New Chinese Weight-Loss Injection Could Rival Mounjaro

An experimental weekly weight-loss injection could emerge as a rival to popular treatments including Wegovy and Mounjaro, according to new research.In a clinical trial,...
HomeNewsHow Labour’s Policies Killed Off Marlborough’s Historic Tea Rooms

How Labour’s Policies Killed Off Marlborough’s Historic Tea Rooms

The ‘specials’ boards remain on the tables. Brightly coloured cups, saucers and teapots still line the shelves, while a plate piled with enormous meringues sits in one of the 17th-century bow windows. Yet the tearoom is eerily silent.

Several black-and-white photographs hang crookedly on the walls. The ovens are cold, and the revolving cake cabinet is completely empty.

The Polly Tearooms in Marlborough, Wiltshire, has closed its doors for good. The High Street institution had served customers since 1912, opening seven days a week, and stood on the site of what was once a busy coaching inn on the London-to-Bath route.

Yesterday, regulars walked solemnly past the historic brick-and-timber building. Some shook their heads in disbelief; others looked simply heartbroken.

No one feels that loss more deeply than David Clarke. He and his late wife, Annie, bought Polly’s in 2013 and invested around £60,000 in refurbishing the basement kitchens and updating the interior.

“It was always Annie’s dream to run a tea house,” Mr Clarke said. “We knew the margins would be tight, but we wanted to give people a treat — to prepare everything fresh on the premises and make every customer feel special.”

That dream ended last Sunday, when Mr Clarke placed a notice on the door declaring: “Sorry, we are closed for good because of relentless tax rises and overhead costs, plus another minimum wage increase… it is simply impossible to run a high street business in the UK in these circumstances.”

Mr Clarke said he did not finally decide to close until after John Healey’s budget on October 28.

It¿s all over for The Polly Tearooms in Marlborough, Wiltshire, which has been a fixture on High Street since 1912 (open seven days a week)

The Polly Tearooms in Marlborough, Wiltshire, has closed after serving customers on the High Street since 1912

The Princess of Wales was said to have loved the blueberry muffins at Polly¿s

The Princess of Wales was said to be particularly fond of Polly’s blueberry muffins

From his nearby home in the Wiltshire village of Axford, he listened closely to every word Andy Burnham’s new Chancellor had to say. He had been hoping for some relief — a reason to keep going. Instead, he said, there was nothing to encourage him.

“The Government has no understanding whatsoever of hospitality,” said Mr Clarke, who was awarded an MBE for his work as group chief executive of the Chartered Institute for IT. “I held out because I thought Healey might be different from Rachel Reeves, who clearly had no experience of business. But there was nothing to help us. Nothing at all.”

What angers Mr Clarke most is what he sees as the short-term thinking behind the policies. Until recently, Polly’s employed 20 people, some full-time and others part-time.

For many of those workers, it was their first job — an opportunity to enter employment, build confidence, gain experience and become part of a community.

Those former employees may now struggle to find new work amid a difficult economy and a deepening hospitality crisis. Mr Clarke fears they could be left relying on benefits, adding to what he describes as an already out-of-control bill.

“Everything was against us,” he told the Daily Mail. “Our suppliers were under pressure and, understandably, they passed those costs on to us. They also reduced the amount of credit available to us. The pressure worked its way down the chain until it reached our business.

“But we couldn’t pass those costs on to our customers. They simply wouldn’t accept it.”

Another serious blow came with the ending of the temporary Retail, Hospitality and Leisure relief scheme, which had offered discounts of up to 75 per cent, later reduced to 40 per cent, on business rates. The scheme ended at the start of the new financial year on April 1.

As a result, Mr Clarke’s business rates rose from £974 last year to £2,400 a month from April. National Insurance contributions also increased, while energy bills surged amid the impact of America’s war against Iran.

The Government has also increased the living wage, which Healey announced would rise again next April, from £12.71 an hour to £13.21. But Mr Clarke says VAT is the biggest burden. Hospitality businesses in Britain pay the standard 20 per cent rate on food, non-alcoholic drinks and hotel accommodation — one of the highest rates in Europe.

Comparable businesses in Germany pay 7 per cent VAT, while the rate is 9 per cent in Ireland and 10 per cent in France, Spain and Italy.

“Reducing VAT to 15 per cent would make a huge difference,” Mr Clarke said. “Businesses could then decide whether to keep the money or pass the saving on to customers through lower prices. In our case, we would have passed it on and encouraged more people to come through the door. That is what growth looks like.”

For now, however, Marlborough is experiencing a crisis, despite being an affluent town whose charter was granted by King John in 1204. In the past 18 months, at least six shops and hospitality businesses have either been boarded up or sold.

Until last year, the town had a WH Smith, later replaced by a TG Jones outlet. That business closed in October. Rejuvenesce Beauty Salon entered receivership in January, fashion retailer Mint Velvet shut its doors in May, and even Costa Coffee near the famous Town Hall has departed.

“The tax burden on hospitality businesses has soared over the past two years and now amounts to 82 per cent of profits,” said Kate Nicholls, chair of UK Hospitality.

“We need immediate tax cuts, and VAT is the quickest lever to pull. Reductions in business rates and employment taxes would also help keep our high streets open.”

When the then Prince of Wales visited Marlborough in 2004, he declared: “Towns do not come better than this.” It is easy to see why. The High Street is regarded as one of the widest and most attractive in Britain, having been largely rebuilt after a fire in 1653, although several Tudor buildings survived.

The Polly Tearooms, on the southern side of the High Street, was founded by women’s rights campaigner Janet McCloud and her business partner, Jean Leith Hay. It later became a refuge of sorts for suffragettes.

Students from Marlborough College, built on the site of the town’s old castle at the western end of the High Street, also found sanctuary at Polly’s. Former pupils include John Betjeman, Bruce Chatwin, Rab Butler and, more recently, the Princess of Wales, who was reportedly fond of the tearoom’s blueberry muffins, as well as Princess Eugenie and comedian Jack Whitehall.

“We used to go in for a cream tea, but it was also somewhere we could hide behind a pillar and smoke a cigarette or two,” said one former pupil who attended the school in the late 1970s.

Danny Kruger, the local Reform UK MP, told the Daily Mail: “Polly’s has been a landmark for generations of residents and students. It is desperately sad that a business like this is being used as a cash cow by the Government to pay benefits. Labour does not regard employers as proper working people.”

Mr Clarke is now left with debts, as well as memories of better times. Singer Robbie Williams, who lived nearby before moving to Los Angeles, had his own table in a corner close to a signed photograph of himself. His usual order was a fish-finger sandwich with chips and salad, costing £14.95.

“He said he never wanted to be disturbed, but on one occasion he seemed so upset at not being recognised that he began singing ‘Angels’,” Mr Clarke recalled. He plans to pay all his employees through their notice periods from his own savings.

Perhaps an angel investor will yet come to Mr Clarke’s rescue. For now, the Union Jack bunting that once fluttered outside Polly’s has been taken down — and another distinctive British institution has surrendered its fight for survival.