JonBenét Ramsey’s Father Challenges DA Over Family Clearance Report

JonBenét Ramsey’s father is pushing back against reports that the Colorado prosecutor now overseeing his daughter’s cold-case murder would not have cleared the...
HomeUSRussia’s Mega-Rich Oligarchs Are Planning for a Post-Putin Era

Russia’s Mega-Rich Oligarchs Are Planning for a Post-Putin Era

Russia’s wealthiest business figures are quietly contemplating what the country could look like after Vladimir Putin, as growing numbers of billionaire oligarchs reportedly become increasingly uneasy.

Analysts say members of the business elite have begun thinking about succession and are increasingly using the dismissive nickname “Ded” for the 74-year-old president, a Russian term meaning “old man” or “grandfather.”

Many reportedly yearn for a return to the political order of the 1990s, when oligarchs had direct access to officials and could exercise influence with far fewer risks.

Under Putin, however, Russia’s tycoons have been reduced to subordinate figures. Those who challenge the Kremlin can face frozen or confiscated assets—and, in the most extreme cases, the threat of death.

Their fortunes also carry less international power than they once did. Since Putin first became president in 2000, he has shown little willingness to share authority with rival centers of influence.

Outside Russia, meanwhile, many oligarchs have been isolated by Western sanctions imposed after Moscow launched its full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022.

Frustrated by their diminished status and nostalgic for the “wild 1990s,” some are now quietly discussing what a post-Putin Russia might bring.

“They’re treated like low-level criminals. They can’t fly their private jets. Their yachts can’t park in all the best harbours in Europe. It must be very awful and humiliating for them,” Bill Browder, once the largest foreign investor in Russia before being barred from the country in 2005 after campaigning against corruption, told the BBC.

Russian President Vladimir Putin smiles during a press conference at the Russia-Africa Summit, on October 29 in Moscow, Russia

Russian President Vladimir Putin smiles during a press conference at the Russia-Africa Summit in Moscow on October 29

Russian President Vladimir Putin chairs a meeting of big businesses at the Kremlin in Moscow on February 24, 2022

Vladimir Putin leads a meeting with major business figures at the Kremlin in Moscow on February 24, 2022

The 118-metre (387-foot) Motor Yacht A belonging to Russian oligarch Andrey Melnichenko, anchored in the port of Ras al-Khaimah, United Arab Emirates

The 118-metre Motor Yacht A, owned by Russian billionaire Andrey Melnichenko, anchored in Ras al-Khaimah in the United Arab Emirates

For Russia’s super-rich, silence has become one of the clearest signs of Putin’s rule. The Kremlin leader expects absolute loyalty from the country’s most powerful businessmen.

Speaking out can carry devastating consequences. In 2003, oil magnate Mikhail Khodorkovsky—then Russia’s richest man and a backer of opposition groups—accused Putin’s administration of widespread corruption.

Khodorkovsky subsequently spent a decade in prison after being convicted of tax evasion, fraud and embezzlement. He denied the allegations, but his case served as a stark warning to other potential critics.

Just hours after ordering the full-scale invasion of Ukraine, Putin summoned Russia’s richest businessmen to the Kremlin’s Yekaterininsky Hall.

More than 30 tycoons sat along one side of the vast room, many wearing masks because of the Covid pandemic.

A Russian newspaper journalist described the businessmen as “pale and sleep-deprived.” Putin positioned himself across the cavernous hall, leaving a striking distance between the president and the assembled tycoons. As was often the case, he wore no mask.

In typically indirect language, he made clear that he expected their backing for the war.

“I would like to call on you to show understanding of what is going on,” he said, urging them to “work together with the government to find the tools which would support production, the economy, jobs.”

The Kremlin’s video of the meeting showed none of the billionaires responding.

The gathering offered a vivid display of Putin’s authority over Russia’s business elite.

Yet the risks of questioning the president have not entirely erased the oligarchs’ desire for change.

