Lindsay Clancy has been given a new trial date after prosecutors indicated they plan to pursue first-degree murder charges following the collapse of her initial trial in a hung jury.
The mother of three appeared Monday morning in Plymouth County Superior Court in Massachusetts for a pivotal hearing, days after a judge rejected her last attempts to prevent a retrial.
Although the Plymouth County District Attorney’s Office has not formally confirmed the charges, prosecutor Jennifer Sprague strongly suggested the state would again seek first-degree murder convictions.
“Given what the charges are, it requires a jury trial,” Sprague told the court Monday.
Massachusetts law allows defendants facing second-degree murder or lesser charges to request a bench trial. The state’s position therefore indicates that prosecutors continue to pursue first-degree murder charges.
Judge William Sullivan ultimately set March 29, 2027, as the date for Clancy’s retrial after a tense exchange with prosecutors.
Sprague argued that several murder cases filed long before Clancy’s were still awaiting trial and noted that she already had a 2014 criminal case scheduled for April.
Sullivan pressed the attorneys to choose a date in either March or April, refusing to delay the case further.
Lindsay Clancy will face a retrial for the deaths of her three children on March 29, 2027
Clancy’s first trial involved three first-degree murder charges stemming from the January 2023 deaths of Cora, five, Dawson, three, and Callan, eight months
The timing is especially important because Sullivan is required to retire in June 2027.
Any further postponement could force another judge to take over the case.
The hearing came two months after Clancy’s first trial ended in a mistrial and was expected to resolve whether prosecutors would try her again, as well as determine the timing and possible charges.
So far, Plymouth County District Attorney Tim Cruz’s office has remained guarded about its plans.
The mistrial, combined with the fact that most jurors concluded the state had not proven its case beyond a reasonable doubt, had raised questions about whether prosecutors would move forward.
Clancy, 36, was initially charged with three counts of first-degree murder in connection with the January 24, 2023 deaths of her children: five-year-old Cora, three-year-old Dawson and eight-month-old Callan.
The labor and delivery nurse admitted killing the children but said she was not criminally responsible because she was suffering from postpartum psychosis and depression. Prosecutors alleged that she strangled the children in the basement of the family’s home in the affluent town of Duxbury before attempting suicide by cutting her wrists and neck and jumping from a second-floor window.
Clancy survived the fall but was left paralyzed from the waist down.
Judge William Sullivan selected the retrial date after a tense exchange with prosecutors
Local residents expressed outrage as jurors considered whether Clancy should be convicted
Patrick publicly supported Lindsay while quietly selling the family home and relocating to New York City
At trial, Clancy did not dispute that she had killed her children. Instead, she pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity, maintaining that postpartum psychosis and depression left her unable to understand or control her actions.
Jurors deliberated for 38 hours across seven days but could not agree on a verdict.
Eleven jurors favored finding Clancy not guilty by reason of a lack of criminal responsibility, while one juror believed she should be convicted of murder.
Because the panel could not reach a unanimous decision, Sullivan declared a mistrial on September 4.
Near the end of deliberations, the jury foreperson sent the judge a series of notes accusing the holdout juror, Michael Desronvil, of refusing to apply the legal standard for reasonable doubt.
Several jurors later repeated those allegations in media interviews. Desronvil has denied them, saying he had no reasonable doubt about Clancy’s guilt.
If prosecutors proceed with a second trial, they could bring the original charges again or pursue lesser counts, including second-degree murder or manslaughter.
That choice could significantly affect how the retrial is conducted.
Hours before the killings, Dawson, three, and Cora, five, built a snowman in the family’s yard with their mother
Neighbors told the Daily Mail they believed Clancy was suffering from severe mental illness when she killed Cora, Dawson and Callan, pictured
Massachusetts law requires a jury trial for first-degree murder charges. Defendants facing lesser charges, however, may choose to have a judge decide the case.
At a hearing earlier this month, Sprague declined to reveal the prosecution’s strategy, saying prosecutors were waiting for the judge to rule on several motions before deciding whether to retry Clancy and which charges to pursue.
Sullivan issued those rulings last week, rejecting defense requests to dismiss the case and investigate Desronvil. The decisions cleared the way for a second trial.
Defense lawyer Kevin Reddington argued that the charges should be dismissed on double-jeopardy grounds, claiming the mistrial might have been avoided had Sullivan conducted a more extensive inquiry into the holdout juror.
Reddington also requested an investigation into Desronvil’s juror questionnaire, phone records and 2021 arrest. The defense wanted to determine whether he had been truthful during jury selection and whether he used his phone during deliberations.
Sullivan, who is scheduled for mandatory retirement in June 2027, denied both motions on November 9.
Desronvil welcomed the rulings. According to his attorney, Heather O’Connor, he wants to put the controversy behind him and resume his normal life.
“Does this mean it’s over? Can I go back to living my life?” O’Connor said he asked after learning of the decision.
The judge also rejected a prosecution request for a gag order.
Despite the new trial date, the case could still end in a plea agreement.
Reddington has previously indicated that he would consider a deal, but only if Clancy avoids prison time.