marina and down through the grass and over the wall into the water.”
Ruth told police that “she and Marcus were both nervous about getting in the water initially,” per Fisher, but they allegedly got in anyway.
“They were to float on their backs at one point and Marcus began to sink during this,” Fisher alleged. “So they swam back to the dock.”
Ruth allegedly told police that Marcus Miller was supposed to be able to pull her from the water onto the dock, but he failed to do it multiple times, so she had to swim to the back of the boat and climb out using its ladder.
“She said that Marcus … started to sink because of his lack of faith and that he was not able to pull her out of the water because he would not ask God for any strength to do that,” Fisher explained.
Ruth allegedly claimed that they got out of the water and went back to their camper for awhile before eventually returning to the lake to keep testing themselves.
Police said she commanded Marcus Miller to get back in as part of another “test” from God, which caused him to drown. Miller said she believed he failed the initial tests “because he didn’t have enough faith,” per police. She then allegedly demanded that Vincen go in afterward as punishment.
“She believed that she and her husband had to pass these tests to show their faith, and when they didn’t, then Vincen became the price to pay for that,” Campbell said. “What she says is that she and her husband went to this dock, and they jumped in the water because God was speaking to them and telling them to do things, things to prove their worthiness to God, to show their faith is complete. And they didn’t do very well in those.”
Police said some of the tasks Marcus Miller was given were “bizarre,” with many of them being “swimming exercises.” Ruth Miller allegedly told investigators that God asked her at one point to be “swallowed by a fish.” Ruth Miller said God’s final test for Marcus Miller was to swim to a nearby sandbar, according to police.
Police have described the Millers as members of the Old Order Amish Church and living in Holmes County. They were reportedly visiting Atwood Lake as part of a weekend trip, which Campbell says began like any vacation.
“I do not think it was a plan,” the sheriff concluded. “I believe that based off detailed conversations with the family, that they were just going to the lake.”