“I can remember seeing oligarchs walking around like they own the place, the most arrogant and self-confident individuals,” Browder said, recalling the years before the war when Russian businessmen were still welcomed at the Davos economic forum.

“And then Putin showed up, and it was just remarkable to see how these supposedly alpha-male-on-steroids individuals turned into absolutely subordinate, almost desperate schoolchildren.”

Arkady Ostrovsky, a senior Kremlin watcher at The Economist who recently spent hours interviewing one of Russia’s richest men, believes a major change is taking place in the way the ultra-wealthy view the country’s future.

There is no immediate sign that Putin is preparing to leave power, nor any public indication that his health is failing. Still, after roughly a quarter-century in the Kremlin, most Russians understand that he will eventually have to depart.

Asked by Reuters last year whether he planned to remain in office until 2036, when his current constitutional term would technically end, Putin replied: “Only God knows if we have enough health.”

If Putin were to die in office or resign, Prime Minister Mikhail Mishustin would initially assume the presidency.

Mishustin, however, has shown no obvious ambition to become president—possibly one reason he was selected for the role.

After that initial transition, several possible futures could emerge.

Some Western Russia analysts hope Putin’s exit could open the way for democracy, with power returned to voters rather than concentrated in one autocrat or a small circle of oligarchs.

That is widely viewed as the least likely outcome, however, because democratic institutions have been badly weakened—and in some cases effectively dismantled—during Putin’s rule.

“Russia is so used to violence, it has grown unaccustomed to standard democratic procedures,” Alexandra Prokopenko, an exiled Russian journalist and analyst, told the BBC.

A second possibility would be the continuation of authoritarian rule and political repression.

Prokopenko argues that such a system would not immediately resemble another fully consolidated strongman dictatorship.

Centralising power takes time, she says. At first, Putin’s successor would probably be weaker, with fewer political and financial resources at his disposal.

The third possibility is a government dominated by a small number of powerful elite families working alongside major business interests—a revival of the oligarchic system associated with the 1990s.

Although the oligarchs’ influence has been sharply restricted since that decade, their vast fortunes mean they are likely to try to reclaim political authority sooner or later.

Some are already “trying to be friends with the right sort of security officials or ministers,” according to Dmitry Nekrasov, a former Kremlin adviser and opposition politician now living in exile.

He told the BBC that taking more decisive action remains “too dangerous” for them.

Russia’s tycoons, Prokopenko said, “would like to return to a time when they were listened to, when they were not stripped of assets and when they understood the rules of the game.”

Smoke rises above the city following an air attack on the oil terminal in Saint Petersburg on October 18, amid the ongoing Russian-Ukrainian conflict

Smoke rises over the city after an air attack on an oil terminal in Saint Petersburg on October 18 amid the continuing Russia-Ukraine conflict

One prominent Russian oligarch of the 1990s was Boris Berezovsky, who fell out with the Kremlin and lived his later years in Britain

Boris Berezovsky, a prominent oligarch of the 1990s, later broke with the Kremlin and spent his final years living in Britain

How the tycoons respond in the coming years will depend heavily on the nature of their wealth.

Those holding substantial liquid assets may feel confident enough to “play political games,” compete for influence and prepare for a post-Putin Russia, Nekrasov said.

Businessmen whose fortunes rely on state contracts or official favour, by contrast, are likely to remain cautious, fearing that a misstep could cost them everything.

Even the language used to describe Putin appears to be changing.

According to Prokopenko, Russia’s wealthy once referred to him as “Nachalnik,” or “boss,” “Perviy,” meaning “first,” or simply by his initials, “VV.” Each suggested a measure of respect or deference.

Increasingly, however, they call him “grandad.”

Some members of the elite are said to want politics to return to everyday life, with less repression, greater freedom of speech and more meaningful competition between parties and candidates.

For now, Prokopenko says, fear prevents them from pushing for those changes in public.

