Each year, anonymous reviewers put restaurants through their paces, awarding coveted chefs’ hats to the country’s leading dining venues in a system often compared with the globally recognised Michelin stars.
The Good Food Guide introduced its chefs’ hat ratings 42 years ago. Its inspectors assess restaurants anonymously, considering the quality of the food, service, value for money and the overall dining experience.
For the 2027 awards, about 160 restaurants across NSW received at least one hat after inspectors spent six months dining discreetly at more than 500 venues.
Every restaurant reviewed by the Guide receives a score out of 20. A score of 15 earns one hat, 16 or 17 earns two, and restaurants scoring between 18 and 20 receive three hats.
Although many restaurants retained their ratings or gained an additional hat, 13 Sydney venues lost their coveted recognition — including one famous for serving the world’s ninth-best burger.
In a surprise result, popular CBD venues The Gidley and Loulou Bistro Martin Place, along with The Star’s Sokyo, were all removed from the one-hat list.
Good Food Guide national restaurant editor Callan Boys told the Good Food Guide that critics are required to remain anonymous during their visits, ensuring the experience mirrors that of an ordinary diner.
Service shortcomings were the leading reason for the demotions, with Callan describing poor hospitality as the “greatest contributing factor to declining scores this year”.
The Gidley, a popular steakhouse beneath Sydney’s CBD, has lost its one-hat rating
The lavish fine-dining steakhouse is celebrated for its acclaimed steaks and burgers
“In one instance, a solo reviewer was mostly ignored in favour of larger tables of men ordering bottles costing three figures,” Callan said.
“Plates were not cleared or refreshed, empty glasses went unfilled and were left on the table, and staff provided little guidance… That restaurant no longer has a hat.”
“We understand the importance of looking after big-spending tables, but we also want to recognise restaurants whose staff are trained to notice a solo diner and think, ‘Right, I’m going to make sure this person eating alone has the best night possible.’”
“That is what genuine hospitality looks like.”
One of the most unexpected demotions went to The Gidley, an opulent fine-dining steakhouse known for its highly regarded steaks and burgers.
In 2024, the restaurant’s cheeseburger was named the ninth-best burger in the world by World’s 101 Best Steak Restaurants and ranked number one in Australia.
Tucked beneath Sydney’s CBD, the venue has become a sought-after dining destination, with bookings often filled weeks ahead.
The restaurant also enforces a strict no-phone policy in its main dining room. Guests are not allowed to photograph their meals, with the rule intended to encourage them to stay present and enjoy the experience.
Sokyo, one of Sydney’s best-known contemporary Japanese restaurants, was also quietly dropped from the 2027 one-hat list.
Sokyo, one of Sydney’s most popular contemporary Japanese restaurants, has been removed from the one-hat list
Loulou Bistro Martin Place is a modern French restaurant known for dishes including steak frites, escargots, beef tartare and duck. However, the bistro appears to have fallen short after losing its one-hat rating
Located inside The Star, the restaurant combines traditional sushi and sashimi techniques with Australian meat and seafood, including Moreton Bay bugs and tuna.
Sokyo opened in 2011 and retained its one-hat rating for most years from 2013 to 2026, making the loss of its 2027 distinction a surprise to many diners.
Loulou Bistro Martin Place is a modern French venue serving popular dishes such as steak frites, escargots, beef tartare and duck.
The restaurant opened in July 2025 and was awarded a one-hat rating soon afterwards.
However, the bistro has been unable to retain that prestigious recognition for 2027.