When Anthony Albanese joined the leaders’ photograph at the APEC summit in Shenzhen this week, Xi Jinping stood between Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin.
Putin could scarcely have asked for a more favourable image. Almost five years after invading Ukraine, he was in China sharing the stage with the American president.
Xi’s position was even stronger. Both men had travelled to him, and each was seeking something only the Chinese president could deliver.
Putin needs China to continue buying Russian oil and supplying the machinery and components that keep Russian industry operating. Trump wants Beijing’s help in persuading Putin to accept a settlement over Ukraine. He could also benefit from Chinese influence in Tehran, where months of American and Israeli military action have weakened the regime but left it capable of threatening the global economy.
That puts Xi in an enviable position. Whenever a Western leader asks him to pressure Moscow or Tehran, it reinforces the logic of maintaining commercial ties with both. If Beijing had joined the campaign to isolate those regimes, the American president would now have far less reason to seek Xi’s assistance.
China’s influence, in other words, is soaring.
Consider what happened last month, when Washington had an opportunity to impose a heavy cost on China for purchasing Russian oil. Congress had authorised Trump to levy tariffs of up to 100 per cent on goods from the biggest buyers of Russian oil and gas. But only days before the measures were due to begin, Trump signed a waiver. Chinese refiners could continue purchasing Russian crude without facing the threatened American penalties. Trump defended the reversal as being in the national interest.
He had a point. Removing Russian oil from the global market while conflict in the Middle East was already disrupting supplies risked driving petrol prices even higher in the United States. And who did Congress think would ultimately pay the tariff on Chinese goods entering American ports? The same voters already weary of war.
Xi did not need to offer Trump anything to avoid the proposed tariffs. The economic consequences of enforcing them negotiated on his behalf.
Prime Minister Anthony Albanese (back, right) with Russian President Vladimir Putin, China’s President Xi Jinping and US President Donald Trump
Putin understands that Europe can control what crosses its own borders, while Xi decides what moves across China’s border with Russia. Oil flows one way, providing Moscow with the revenue needed to continue the war. Machine tools and electronic components travel the other way, helping Russian factories produce weapons.
European sanctions undoubtedly impose costs on Putin. But the extent of that burden depends to a significant degree on decisions made in Beijing.
Ukrainian forces have exposed the limits of Russian power more clearly than any Western government. When Russian troops advanced on Kyiv in February 2022, who would have predicted that, almost five years later, Ukrainians would be using domestically produced weapons to strike Russian oil refineries?
Western assistance gave Ukraine the capacity to defend itself. Persuading Putin to accept peace on terms Ukrainians could live with has proved far more difficult, which helps explain Trump’s desire to speak with Xi.
MORE STORY: Magnitude 5 Earthquake Strikes California as Seismic Swarm Intensifies
China now sits at the centre of what happens next in two major conflicts.
Iran presents Xi with a different set of calculations. China wants Iranian oil, but it also needs tankers carrying oil from other Gulf producers to reach Chinese ports. Keeping Tehran economically afloat serves Beijing’s interests. Allowing Tehran to decide when the rest of the Gulf can trade with China is a different proposition.
This gives Trump at least one point of leverage. Both presidents want oil to continue moving freely through the Strait of Hormuz. Trump’s difficulty is that Xi can pursue that goal without supporting America’s broader war aims.
Beijing could urge Tehran to allow tankers to pass while continuing to trade with a regime Washington has spent months trying to pressure into submission. Even a limited Chinese diplomatic success would give Xi an opportunity to ask what America’s military campaign had ultimately achieved.
Who could alter that balance? India has the population, economic potential and motivation to challenge Beijing’s ambitions. Its disputed border with China gives New Delhi a more immediate interest in limiting Xi’s power than almost any Western capital can claim. Yet when Indian and Chinese refiners compete to buy Russian crude, Putin gains two customers where the West would prefer he had none.
We encourage India to act like a great power, then express surprise when it makes its own decisions about where to source its oil.
Trump, Xi and Putin at the table… Ukraine and Iran were no doubt on the menu
In the optimistic years after the Cold War, Western policymakers assumed that drawing China further into the global economy would give them greater influence over Beijing. Instead, it helped accelerate the rise of the Middle Kingdom.
Australians have already received a practical lesson in Chinese power. When Beijing wanted to punish Canberra, it imposed trade restrictions on about $20 billion worth of Australian exports. South Australian winemakers lost access to customers they had spent years cultivating. Meanwhile, iron ore required by Chinese steel mills continued to leave the Pilbara. Beijing knew exactly which Australian exports it could afford to sacrifice.
For decades, Australians have worried about the possibility that our most important ally and largest trading partner might one day force us to choose between them. The Shenzhen summit raises another possibility, one we have spent far less time considering.
What happens if Washington and Beijing decide that agreement suits them, leaving Australia outside the room?
Trump was willing to sit down with Putin and Xi to discuss Ukraine’s future without Ukraine represented at the table. Albo was left standing in the background.
If an American president and a Chinese president ever reach an agreement about the future of our region, what makes us confident Australia would have a say?
As the saying goes, if you are not at the table, you are on the menu.