She interviewed one oligarch who kept his phone beneath him throughout their conversation, believing that doing so might make surveillance by the security services more difficult.

“I thought that it’s an absolutely Stalinistic type of fear. It’s absolutely irrational,” she said.

An interview published by The Economist earlier this year offered one of the clearest hints about what some Russian tycoons may want from a post-Putin future.

The decision by Andrey Melnichenko, described as Russia’s eighth-richest man, to speak to the publication was notable. The Economist is based in a country the Kremlin labels unfriendly, and the magazine also published an essay by the billionaire.

Some of Melnichenko’s comments echoed official Kremlin narratives. He described Ukraine as a battleground between Russia and the West and argued that Western governments had ignored Moscow’s security concerns and threatened Russian sovereignty.

But the conversation took a more revealing turn.

Melnichenko did not explicitly demand Putin’s removal. Instead, he argued for changes that would bring an end to Russia’s one-man system of rule.

He also said Russia needed to reconnect more closely with the wider world.

Prokopenko believes the businessman may have been attempting to start a wider public discussion—a “call on rich people like him to start talking.”

Ostrovsky, who conducted the interview, told the BBC that he and Melnichenko held “tense and heated discussions” in “hotels and cafes, mostly drinking coffee, lots of coffee, sometimes smoking.”

The journalist said Melnichenko appeared to be genuinely considering his responses rather than simply delivering polished political messaging.

Most observers believe the interview likely had at least tacit approval from senior authorities. What remains unclear is why the Kremlin would permit such an unusual public call for political transition.

One explanation is that officials wanted to suggest that limited pluralism still exists in Russia.

No other oligarchs publicly rallied behind Melnichenko. Even so, Ostrovsky believes the businessman was expressing concerns shared by a much broader section of the ultra-rich.

Russia's mega-rich are already imagining a future without Vladimir Putin as the country's billionaire oligarchs grow 'restless'

Russia’s wealthiest business figures are quietly imagining a future beyond Vladimir Putin as the country’s billionaire oligarchs grow increasingly uneasy

The Queen K yacht of Russian Oligarch Oleg Dripaska pictured in waters of Mljet island Croatia

The Queen K yacht, linked to Russian oligarch Oleg Deripaska, pictured near Croatia’s Mljet island

Some Russian billionaires hope Putin’s eventual departure could lead to what Ostrovsky calls an “oligarchic republic.”

The collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991 created a powerful new class in Russia: men who exploited the end of communism to amass enormous fortunes and then sought to influence politicians for their own advantage.

They became known as oligarchs, a word derived from the Ancient Greek phrase for “rule by the few.” In 1990s Russia, money could be converted directly into political power.

As the so-called “new Russians” emerged, huge state-owned enterprises were sold or divided up. Those with the right connections became millionaires—and sometimes billionaires—almost overnight.

Corruption was widespread, political favouritism was routine and contract killings were a regular feature of the era.

Their influence began to disappear once Putin consolidated power.

Drawing on decades of reporting, Ostrovsky says many of Russia’s richest citizens now feel trapped by a “sense of complete dead end, which this war has led Russia to… [an] absence of the future.”

Even if the ultra-rich are planning for what comes next, however, few are expected to act openly in the near term.

Browder argues that many oligarchs may be unhappy, but they are unlikely to move against Putin while he remains alive. “They understand that if they were to do anything that would challenge Putin, he would kill them. And Putin is a very paranoid little man.”

Mike Calvey, an American financier who was once a major investor in Moscow, agrees. “What can they do besides just go straight to the prison and lose their assets? It’s easy for people who are sitting in London to say that, ‘why don’t you just all go stand up and go straight to prison?’ That’s really what would happen.”

Russia’s richest businessmen once pulled political strings at the highest levels. After Putin is gone, they will almost certainly try to recover at least some of the influence they lost.

The unresolved question is whether the surviving forces of Putin’s system will allow them to do so.