It’s easy to approach Mike Flanagan’s Carrie with some skepticism. Stephen King’s short novel already became a famously compact film, so what could a miniseries add? Flanagan, however, has built a career on transforming classic horror into expansive stories about human weakness, trauma, and fear. His answer becomes clear when Carrie enters high school: the longer format brings complexity.
High school is an overwhelming shock for Carrie, made even harsher by bullies, social media, parties, and the many dangers of an unsheltered new life. Yet she isn’t the only teenager being forced into upheaval. Her arrival triggers cruelty and violence among her classmates, while also compelling them to confront uncomfortable truths about who they are. Chris, Sue, and the other students each face urgent personal questions of their own. It would be too simple to say every character receives a separate arc, but Flanagan and writers including Justina Ireland and Elan Gale clearly move the series in that direction. Strong performances from Siena Agudong and Alison Thornton—who vividly conveys the turmoil inside Chris—make those individual struggles feel authentic.
Still, Carrie remains Carrie’s story, and much of its emotional power rests with Summer H. Howell and Samantha Sloyan. Sloyan moves beyond the more exaggerated qualities sometimes associated with Margaret White, presenting her instead as frightened, furious, and dangerously human. Following Sissy Spacek’s unforgettable performance, Howell finds an ideal balance between Carrie’s innocence and intelligence. Carrie learns quickly, but nothing in her life has prepared her for the world’s cruelty—or for the speed with which kindness can turn into something darker. It’s a remarkable central performance, and an essential one, because Flanagan is reaching for more than a longer retelling of Stephen King’s familiar plot.
KEEP READING: Strictly Fans Unite Over It Takes Two Presenter Ellie Taylor
The key events remain, but this Carrie is ultimately concerned with the broader pressures placed on American teenagers. Each of these young people is pushing against a social cage whose bars keep shifting to make escape nearly impossible. At times, the conflict is simply a matter of bullies inflicting harm. More often, though, the series aims for something broader, delivering major surprises while deepening its themes. Carrie is the story’s center, but she also opens the door to a larger discussion about the misery of high school—and how that misery might be challenged. Mike Flanagan, horror cinema’s great humanist, has created another series that demands your attention.
Carrie premieres on October 7 on Prime Video.