Mother and Daughter Killed in Attack by Grizzly Bear and Three Cubs

DNA evidence has confirmed that a female grizzly bear and her three cubs killed a Canadian mother and daughter during a walk on a...
HomeUSTyler Robinson’s Defense Seeks to Halt Bullet-Fragment Testing in Charlie Kirk Assassination...

Tyler Robinson’s Defense Seeks to Halt Bullet-Fragment Testing in Charlie Kirk Assassination Case

Attorneys for Tyler Robinson, who is accused of killing Charlie Kirk, are asking a Utah judge to suspend additional ballistics testing. Prosecutors are seeking to determine whether bullet fragments recovered during Kirk’s autopsy can be conclusively tied to the rifle believed to have been used in the shooting — a step some experts consider unnecessary and prosecutors acknowledge is not essential to their case.

The Utah County Attorney’s Office has urged the judge to reject the defense request. Prosecutors maintain that the proposed testing will not consume the evidence or prevent Robinson’s experts from examining it afterward. They also argue that they have stronger evidence to present at trial.

“There is no reason to believe the bullet fragments contain exculpatory evidence,” Deputy Utah County Attorney Ryan McBride wrote in an opposition to the defense motion. “To the contrary, all the evidence points to the inculpatory value of the fragments.”

Charlie Kirk's alleged killer, Tyler Robinson in court in Utah

Tyler Robinson, accused of fatally shooting Charlie Kirk, listens during a preliminary hearing at the Fourth District Courthouse in Provo, Utah, on Thursday, July 9, 2026. (Spenser Heaps/AP via Pool)

According to McBride, Robinson has allegedly acknowledged the shooting. Three unspent cartridges found in the rifle were consistent with the round fired at Kirk. The recovered fragments were also consistent with the suspected weapon, although investigators have not conclusively matched them to it. Police additionally found video evidence and a Dremel tool that prosecutors say are consistent with the etchings discovered on brass casings recovered from the rifle at the scene.

The proposed examination, known as virtual comparison microscopy, or VCM, would not destroy the fragments but could physically alter or damage them, according to court filings. Investigators may fold back the fragments’ “petals” to search for rifling marks on the surface beneath them. A small section could be cleaned, while lead fragments might be scraped or otherwise altered. There is also a possibility that pieces could break away during the process.

Evidence in the Charlie Kirk murder case

Bullet fragments are displayed on a screen during a preliminary hearing for Tyler Robinson, accused of fatally shooting Charlie Kirk, at the Fourth District Courthouse in Provo, Utah, on Thursday, July 9, 2026. (Spenser Heaps/AP via Pool)

Robinson’s defense team wants the VCM examination delayed until its experts can inspect and photograph the evidence. Alternatively, the lawyers are seeking permission for a defense specialist to observe the testing in person or through a video recording. The FBI has declined to allow that, citing concerns that include contamination and national security.

The defense contends that earlier testing by the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives, or ATF, already damaged the evidence and that another examination could cause additional harm.

Expert witness testifies in the Charlie Kirk murder case

Samantha Karner, a firearm and tool mark examiner with the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives, holds a bullet model while testifying during a preliminary hearing for Tyler Robinson, accused of fatally shooting Charlie Kirk, at the Fourth District Courthouse in Provo, Utah, on Thursday, July 9, 2026.  (Spenser Heaps/AP via Pool)

“The ATF couldn’t conclusively connect the bullet fragment to the recovered rifle, but it couldn’t rule out the rifle either,” said Jason Pack, a retired FBI supervisory agent who has followed the case. “That’s an important distinction, and it helps explain why prosecutors want the FBI to take another look.”

Pack said VCM is more sophisticated than the traditional practice of examining fragments under a microscope. However, he cautioned that even advanced technology may not produce a definitive connection between the fragments and the suspected murder weapon.

“If the markings are too damaged or simply aren’t there anymore, even the best technology can’t bring them back,” Pack told News Media.

Robinson is accused of shooting Kirk at Utah Valley University during a Turning Point USA speaking event on Sept. 10, 2025. Prosecutors say a bullet jacket fragment and four lead fragments were recovered from Kirk’s body during the autopsy.

