An Alabama Democratic judge under renewed scrutiny for past decisions involving violent offenders is challenging a state law that permits defendants accused of certain violent crimes to be held without bail.
Circuit Court Judge David Carpenter described Alabama’s Aniah’s Law as a direct threat to constitutional protections. He argued that defendants should not be detained indefinitely based only on criminal accusations, pointing to the legal presumption of innocence.
In a social media post, Carpenter contrasted the criticism directed at license plate surveillance systems, including Flock cameras, with what he characterized as limited concern over laws expanding pretrial detention.
“Can someone explain to me why the people who are so alarmed that a flock camera might spot their car on a public road, and they call that government overreach, are silent on the fact that voters across the country keep overwhelmingly passing new laws to empower the government to hold you in jail indefinitely on the basis of a charge only,” Carpenter said.

According to Birmingham police, Damien McDaniel, 22, has been linked to more than a dozen killings in the Alabama area since July 2023. Carpenter approved a plea agreement for McDaniel before the alleged 18-fatality shooting spree. (Alabama Department of Corrections / Birmingham Police Department)
“These laws, like Alabama’s Aniah’s Law, are a direct assault on the Constitutional guarantee of the presumption of innocence. But no one is talking about this at all, much less expressing the hysteria associated with having a camera see a license plate,” he said.
Enacted in 2022, Aniah’s Law was expanded this year after Alabama voters approved a constitutional amendment adding more qualifying offenses. The new provisions include attempted murder, soliciting or conspiring to commit murder, and firing a weapon or explosive into an occupied home, building or vehicle.
“We are all one accusation away from being a criminal defendant,” Carpenter wrote in a Facebook post.
Carpenter has drawn criticism for several rulings during his judicial career. The local outlet 1819 News reported that he previously identified himself online as a “far left, liberal, progressive, democratic socialist.”
In April 2023, Carpenter approved a plea agreement involving Damien McDaniel, who had been arrested in 2019 after allegedly shooting two people in a vehicle at age 17, according to 1819 News. After his release, McDaniel allegedly carried out a 14-month shooting spree in Alabama that left 18 people dead and more than 30 injured.

Damien McDaniel, 22, was approved for a plea agreement by Carpenter and later connected to several shootings over a 14-month period. (Birmingham Police Department / WBRC)
The outlet also reported that Carpenter granted bond to Raukeem Cunningham in the 2022 shooting death of a teenage girl. While free on bond, Cunningham was arrested and charged in the fatal shootings of three people at a Bessemer gas station in 2024. His original bond was subsequently revoked.
Reports also say Carpenter dismissed a 2015 rape case against Fredrick Terrenda Hampton in 2019. The dismissal occurred two days before Hampton met Paighton Houston, who later vanished. Houston’s body was discovered buried behind a home after she died from an accidental overdose.

Fredrick Hampton, 50, was sought in connection with Paighton Houston’s disappearance. Houston, shown at left, was last seen leaving a Birmingham, Alabama, bar on Dec. 30. Her body was found two weeks later. (Jefferson County Sheriff’s Office)
Hampton later pleaded guilty to abuse of a corpse in Houston’s death. Carpenter sentenced him to a 20-year split term, with three years to be served in custody, according to the outlet.
Houston’s mother eventually asked Alabama Attorney General Steve Marshall to investigate Carpenter’s decision to release Hampton, whom critics characterized as a repeat sex offender.
While campaigning for judicial office, Carpenter said one of his central aims was to “reform the criminal justice system in Alabama.”
“If elected, I will work to reduce the number of repeat offenders while addressing the expensive problem of prison overcrowding in Alabama,” he said.