California voters rejected a billionaire tax at the ballot box, but the debate over whether the state’s wealthiest residents should pay more is already moving toward a new chapter.
Dustin Corcoran, chief executive of the California Medical Association, is considering a 2028 ballot initiative that would restructure California’s income tax system, Politico reported. The proposal could set up another high-profile contest involving wealthy taxpayers after voters turned down Proposition 40.
Unlike the defeated measure, Corcoran’s early vision centers on building a wider coalition and directing new revenue toward health care, education and workforce development.
The plan is still being developed, and its organizers have not yet settled on tax rates or estimated revenue. Corcoran maintains, however, that Prop 40’s defeat should not be interpreted as a broad rejection of higher taxes on California’s richest residents.
“Californians’ rejection of Proposition 40 reflects the shortcomings of the measure itself, not a lack of support for addressing wealth inequality and ensuring the wealthiest Californians pay their fair share,” Corcoran told Politico.
Proposition 40 would have imposed a one-time 5% tax on billionaires. The Associated Press called the measure on Nov. 9 after voters rejected it by a margin of 52.8% to 47.2%.
Backers estimated the tax could generate about $100 billion, with much of the money earmarked for health care. Critics countered that the proposal could undermine the economic base and public services it was intended to support.
“Proposition 40 risked California’s economic competitiveness and fiscal stability, as well as the revenue we rely on to fund our top priorities — from education and health care to public safety and infrastructure,” an opposition group told the Los Angeles Times.
The state’s search for additional revenue could now lead to multiple tax proposals in 2028, creating a potentially bitter fight between organizations that agree California needs more funding but differ sharply over the best way to raise it.
Corcoran told Politico that he is speaking with possible allies in the health care, education and labor sectors while criticizing the coalition strategy used by Prop 40 supporters.
His concept would focus on changing California’s existing income tax structure, potentially through revisions to the state’s tax brackets. He said other options are also under consideration as the campaign explores the details and seeks broader backing.
The distinction could be significant: An income-tax plan would apply to earnings, while Proposition 40 sought to tax billionaire wealth. Still, the labor organization that championed the failed initiative has no intention of abandoning the issue.
Dave Regan, president of Service Employees International Union-United Healthcare Workers West, said the union would pursue another measure if lawmakers do not identify new funding to meet rising costs.
“That’s not a hypothetical,” Regan told reporters. “That is our plan.”
Regan also rejected Corcoran’s assessment that Proposition 40 failed to assemble a sufficiently broad coalition.
Suzanne Jimenez, Regan’s chief of staff, cited support from dozens of labor and community groups, including the California Nurses Association and the California Federation of Labor Unions.
She argued that Prop 40’s opponents had not presented a realistic alternative to replacing an estimated $100 billion in federal health care cuts.
Gov. Gavin Newsom opposed the measure, warning that taxing billionaire wealth could encourage affluent residents and technology entrepreneurs to leave California.
The campaign against Prop 40 also received substantial financial support from Google co-founder Sergey Brin, former Google CEO Eric Schmidt and Palantir co-founder Peter Thiel.
Voters added another obstacle to future wealth-tax efforts by approving Proposition 42, which prohibits new taxes on assets.
Corcoran told Politico that any proposal extending beyond income-tax changes could require language to repeal or modify that new restriction.
For now, organizations that favor raising more state revenue are continuing to weigh their choices rather than committing to a specific plan.
Jodi Hicks, CEO of Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California, said her organization opposed Prop 40 and is not ready to endorse a 2028 proposal. She told Politico that discussions have included the possibility of a wealth tax, but no final position has been reached.
No replacement measure has been completed, yet the next California tax battle is already beginning to take shape. Proposition 40 may be over, but its defeat could prove to be the opening round in a larger fight over how much the state’s wealthiest residents should contribute.