Evidence in the Charlie Kirk murder case

An image showing ammunition, including a casing engraved with the words “TEST SHOT,” is displayed during a preliminary hearing for Tyler Robinson, accused of fatally shooting Charlie Kirk, at the Fourth District Courthouse in Provo, Utah, on Thursday, July 9, 2026. (Spenser Heaps/AP via Pool)

“If the bullet fragment is again altered to the point where no independent comparison is possible, then the degree of prejudice to the defendant is severe,” Robinson’s attorneys told the court. “The defense will be unable to independently verify conclusions, cross-examination will be unfairly limited, and the jury will hear unchallengeable expert testimony.”

Bernard Zapor, a former ATF special agent in charge and a faculty associate at Arizona State University, said the defense concerns could be overstated. He said the fragments were thoroughly documented during the ATF’s initial examination, and that photographs, data and images have been made available to the defense through discovery. If additional testing damages the fragments, Zapor said, the effect may be limited because the initial examination was inconclusive — a result he described as common in shootings involving weapons of similar caliber.

charlie kirk at uvu before shooting, facing the crowd

Charlie Kirk speaks at Utah Valley University on Sept. 10, 2025, in Orem, Utah. Kirk, the founder of Turning Point USA, was appearing at his “American Comeback Tour” when he was shot in the neck and killed. (Trent Nelson/The Salt Lake Tribune/Getty Images)

“This is all distracting from the purpose of getting information to the jury so they can come to a conclusion, one way or the other,” Zapor told News Media. “This case is solid. You don’t want to do anything to disrupt it.”

Robinson’s attorneys have previously told the court they plan to challenge the ATF’s findings and testing methods.

During the earlier examination, ATF examiner Samantha Karner cleaned the jacket fragment, photographed it and peeled back the “petals” to inspect groove impressions. She determined that the fragment belonged to the .30-caliber class but could not definitively connect it to the suspected murder weapon: Robinson’s grandfather’s .30-06 Mauser rifle.

“Given the limited detail that Ms. Karner observed, she could not include or exclude the fragment as having been fired from the recovered rifle,” prosecutors wrote. “She testified that there was ‘no further testing that [she] could do’ to try to reach a conclusive result…However, she noted ‘the possibility of using a 3D system to visualize the individual characteristics on the bullet,’ to obtain more conclusive results.”

People run after Charlie Kirk was shot at UVU

People run after shots were fired during Charlie Kirk’s appearance at Utah Valley University on Sept. 10, 2025, in Orem, Utah. Kirk, the founder of Turning Point USA, was speaking at his “American Comeback Tour” when he was shot in the neck and killed. (Trent Nelson/The Salt Lake Tribune/Getty Images)

That analysis would require the fragments to be sent to the FBI for VCM testing.

“This analysis is non-destructive and uses 3D technology to capture multiple scans of the object,” prosecutors wrote. “The scan data will be preserved and provided to the defense for their own analysis.”

Prosecutors said analysts may nevertheless need to clean the fragments or fold back warped metal, known as “petals,” to expose the surface that made contact with the rifle when the bullet was fired.

Tyler Robinson, charged with killing Charlie Kirk appears in court

Tyler Robinson, accused of murdering Charlie Kirk, appears during a hearing in Fourth District Court in Provo, Utah, on Thursday, Dec. 11, 2025. (Rick Egan/The Salt Lake Tribune via Pool)

Court filings show that prosecutors are also seeking metallurgical testing on the bullet jacket fragment and at least one lead fragment. That process may require cleaning a small area before the material is examined with an X-ray.

“The FBI is also proposing separate testing to compare the metal in the recovered bullet fragments with ammunition seized during the investigation,” Pack said. “That could provide additional information, although it wouldn’t conclusively identify the firearm.”

Prosecutors also want an examiner to disassemble one of the unfired .30-06 cartridges recovered from Robinson’s home after his arrest so it can be compared with the other evidence.

Robinson’s attorneys have entered not guilty pleas on his behalf to all charges. If he is convicted of aggravated murder, the top charge, he could face the death penalty.