Mayor Zohran Mamdani appeared visibly unsettled Wednesday when questioned about his controversial Oct. 7 anniversary message, then defended his decision to describe Israel’s military campaign in Gaza as an “ongoing genocide.”
Reporter Andrew Ross Sorkin raised the issue during an onstage interview at The New York Times’ DealBook conference. Mamdani was asked about a statement marking the third anniversary of Hamas’ deadly attack on Israel, a post that devoted less than a quarter of its focus to the approximately 1,100 people killed in the 2023 terrorist assault and drew swift condemnation.
“The suffering did not begin nor end that day. It instead continued through the Israeli government’s devastating, ongoing genocide in Gaza,” Mamdani wrote, citing Hamas figures while highlighting Palestinian casualties from the war launched after the attack.
Sorkin pointed out that numerous Jewish leaders said the wording had made Jewish New Yorkers feel less safe. He asked Mamdani whether, amid rising antisemitic hate crimes in New York, he believed he had an added responsibility to choose his words carefully.
Mamdani responded that Sorkin’s account “doesn’t cover the entirety of the day” and sought to emphasize his concern for New York’s large Jewish community.
He cited his attendance at a memorial for the victims of Hamas’ attack, where he was loudly booed by anti-Israel protesters, before offering a halting defense of his position.
“And I say this to say that my politics is one that believes that there has to be room to mourn everyone,” Hizzoner said, adding that he was proud to serve as mayor of the nation’s largest Jewish city.
Sorkin then asked whether Mamdani should have used his Oct. 7 statement to unequivocally condemn the terrorist attack and waited until the following day to criticize Israel. The question prompted appeals from members of the audience.
Mamdani reddened as he considered the question and struggled through his answer, asserting that the attack had been used “as a justification for all that followed it.”
“When the Israeli government is conducting a genocide of Palestinians, oftentimes the defense that will be given, no matter what day that it’s asked about, will be the relationship to October 7,” he said.
When Sorkin pressed him on whether he understood why people might object to his handling of the anniversary, Mamdani again redirected the discussion toward Palestinian rights.
“Whenever I’m asked about why do you support Palestinian freedom or Palestinian rights, I speak about the importance of extending these same values to everyone,” Hizzoner said.
“And that is who I am. That’s who I’ll always be.”
Mamdani’s statement drew immediate criticism last month.
“What he is trying to do is hijack the only day we have for the victims and survivors. He’s trying to hijack the day to talk about attacking Israel,” Israeli Ambassador to the United Nations Danny Danon told The Post. “It’s like on 9/11 you talked about victims and al-Qaeda terrorists.”
“It’s basically taking the only day we have for victims and trying to attack Israel with propaganda,” Danon added.