Pennsylvania State University is working to distance itself from a controversial lecture hosted by its Jewish Studies Program that was titled, “Do we need to decolonize Holocaust museums?”
The university faced intense online criticism Tuesday after the program promoted the event, which was scheduled for later that evening. Critics accused organizers of applying an academic or social justice framework to the Holocaust in a way they considered offensive and inappropriate.
The promotional post was later removed from social media. In comments beneath the advertisement, alumni and other users questioned the decision to hold the event, describing it as “absolutely disgusting,” “vile,” “abhorrent” and “profoundly disturbing.”
As the backlash grew, Penn State acknowledged that the event had caused significant pain within the university community.
“The university condemns all forms of antisemitism and is committed to making our Jewish students, faculty and staff feel safe, welcome and supported at Penn State,” the school said in a statement to The Post Wednesday.
The university added that a speaker’s appearance on campus “in no way constitutes an endorsement by the University of the views being espoused.”
“We understand the concerns regarding the external speaker’s use of the word ‘decolonization’ in the event’s title, and we recognize how hurtful it was to many in our community,” the statement continued.
According to the event flyer, the lecture by Concordia University professor Erica Lehrer was intended to examine “the potential value of decolonial museum theories and practices for Holocaust museums to renew and expand their social justice mandates.” The terminology, however, quickly triggered widespread outrage.
“The very suggestion that Holocaust museums need to be ‘decolonized’ is deeply offensive,” one Instagram user wrote in response to the post.
“Watching a Jewish Studies department promote a lecture on ‘decolonizing Holocaust museums’ is beyond comprehension,” another commenter said.
Andrew Goretsky, regional director of the Anti-Defamation League’s Philadelphia office, urged caution and precision in discussions about the Holocaust.
“This week, Penn State’s Jewish Studies Program hosted a scholar, herself the daughter and granddaughter of Holocaust survivors, to examine how museums care for objects taken from Jewish families and what they owe survivors and descendants,” Goretsky said in a statement to The Post.
Goretsky said those were “important questions,” but acknowledged that the word “decolonize” carries meanings outside academic settings that caused “real pain for many in our community.”
“We hope this moment encourages all of us to be thoughtful about how language lands with the public, especially when it comes to Holocaust memory,” he said.
Tommaso M. Milani, director of Penn State’s Jewish Studies Program, said the term “decolonization” was used in connection with ethical questions surrounding museum collections, including who is represented, whose voices are absent and how institutions should address historical injustices tied to the acquisition and display of artifacts.
“This presentation in particular examined questions regarding how museums care for objects taken from Jewish individuals and communities and the responsibilities institutions have when pieces on display were never returned to survivors or their descendants when their descendants asked for them,” Milani said.
He added that neither the lecture nor the ensuing discussion minimized the Holocaust, the experiences of survivors or the importance of Holocaust museums and memorials.
Lehrer, responding to the criticism, said she delivered the lecture from the perspective of someone whose mother’s family heirlooms were donated to a Holocaust museum, according to a statement to The Jerusalem Post.
“Most of the questions I am exploring relate to how Holocaust museums may learn from Indigenous innovations regarding more flexible ways to care for objects that keeps them connected to families and communities rather than only under glass, as evidence of crimes,” she said.
Lehrer, who previously served as a fellow at the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum, also said the lecture considered how groups of Holocaust victims, including Roma people, have sometimes been portrayed through stereotypes that fail to reflect their full humanity.
She said those concerns parallel questions raised by scholars examining the way museums present other subjects and communities.
The Post has contacted Lehrer twice seeking additional comment.