HomeCrimeSusan Smith: The False Kidnapping Story Behind Her Sons’ Murders

Susan Smith: The False Kidnapping Story Behind Her Sons’ Murders

When Susan Smith’s two young sons were recovered from a South Carolina lake, one of the boys’ small hands was reportedly pressed against the car’s window.

The devastating detail, reported by PBS, offers a haunting glimpse into the final moments of Michael, 3, and 14-month-old Alex. Their mother had allowed her Mazda to roll down the boat ramp at John D. Long Lake while the children remained strapped inside.

More than 30 years after the 1994 killings, Susan is set to appear before a parole board on Nov. 19 in hopes of being released. Her former husband, David Smith, the boys’ father, plans to attend and argue against her freedom.

“It’s been hard, hard,” David told CNN, reflecting on the decades since Michael and Alex died. “If I have a choice, I’d want her to stay in prison until she dies.”

Here is a look at the case that shocked the nation:

Susan Smith Said a Black Man Had Kidnapped Her Sons

On the night of Oct. 25, 1994, the then-23-year-old Susan told police that she had been driving near Union, South Carolina, when she encountered a terrifying situation.

According to CNN, she claimed that a Black man wearing a knit cap approached her while she was stopped at a traffic light, pulled a gun and stole her car—with her two sons inside.

The alleged abduction triggered fear across Union County, while Susan made emotional public appeals for her children to be returned safely.

“I would like to say to whoever has my children that they please, I mean please, bring them home to us where they belong,” she pleaded, according to WYFF. “Our lives have been torn apart by this tragic event.”

A wide-ranging manhunt followed. Susan even worked with a police sketch artist to create an image of the man she said had taken her children, and the sketch was circulated by news organizations nationwide.

As the investigation progressed, however, detectives began finding contradictions in her account.

On Nov. 3, 1994, Susan appeared on NBC’s Today show. She told viewers that protecting her children was “only a natural instinct” for a mother and said the most painful part of the ordeal was not knowing whether they had enough to survive.

Later that same day, she admitted that she had killed her sons.

What Happened to Susan Smith’s Sons Michael and Alex?

Susan, who was separated from David at the time, told investigators that she collected old wedding photographs, placed Michael and Alex in the car and drove toward the lake, according to WSOC-TV.

She said she then released the vehicle down the boat ramp, with both children still inside. A reconstruction later shown to jurors found that the car took approximately six minutes to sink.

According to PBS, Michael and Alex were discovered upside down inside the submerged vehicle, still secured in their seats. A forensic pathologist concluded that both boys had died by drowning, as reported by Time.

Kevin Brackett, the current solicitor for South Carolina’s 16th Circuit who assisted with the prosecution, told WSOC-TV that he still vividly recalls the vehicle being brought out of the lake after Susan confessed.

“Every single time I pass the entrance to the boat ramp, I think about that night,” he said. “And you know, I mean it was horrifying.”

Why Did Susan Smith Kill Her 2 Sons?

At Susan’s 1995 murder trial, prosecutors said she had killed her children after the man she was dating ended their relationship because he did not want to raise children.

“It was selfish,” Brackett said. “She really just … she wanted to shed her old life and hopefully move into this new life with this man. So she really didn’t care about the boys at all.”

Her defense team presented a different explanation. According to Oxygen’s Dateline: Secrets Uncovered, attorneys argued that Susan had planned to die by suicide at the lake but escaped from the car before it entered the water. They also cited alleged sexual abuse by her stepfather and years of untreated mental health struggles.

A jury found Susan guilty of two counts of murder. She received two life sentences and became eligible to seek parole after 30 years.

Where is Susan Smith Now?

Susan remains imprisoned at Leath Correctional Facility in Greenwood County, South Carolina, according to The State. She works there as a wardkeeper, handling various cleaning duties.

Susan first became eligible for parole in 2024, but the board rejected her initial request for release.

“I want to say how very sorry I am,” Susan told the board through tears, according to Dateline. “I know that what I did was horrible and I would give anything if I could go back and change it. I love Michael and Alex with all my heart.”

She is scheduled to make another request for release on Nov. 19.

David Smith and lead prosecutor Tommy Pope are expected to appear at the hearing and oppose her parole.

“I want them to look at it … through my eyes,” David told CNN. “It’s important for me to remind the parole board that it may be 32 years, but for me it’s still like yesterday. Thirty-two years hasn’t changed the heartache.”