Cruise Ship Murder Suspect Said He “Snapped” Before Attack, Affidavit Says

A passenger accused of killing a woman aboard the MSC Seascape told FBI investigators he “snapped” during an argument, then beat and strangled...
HomeNewsQuentin Letts Asks: Is Andy Burnham Real—or a ChatGPT Construct?

Quentin Letts Asks: Is Andy Burnham Real—or a ChatGPT Construct?

When Hollywood actresses need to cry on cue, they often place tiny drops of glycerine in their eyes, prompting the body to produce tears. The result is an imitation of emotion designed to persuade the audience.

It now appears that Andy Burnham’s speeches may rely on a similar device. A Mail on Sunday investigation found one of the Prime Minister’s speechwriters asking the artificial-intelligence programme ChatGPT to add “emotive” material to a speech for Mr Burnham.

The aide was seen working on a train travelling from London to north Wales while drinking prosecco. There seems to be plenty of sugar and fizz around Downing Street these days. One wonders whether the bubbles were claimed on expenses.

Either too unmotivated to write the speech personally or too inexperienced to draw on genuine experience, the unnamed aide turned to a chatbot instead. As a B-movie director in Hollywood might once have put it: “Make them cry, darling—we need the box office.”

In one sense, the revelation was almost comic. What a display of incompetence and carelessness from a prime ministerial official. Working at No 10 was once considered a prestigious role for civil servants, reserved for the most capable people, who were expected to show discipline and resilience.

Several Whitehall high-flyers went on to become prominent figures in public life, including Harold Wilson, Douglas Hurd, Chris Patten and George Robertson. They understood that political argument required both intellectual seriousness and authenticity.

Does Andy Burnham have either quality? Or is he partly a creation of ChatGPT? Is “Eyelashes Andy” actually AI Andy?

Consider the speech Mr Burnham delivered at the recent Labour Party conference. He paused theatrically before speaking tearfully about his late father, and the moment was presented as spontaneous—a glimpse of the “real” Andy Burnham.

A scoop in The Mail on Sunday caught one of the Prime Minister's speech writers asking the artificial intelligence program ChatGPT to add 'emotive' content to a Burnham address

A Mail on Sunday investigation found one of the Prime Minister’s speechwriters asking ChatGPT to add “emotive” material to a speech for Andy Burnham

At the beginning of the address, he told the Liverpool audience: “It’s very hard to put into words the emotion I feel standing here before you all.”

Was the task so difficult that he needed artificial intelligence to help him manage it?

The speech repeatedly reached for emotional triggers, touching on his grandmother, working-class aspiration and the claim that “kids” can no longer advance in life because of Brexit and the Conservatives. How much of it was heartfelt? Did he genuinely believe what he was saying?

Now that we know his speechwriters ask artificial intelligence to insert “emotive” passages, should that conference address be viewed differently?

Some Westminster commentators became carried away, describing the speech as the finest contribution to British politics in a generation. I argued that parts of it were so heavily sweetened that they produced something approaching a diabetic reaction.

A generation ago, Westminster contained no shortage of people with first-hand knowledge of hardship. Parliament included men who had worked in coal mines, on North Sea trawlers, in agriculture and in factories. Others had fought—and killed—in wartime.

The modern Commons includes a few former nurses and doctors. But only a small number of today’s MPs appear to have experienced serious adversity, and Mr Burnham is not among them. He grew up in a loving, middle-class family, attended Cambridge and became a Westminster special adviser. Which raises another question: should an Oxford or Cambridge English graduate not be capable of writing his own speeches?

The Left often loads its arguments with emotional appeals about poverty and hardship. It still invokes the Thatcher years as an assault on opportunity, despite the argument that they did more to promote social mobility than decades of socialism.

Like Hollywood directors manufacturing drama, Labour politicians can amplify hardship and polish grievance until it shines. They use that approach to build the case for higher taxes and further welfare spending, while attacking “privilege”—a term that often appears to mean excellence, including through the undermining of independent schools and the arts.

Now we are told that the performance was manufactured: content generated by ChatGPT and used to support an appeal to welfare voters. It is regrettable that a generally likeable Prime Minister appears to have been caught promoting what amounts to poverty theatre for electoral gain.

If these arguments carried genuine force, and if the hardship described truly demanded political action, no aide would need to ask a computer programme for assistance. The words would come naturally, drawn from personal conviction and experience.

British voters would recognise that authenticity, because the speechwriter would be expressing something true.

Artificial intelligence cannot govern a country. Legislation, regulation and political leadership must be grounded in real lives and genuine experience.

And, Mr Burnham, that can come only from the heart.

READ MORE: Half of civil servants at several Whitehall departments admit using AI to save time at work as Andy Burnham faces fresh questions over speechwriter using it to help craft keynote speech