Andrew Humiston, the teenager accused of killing his parents and three younger siblings at their $1.4 million lakeside home two years ago, has been pictured for the first time.
The 17-year-old was publicly identified as the murder suspect this week after a judge ruled that he should be prosecuted in adult court.
Humiston will remain in juvenile detention until he turns 18. He will then stand trial in connection with the fatal shooting of nearly his entire immediate family at their Washington state home, allegedly using his father’s Glock handgun.
Dressed in beige with his hair tied back in a bun, Humiston pleaded not guilty Tuesday afternoon in King County Superior Court to five counts of murder and one count of attempted murder.
The teenager remained stony-faced during the brief hearing. He is accused of killing his parents, electrical engineer Mark, 43, and nurse Sarah, 42, as well as his siblings Katheryn, seven, Joshua, nine, and Benjamin, 13.
All five victims were found dead at the family’s luxury lakeside home in Fall City, a leafy town about 30 miles from Seattle, on October 21, 2024.
Humiston’s 11-year-old sister, the family’s fourth child, was also shot in the neck and arm. She survived and ran to a neighbor’s home for help.
Prosecutors allege that Humiston, who was 15 when the killings occurred, attempted to frame his younger brother Benjamin by placing the gun in his hand and claiming the deaths were part of a murder-suicide plot.
Andrew Humiston, 17, has been pictured for the first time since his arrest over the alleged killings of his parents and three younger siblings at their $1.4 million lakeside home in October 2024
Humiston’s mother, Sarah, was a registered nurse, while his father, Mark, worked as an electrical engineer. The couple were deeply religious and homeschooled their five children
The family of seven lived in an idyllic $1.4 million lakeside property in Fall City, Washington
Detectives said forensic evidence, including the direction of blood spatter, indicated that Benjamin had not shot himself and that the crime scene had been staged.
According to prosecutors, Humiston showered, changed his clothes and used his father’s cellphone to call 911 after the killings.
Mark and Sarah were described as extremely religious and imposed a tightly controlled lifestyle on their five children, including restrictions on who they could befriend and a decision to homeschool them.
Police documents say the couple were suspicious of the government and medical professionals, particularly in relation to Covid-19 vaccination.
‘Initial reports indicate the home was abusive, tightly controlled, and dominated by extreme religious beliefs,’ court documents state.
Defense attorney Amy Parker told the court that Humiston’s mother physically abused the children and withheld food, while warning them that God would send them to Hell if they disobeyed her.
‘The psychological abuse was even more intense,’ Parker said.
‘Sarah (Humiston) would wake the children at random times during the night and accuse them of cheating, even though they had not.’
Humiston wore beige clothing and his hair in a bun as he pleaded not guilty Tuesday at King County Superior Court to five murder charges and one count of attempted murder
Electrical engineer Mark, 43, and nurse Sarah, 42, were found with multiple gunshot wounds at their home after the October 21, 2024, killings, according to court documents
The children and their father are shown during happier times beside the lake near their home
Court documents previously obtained by the Daily Mail state that Mark had suffered four gunshot wounds, while Sarah was found with two bullet wounds to her head.
An old family photograph obtained by the Daily Mail shows all five children enjoying happier times on the lake with their father beside the home where they had lived since moving from Texas to Washington in 2019.
Other photographs show Humiston, whom his attorney described as a keen fisherman and mountain biker, riding a bicycle mounted on a surfboard.
Several neighbors said the family had appeared to be the picture of happiness.
Soccer coach Rhea Robertson, who had mentored one of the children, described the couple as ‘dedicated’ parents during a vigil reported by KOMO News in 2024.
She said: ‘Dad worked so hard, and mom was the most dedicated, loyal mother you could ask for.’
The Humistons’ home sits on the outskirts of Fall City in a wooded area overlooking Lake Alice, a 32-acre freshwater lake stocked with rainbow trout and largemouth bass.
The family reported lumber theft soon after moving into the property in 2019, prompting Mark to install security cameras around the home.
Police said they had no record of being called to the property since then, and that none of the family members had previously been in trouble with the law.