Progressive New York lawmakers accused the Metropolitan Transportation Authority’s fare-enforcement units of “criminalizing” riders, even as fare evasion costs the transit agency roughly $1 billion in lost revenue each year.
“New Yorkers deserve reliable service and affordability, not criminalization,” Queens socialist Assemblyman-elect Brian Romero said Wednesday during the MTA’s monthly board meeting. Recent allegations of violence involving EAGLE team workers dominated the discussion.
“Do not restart it — end it,” Romero said, referring to the team’s current suspension. “I cannot overstate the fear these enforcement teams create.”
Romero spoke a little more than a month after four EAGLE team employees were recorded removing middle school dean Kyle Taylor from a Brooklyn bus at about 6 a.m. on Oct. 6. The workers confronted and physically handled him over a $3 fare they believed he had failed to pay.
Taylor had paid the fare. The incident triggered widespread public anger, prompting the MTA to suspend the EAGLE team while it reviews the unit’s role and conduct.
That criticism was evident at Wednesday’s meeting, where Bronx Councilmember Pierina Sanchez and Queens Councilmember Tiffany Caban, both Democrats, joined calls to permanently disband the team.
“EAGLE teams cannot be the response,” Sanchez said. “Videos of riders being dragged from buses and slammed to the ground are horrifying.”
Brooklyn activist Rev. Kevin McCall also condemned the unit, saying it “shouldn’t even be called the EAGLE teams because there’s nothing eagle or heroic about them.”
The EAGLE team was created to combat fare evasion, and was deployed to monitor bus payments in 2024 — the same year fare dodgers cost the MTA an estimated $1 billion.
Bus fare evasion accounted for approximately $568 million of that loss, making it one of the largest sources of missing revenue.
Recovering that money could go a long way toward addressing the MTA’s projected $900 million budget shortfall expected by 2030.
Still, the team’s early results have been limited. Fare evasion declined by only about 4% during its first year of operation.
The unit faced additional scrutiny Wednesday when Taylor, who was injured during the confrontation, told the board that no MTA representative had contacted him during the agency’s investigation.
“No one has called me. No one has said anything,” said Taylor, who is suing the MTA for $25 million in damages. “It’s a shame that a person who works hard like me wakes up every morning at 5 to catch the bus and go through that process.”
MTA Chairman and CEO Janno Lieber said he spoke with Taylor before the meeting after learning that he was scheduled to address the board.
“What I said to him was pretty straightforward: No. 1, I’m really disappointed that you got injured by people who work for the MTA,” Lieber said. He added that he had instructed staff to suspend and fire the employees involved in the alleged assault.