A prominent film and television lawyer has accused his former Jewish colleagues of discrimination after being dismissed over relationships with junior employees.
Kamir Naghdi was removed from prestigious London law firm Clintons after partners raised concerns that his conduct could damage the business’s reputation, an employment tribunal heard.
Mr Naghdi, who led Clintons’ film and television department, had an affair with a junior lawyer and later breached workplace rules by asking senior partners to improve the employee’s financial package.
He also did not deny allegations that he had been involved in a “sexual relationship” with another employee, according to the tribunal.
The firm ultimately decided to expel Mr Naghdi, who is Iranian. He subsequently claimed that Jewish colleagues had treated him unfairly because he was Christian.
A London Central Employment Tribunal has now rejected his claims of discrimination and harassment.
Mr Naghdi brought the case against C Legal LLP, Clintons LLP and seven Clintons partners. He was himself an equity principal at the firm.
A London Central Employment Tribunal judge rejected lawyer Kamir Naghdi’s claims
The tribunal heard that Mr Naghdi joined Clintons in 2014 and became an equity principal on January 1, 2017.
The judgment stated: “He remained head of the film and TV team at Clintons until the relationship was terminated, and it was not in dispute that he is, or was, an excellent lawyer in his field.”
Tensions began to surface after Mr Naghdi started a relationship with a junior lawyer identified by the tribunal only as the Relevant Employee, or RE.
The exact start of the affair was unclear. However, messages presented to the tribunal showed that in December 2021 RE booked tickets to Cannes for dates when Mr Naghdi was expected to be there and forwarded her booking to him.
RE also told Mr Naghdi that she planned to take two “absolutely stunning” designer dresses on the trip. Mr Naghdi said the exchange reflected their shared interest in fashion, but the tribunal found the message suggested he would enjoy seeing her wear the dresses.
The judgment added that the correspondence confirmed RE would be travelling to Cannes with Mr Naghdi.
Rumours about a relationship between the pair then began circulating within the firm.
Around mid-April 2023, Mr Naghdi approached Andrew Myers, a Jewish partner who was responsible for most management decisions, and said his marriage was breaking down.
Mr Myers, who had heard rumours involving RE, asked whether anyone else was involved.
After Mr Myers warned that a relationship could create difficulties for the firm, Mr Naghdi admitted that he was involved with RE, although he said the relationship had not become physical.
A protocol was prepared to manage the situation. By the time it was finalised in June 2023, however, the relationship between Mr Naghdi and RE, who reported to him, had ended.
Mr Naghdi later emailed two other partners, saying RE was considering leaving and proposing that the firm improve her overall package by paying for training and increasing her expenses allowance.
The tribunal judge found that this amounted to a “clear breach of protocol”.
During a meeting with a partner, Mr Naghdi also acknowledged a relationship with another junior member of staff, referred to as the Former Associate, or FA.
The judge said he was asked twice whether he had been involved in a sexual relationship with FA and, on both occasions, did not deny it.
A further partner warned that clients could react negatively if they became aware of the relationships.
Mr Naghdi was told he would be suspended, but rejected the possibility of a negotiated departure. Through his lawyers, he argued that expelling him would be unlawful.
The tribunal heard that a formal meeting was subsequently held to consider his expulsion. In September 2023, the partners voted unanimously to terminate his membership.
The decision triggered a lengthy legal dispute between Mr Naghdi and his former partners, with the lawyer alleging that he had been discriminated against.
He brought the firm and its partners before the Central London employment tribunal, maintaining that he had done nothing wrong.
His case alleged that someone who was not Jewish or white would not have been permitted to rise through the firm to a position that threatened the authority of those at the top.
He also claimed that Mr Myers had disliked him because he was neither Jewish nor white.
Employment Judge Emma Webster dismissed claims of direct discrimination, harassment related to race or religion and belief, victimisation, and detriment for whistleblowing.
She said Mr Naghdi’s case failed to account for his own conduct and the effect it had on colleagues.
“He cannot accept that his intimate relationship with a junior member of staff, and the way in which he handled that situation, had the very real impact that it did,” she concluded.