The Trump administration has urged Nature Medicine to examine whether former senior US health officials Dr. Anthony Fauci and Francis Collins helped write a widely cited paper that rejected the theory that COVID-19 escaped from a Chinese laboratory.
In a letter obtained by The Post, National Institutes of Health Director Dr. Jay Bhattacharya called on the journal to launch a “formal, independent investigation” into alleged ghostwriting and “unacknowledged substantive contributions” to the study.
The Daily Telegraph first reported on Bhattacharya’s letter.
Published in March 2020, the paper, “The Proximal Origin of SARS-CoV-2,” argued that the virus most likely emerged through natural transmission from animals to humans rather than through a laboratory leak.
Documents gathered by congressional investigators indicate that the manuscript was drafted four days after Fauci, who at the time led the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, and Collins, then the NIH director, participated in a conference call with the scientists later listed as its authors.
Bhattacharya contends that Fauci and Collins should have been credited as co-authors. He also asked the journal to consider retracting the study if it cannot conduct an investigation or if any resulting correction fails to address the concerns.
The NIH director’s letter states that Fauci and Collins received a draft of the paper on Feb. 4, 2020, three days after the call. In a March 6 email, credited author Kristian Andersen referred to a subsequent version of “Proximal Origin” and thanked Fauci, Collins and British scientist Jeremy Farrar for their “advice and leadership.”
On Feb. 4, the day the draft was shared with Fauci and Collins, Farrar told the two US officials that he was evenly divided—“50-50”—over whether the virus originated in a laboratory. Another author, University of Sydney researcher Edward Holmes, said he viewed the possibility as “60-40 lab.”
Still, other members of the research team pushed back against assigning responsibility to Chinese officials for the outbreak, even if any release had been accidental.
“Given the s–tshow that would happen if anyone serious accused the Chinese of even accidental release,” University of Edinburgh scientist Dr. Andrew Rambaut wrote in a Feb. 2, 2020, Slack message to Andersen, Holmes and co-author Dr. Robert Garry, “my feeling is we should say that given there is no evidence of a specifically engineered virus, we cannot possibly distinguish between natural evolution and escape so we are content with ascribing it to natural process.”
Andersen replied, “Yup, I totally agree that that’s a very reasonable conclusion,” while adding that he disliked the injection of politics into science but believed it was impossible to avoid under the circumstances.
Dutch virologist Dr. Ron Fouchier, who joined the conference call but was not named as an author of “Proximal Origin,” likewise wrote that any claim the virus had been engineered and released—whether deliberately or by accident—would require exceptionally strong evidence.
“It is good that this possibility was discussed in detail with a team of experts,” Fouchier wrote. “However, further debate about such accusations would unnecessarily distract top researchers from their active duties and do unnecessary harm to science in general and science in China in particular.”
A July 2023 report from the Republican-led House Select Subcommittee on the Coronavirus Pandemic said Nature Medicine had initially come close to rejecting the paper because it did not sufficiently rule out the lab-leak explanation.
“The possibility must be considered as a serious scientific theory, which is what we do, and not dismissed out of hand as another ‘conspiracy’ theory,” Andersen wrote to a journal editor on Feb. 20, 2020. He added that the researchers wished they could reach a firmer conclusion, but said the available data did not allow it.
The FBI and the Energy Department have since assessed, with low confidence, that COVID-19 may have leaked from a laboratory in Wuhan, China, the city where the first known cases were identified in late 2019.
Andersen has maintained that Fauci and Collins had no role in writing the paper. However, he previously testified that Fauci spoke with him by phone on Jan. 31, 2020, and “specifically suggested considering writing a peer-reviewed publication” about the origins of COVID-19.
Emails obtained by Republican members of the subcommittee also indicate that Fauci proposed changes to the manuscript through Farrar.