A mother has been cleared after a six-year legal ordeal over the death of her baby daughter, following accusations that she pressed the infant’s face into a mattress and suffocated her.
Former Coast Guard petty officer Katie Richard, 30, became the primary suspect after her five-month-old daughter, Scarlett, was found dead in her crib in April 2020.
At her first trial, prosecutors argued that Richard had killed the baby by pushing her face into the crib mattress. Her defense team maintained that Scarlett may instead have died from sudden infant death syndrome, commonly known as SIDS.
After two trials, two years in military custody and an acquittal earlier this year, Richard—who was stationed in Kodiak, Alaska—is now free.
She told The Washington Post that she discovered Scarlett dead in her crib after leaving to buy coffee while her then-husband, Gustavo ‘Gus’ Flores Guerra, stayed at home.
“My heart dropped. I couldn’t move, I couldn’t speak,” she said. “I was just looking at her, and then I started getting closer, and I was just screaming: ‘Why does she look like that? Why does she look like that?’”
Richard said she and her husband rushed Scarlett to the nearest emergency room, but the baby had already turned blue and medical staff were unable to revive her.
“[There was] this primal pain that I’ve never felt in my entire life,” Richard said. “It literally feels like a piece of my heart was ripped out of my chest and thrown away.”
Katie Richard, 30, was the primary suspect in the death of her five-month-old daughter, Scarlett
Scarlett died without warning in April 2020. Her parents rushed her to a nearby hospital, but doctors could not save her
In the weeks and months after Scarlett’s death, military investigators examined the case and questioned Richard for what she said amounted to as many as 18 hours.
The interrogation culminated in a session lasting about an hour, conducted two months after Scarlett died.
Richard said she told investigators that she “might have” pushed her baby’s face into the mattress while putting her down to sleep.
That recording was played at her first trial, which ended with her conviction and imprisonment.
After she was sentenced in 2022, Richard was transferred to the Navy brig in Chesapeake, Virginia. She spent her first month alone in a cell, inconsolable and barely eating or drinking.
She was later moved to a Navy brig in Miramar, California. There, she tried to establish a semblance of normality by volunteering and attending Bible studies.
Yet she was devastated by the belief that fellow inmates considered her guilty of killing her own child. “It literally felt like a loss of my own identity because I knew the truth,” she said. “I knew myself. I knew I didn’t do that, but everybody around me, 24/7, was looking at me like I did.”
During the first trial, Richard’s lawyers argued that the military had failed to preserve Scarlett’s clothing and bib—items they said could have helped support the possibility of SIDS.
The Washington Post reported that a medical review from the hospital where Scarlett died also pointed toward SIDS. One doctor wrote: “I have no suspicion of abuse. Mother and father were understandably devastated.”
In 2024, two years into her six-year sentence, a military appeals court overturned Richard’s conviction.
The court ruled that the manslaughter charge, which had been brought alongside allegations of first-degree murder and obstruction of justice, was legally insufficient.
According to the ruling, Richard was accused of committing manslaughter through asphyxia, but the charge did not identify the specific physical act she had allegedly carried out.
Richard was released two months after the appellate ruling. She then sought back pay for the time she had spent imprisoned and worked to prevent the case from going to trial again.
Those efforts were unsuccessful. In 2025, the Coast Guard charged her again, this time with a single count of involuntary manslaughter.
Richard appealed, arguing that the new prosecution violated the Fifth Amendment’s protection against double jeopardy.
The court rejected her petition, finding that her constitutional argument had no merit.
Her second trial therefore proceeded at Coast Guard Base Portsmouth in Virginia and lasted two months.
In April, the former petty officer was acquitted of manslaughter. In September, she was awarded $168,000 in back pay, before taxes, for the time she spent in prison.
Now divorced from her former husband and living in Hawaii, Richard says she wants to move beyond the ordeal.
She has been accepted into a master’s program in public administration and is drawing on her Coast Guard experience in a new role as a crew member and safety diver aboard a tour boat.
Even so, she continues to have nightmares about driving Scarlett to the hospital and about her time behind bars.
“I’ve been dealing with this for six years, just about half of my entire time in the Coast Guard,” she said. “So it’s been very long, very unnecessary, and now I’m trying to finally catch up—to be able to grieve properly now.
“I can never get my daughter back. I can never get the years back that they took from me.”
A spokesperson for the US Coast Guard told the Mail: “The Coast Guard retried YN2 Kathleen Richard after her conviction for involuntary manslaughter was set aside on appeal. The appellate court specifically authorized a rehearing of the case. YN2 Richard’s challenge to the second trial on double jeopardy grounds was dismissed by the appellate court in Richard v. United States, which found the retrial lawful.
“The case was referred to court-martial and tried by certified special trial counsel, specialized military prosecutors assigned to the Coast Guard’s Office of the Chief Prosecutor. As in all courts-martial, the Coast Guard strives to ensure that prosecution decisions are made rationally and fairly, based on the objective merits of each case, and respects the results of the trial process.”
Addressing the investigation, the spokesperson added: “The death of a child is a profound tragedy. The Coast Guard Investigative Service is the federal law enforcement and criminal investigative arm of the United States Coast Guard and is required to investigate all deaths within its jurisdiction.
“CGIS special agents are independent, accredited federal law enforcement professionals trained to conduct thorough, objective and fact-based investigations. The interview was presented in open court, and the Coast Guard respects the findings of the court-martial panel.”
The Daily Mail has contacted the US Coast Guard for comment.