The brother of a renowned California surfer murdered in Costa Rica said he never stopped believing investigators would identify those responsible, even as authorities spent nine months piecing together a case that initially appeared to involve a fatal home invasion.
Kurt Van Dyke, 66, was discovered dead in February inside his apartment in Hone Creek, Cahuita, Limón. His former girlfriend, identified by local authorities as Arroyo, was arrested in connection with the killing on Nov. 12.
During an interview with Fox News on Thursday, Kurt’s brother, Peter Van Dyke, described him as “a very giving person, very kind, very generous.”
Video obtained by News Media from Costa Rica’s Judicial Investigation Agency shows authorities conducting two raids tied to the investigation into Kurt Van Dyke’s death.

Kurt Van Dyke, a celebrated California surfer found murdered inside his Costa Rican home in February 2026, is pictured with a puppy. Authorities have arrested two suspects, including his former girlfriend, in connection with his death. (Facebook/Kurt Van Dyke)
Peter Van Dyke said he did not know his brother was in a relationship with Arroyo.
“I never met his girlfriend. I only know his former wife, and I still communicate with her. His children come and stay with me all the time,” Peter Van Dyke said. “I really wasn’t aware that he was dating her.”
Peter said he remained confident throughout the investigation that those responsible would eventually be arrested and prosecuted. He added that his nephew had stayed in contact with Costa Rican authorities since the killing.
“They assured [Kurt’s son] that they had a pretty solid case. They just needed to build it, and it had to go through the judicial system before they could make the arrests. They had to solidify the case,” Peter Van Dyke said.

Kurt Van Dyke, 66, was reportedly killed at his Costa Rican home over the weekend. (Facebook/ Kurt Van Dyke)
Timeline of Kurt Van Dyke’s murder:
Feb. 14, 2026:
Kurt Van Dyke was found dead in his apartment in Hone Creek, Cahuita, Limón, Costa Rica. Authorities said he had suffered stab wounds and showed signs of asphyxiation. His body was discovered beneath a bed, wrapped in a sheet, with multiple stab wounds.
NEXT UP: Avengers: Doomsday Recap: Everything You Need to Know Before Watching the Marvel Sequel
Feb. 14, 2026:
Van Dyke’s former girlfriend reportedly told police that armed intruders had entered the apartment, restrained her and taken valuable belongings.
Feb. 16-17, 2026:
Costa Rican investigators began treating the case as an apparent home invasion.
Nov. 12, 2026:
Costa Rica’s Judicial Investigation Agency arrested Van Dyke’s former girlfriend, Arroyo, 31, and alleged that she helped armed attackers enter the apartment on Feb. 14, according to La Nación. Investigators also arrested a 34-year-old man identified as Gutiérrez.
Costa Rican police believe Arroyo and Gutiérrez organized a robbery targeting Van Dyke and sought the bank card codes connected to the hotel he owned in the country.

Van Dyke was a prominent surfer in Santa Cruz, California, where he was born, and within Costa Rica’s surfing community. (Facebook/ Kurt Van Dyke)
During the Nov. 12 raids, police confiscated a cellphone, a vehicle allegedly used in the crime and other evidence considered relevant to the case.
Investigators believe Arroyo’s car theft was staged to resemble a robbery, a detail authorities say strengthens their theory that she helped plan the attack.
Arroyo and Gutiérrez were turned over to Costa Rica’s Public Ministry, which will determine whether charges should be filed.
CONTINUE READING: Meet Peter Dager: The Actor Behind Santi in ‘Stick’ on Apple TV+