Jess Wilson is on course to end 12 years of Labor rule when Victorians vote next Saturday. Pauline Hanson’s One Nation, meanwhile, may fail to secure a single lower house seat. That, however, should not necessarily be read as a defeat for the minor party.
One of the first challenges facing Victoria’s next Liberal premier could be working out what Pauline Hanson wants. The numbers suggest One Nation may hold the balance of power in the Victorian upper house once counting is complete.
That is the picture emerging from internal Liberal polling seen over the past week. The survey places One Nation between zero and six lower house seats, although expectations have shifted sharply towards the lower end of that range. In the upper house, by contrast, the polling forecasts Hanson’s party winning between 10 and 12 of the 40 available seats.
Such a result would probably give One Nation decisive influence over the chamber. It would be a remarkable outcome for a party whose political obituary may be being drafted over the summer if next weekend unfolds as expected.
Before looking at that possibility, it is worth considering what appears likely to happen in what was once Labor’s electoral stronghold. In the 27 years since Steve Bracks defeated Jeff Kennett in 1999, the Victorian Coalition has held government for just four years.
Even that brief period was hardly a triumph. Ted Baillieu failed to complete his term as premier, while Denis Napthine never secured a term of his own. Together, they made the case for a change of government almost as quickly as Victorian voters had installed them.
Wilson has given voters who remember that record a reason to reconsider the Liberals. She is young, polished and largely free of the political baggage accumulated by many of her colleagues over the years. If the Victorian Liberal Party wanted a fresh public face, it would be difficult to find a stronger option.
Whether the figures standing just beyond that carefully presented image are equally prepared for government is another question. Wilson’s team does not necessarily project great depth or quality.
Jess Wilson is on course to end 12 years of Labor government when Victorians vote next Saturday
Consider the marginal seat of Ripon. As I reported last week, Nationals candidate Jo Armstrong is distributing how-to-vote cards urging supporters to place Liberal candidate Megan Read second — exactly what a Coalition partner would ordinarily be expected to do.
Yet a senior Liberal official privately named two preferred winners in Ripon: Read and One Nation’s Donna Buxton. The Nationals candidate whom the Liberals hope to govern alongside was dismissed with the blunt assessment: “Not bloody Jo.” Charming.
A senior Liberal MP also sought an urgent “favour” to prevent One Nation from placing Armstrong ahead of Read. Imagine being the Nationals leader negotiating ministerial positions with the Liberals after the election while knowing what some of your supposed partners truly think of you.
That hardly sounds like a healthy Coalition relationship.
Then there is former Liberal leader John Pesutto. His party has been fighting in court to keep secret the identities of the guarantors behind the loan that helped preserve his political career after he lost a defamation case brought by fellow Liberal MP Moira Deeming.
The Daily Mail understands further legal efforts have been under way to delay disclosure until after polling day. If Pesutto returns to the frontbench, Wilson could soon be forced to answer questions about who helped keep one of her ministers in parliament.
YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE: Ruby Franke’s Daughter Urges Parole Board to Keep Utah Parenting Influencer in Prison, Calling Her a “Monster”
None of those problems appears likely to save Labor next Saturday. Last week’s tracking poll placed the Coalition on 31 per cent, One Nation on 24 per cent, Labor on 22 per cent and the Greens on 15 per cent. The decisive factor will be the flow of preferences.
Take a seat where the Liberals are ahead and One Nation is in second place. If Labor is eliminated, even after receiving Greens preferences, its ballot papers must still be distributed. In Victoria, voters are required to number every square.
“Reports of Pauline’s political death may have been greatly exaggerated yet again,” writes Peter van Onselen. Pauline Hanson is pictured
The reverse scenario also matters. In traditionally safe Labor seats where the party would normally expect to finish first with Greens preferences, the Liberals could overtake One Nation and ensure those third-party votes ultimately elect one of the major parties. That could happen even if One Nation records its highest-ever primary vote in Victoria.
In an inner-city electorate, the Greens could also prevail with the help of Labor preferences.
That is why a strong primary vote for One Nation may not translate into many — or any — lower house victories. In the upper house, however, the same vote could be worth considerably more.
Five Legislative Council members are elected from each of Victoria’s eight regions. A substantial vote spread across the state could give One Nation genuine influence in the chamber, even if it cannot secure a majority after preferences in a single lower house electorate.
To borrow from Mark Twain, reports of Pauline Hanson’s political death may once again prove greatly exaggerated.
The Daily Mail political editor says Pauline Hanson should not be written off just yet
There will be another test soon enough when New South Wales votes in March. It has traditionally been a more favourable state for Hanson than Victoria, while optional preferencing in NSW currently works to One Nation’s advantage.
If journalists begin declaring Hanson finished after the Victorian election, watch them recast the story as a political comeback when March arrives next year. In reality, both conclusions would be based on a false narrative.
The more important question for One Nation is where it stands at the next federal election. That is the level of government Hanson herself serves in, alongside prominent figures including Barnaby Joyce.
At the federal level, voters must number every square. If Angus Taylor can lift his performance while Anthony Albanese’s support continues to slide, Victoria may offer an indication of how the Coalition could eliminate One Nation in lower house contests. Taylor’s problem is that, despite Albanese’s unpopularity, Labor’s federal vote is unlikely to fall as far as it has in Victoria.
Where the Coalition drops into third place, its own preferences could help elect Hanson’s candidates. That scenario is very much in play across regional electorates, as well as in traditionally safe Labor seats in Melbourne’s outer suburbs.