Thomas Markle Sr has been branded a “lying, no-good coward” by his son after a court ruled that he is fit to stand trial despite claims that he suffers from dementia.
A court-ordered psychiatric assessment concluded on Thursday that Markle, 82, is mentally capable of participating in proceedings over a serious child sexual abuse material charge following his arrest in Florida.
The report said Markle appeared to exaggerate his memory problems in an effort to avoid prosecution.
That conclusion came despite Markle telling an evaluator that he had only two children, even though he is the father of Thomas Markle Jr, Samantha Markle and Meghan Markle, the Duchess of Sussex.
Thomas Markle Jr responded on Thursday night by describing his father as a “liar” and a “coward”.
Markle Jr was the first to tell media and police in the Philippines that he had allegedly discovered child sexual abuse images among his father’s belongings.
He said his sister Samantha had told him their father was recovering well after having his left leg amputated in May.
Markle Jr claimed his father only began saying he had dementia after allegations involving child abuse emerged.
Thomas Markle Jr (pictured) called his father a “lying, no-good coward” after a court ruled he was fit to stand trial on a charge involving child sexual abuse images
Thomas Markle, 82, the estranged father of the Duchess of Sussex, was arrested by the FBI in Florida over allegations that he possessed child sexual abuse material
Mr Markle Jr told the Sun: “This report proves he’s a lying, no-good coward. He left the Philippines in May after a blood clot led to the amputation of his left leg.
“I called Samantha and asked how he was doing. She said he was in good health and had recovered really well. She said he was mentally sharp, making jokes and laughing.
“Then, when I found this stash of horrific child abuse images in his home, he suddenly had dementia. It never rang true.”
The former Hollywood lighting director was declared mentally competent in a 15-page report examining whether he understood the nature and consequences of the case following his arrest at a Florida care facility on November 6.
Markle was brought into federal court in Tampa on Thursday in handcuffs and an orange jumpsuit marked “Pinellas County Jail” as the assessment was submitted as evidence. Some reports have said he is experiencing cognitive difficulties.
Federal Judge Lindsay Griffin told the court there was a “reasonable degree of medical certainty” that Markle had enough understanding of the charges against him.
His attorney, Mary Claire Wolf, said, “We are not contesting the conclusion of the doctor,” although that position could change if the case is transferred to California, where the charge originated.
The lawyer added: “I reviewed the report with Mr Markle. I suspect he would want to contest it, but I do not.”
The Duchess of Sussex previously said she was “deeply distressed” by allegations involving her father in the Philippines. She has not commented on the latest developments in Mexico
Among the material recovered was an undated image of Markle lying on a bed with his arm around a young Asian woman; both appear fully clothed. Other images allegedly show her alone and naked
Judge Griffin said she would admit the psychiatric report into evidence.
In a previous two-page order, the judge said Markle’s failure to recall details during his first federal appearance in Tampa on November 6 had raised concerns about whether he was competent to face prosecution.
However, Markle was described as a “malingerer” in the 15-page evaluation prepared by Amie Gerodimos, an assistant professor of psychiatry and behavioral neurosciences at the University of South Florida.
Gerodimos wrote that Markle had a “neurocognitive disorder”, but concluded that when he repeatedly said he did not understand or remember the allegations, he was malingering.
“The essential feature of malingering is the production of false or grossly exaggerated physical or psychological problems, motivated by external incentives,” she wrote.
Gerodimos added: “He understood the seriousness of the nature of the charges. It is my clinical opinion, with reasonable medical certainty, that Mr Markle is malingering because he is exaggerating a lack of recall or understanding of the charges in order to avoid criminal prosecution.”
She noted that no psychological test can definitively establish whether a person is pretending to have symptoms.
CONTINUE READING: Home Alone Director Chris Columbus Kept in Dark on Culkin Sequel
Nevertheless, she wrote: “It is my opinion that Mr Markle was exaggerating deficits in remembering the allegation.”
The report said he was able to recall the allegation during their discussion and use that information to develop a strategy that benefited him.
Gerodimos said Markle was being treated for recurrent moderate major depressive disorder with bupropion, an antidepressant.
“However, at the time of my evaluation, Mr Markle reported no previous or current symptoms of depression,” she wrote. “Mr Markle reported no current psychiatric symptoms other than memory loss.
“Near the end of the interview, after discussing the allegation against him, I asked again and he said, ‘I don’t think so. I am getting depression now!’ He reported no thoughts of suicide.
“I inquired about a second daughter because I knew he had been staying at his elder daughter Samantha Markle’s home earlier that week. He said to me, ‘I don’t think so. I have two kids. I think Meghan is Samantha. I only have one daughter and one son.’”
“I think my son is crucifying me at this moment,” he said of Thomas Markle Jr, who reported to Philippine police that he had allegedly found child sexual abuse images among his father’s possessions.
According to Gerodimos, Markle also said of his son: “I always poke him because he never went past the eighth grade in school. He did not accomplish anything. I mocked him.”
The report said Markle claimed to have “memory lapses” while discussing his Hollywood career and said he could not remember the name of his first wife, Roslyn Loveless.
He told the evaluator that he had used marijuana “on a couple of occasions, never routine” and had tried cocaine once.
Markle said he saw a therapist for “forgetfulness” and repeatedly stated that his age—82—explained his memory problems.
However, he could not recall the therapist’s name and appeared to become confused about the identities of the Duchess of Sussex and Samantha, at one point saying that “his sister Meghan” might be able to help.
Despite those issues, the professor concluded: “It is my opinion, with reasonable medical certainty, that Mr Markle is competent to stand trial.”
Meghan’s father remains in federal custody in Florida after being charged with possessing child sexual abuse material allegedly recovered from two storage units he rented in Los Angeles.
The wheelchair-using former lighting director was arrested by the FBI on November 6 at Maravida Senior Living in Lakeland, a facility that provides care for older people with Alzheimer’s disease and dementia.
Markle moved to Florida in May for rehabilitation after having his leg amputated in Cebu, Philippines, where he had lived since January 2025. He later moved into the Maravida facility, reportedly because of concerns about his cognitive health.
At his first court appearance, held hours after his arrest, Judge Griffin agreed that he could remain under home detention at the care facility. Staff, however, declined to accept him back.
He was subsequently released into the care of his eldest daughter, Samantha, 61, who lives in a nearby trailer with her partner, Mark Phillips, 68.
Markle was returned to court on November 10 after allegedly tampering with his ankle monitor. The judge described the living arrangement as “untenable” and ordered that he be jailed.
The elderly amputee was taken to Pinellas County Jail in Clearwater, Florida, where he is listed as prisoner number 05907-513. He denies being a pedophile and has dismissed claims that he stored child sexual abuse material as “sick lies.”
Markle faces one federal charge of possessing child sexual abuse material. The offense carries a statutory maximum sentence of 20 years in prison.
FBI agents seized 78 items from the Los Angeles storage units, which Markle had rented for almost two decades. The material allegedly included slides, negatives and books containing child sexual abuse images.
According to the Justice Department, two images showed an adult man—identified by a witness as Markle—with a nude prepubescent girl. A third allegedly depicted a prepubescent girl inside a room that appeared to be in a hotel operated by a chain in the Philippines.
The affidavit also refers to photographs that allegedly show Markle with children in various states of undress.
READ MORE: Meghan Markle’s estranged father Thomas is charged after Daily Mail reported him to the FBI and a new Los Angeles storage unit allegedly containing images of him abusing girls is discovered
READ MORE: Philippine police investigating Thomas Markle found more than 7,000 alleged child abuse images of girls and boys of Asian, Latin and European descent, some as young as 10