Accused killer Erin Patterson.
Share and Follow

Disagree. Disagree. Disagree.

Those were Erin Patterson’s responses to the prosecution’s final three questions in her murder trial.

Crown prosecutor Nanette Rogers SC rounded out her marathon cross-examination on Thursday with three suggestions: that Patterson deliberately sourced death cap mushrooms in 2023, deliberately included them in the beef Wellington she served her former in-laws and did so intending to kill them.

Accused killer Erin Patterson.
Accused killer Erin Patterson. (Anita Lester)

Patterson has pleaded not guilty to the murders of her estranged husband Simon’s parents, Don and Gail Patterson, 70, his aunt Heather Wilkinson, 66, and the attempted murder of Heather’s husband Ian.

She denies deliberately poisoning her lunch guests on July 29, 2023 when she served them meals that included death cap mushrooms.

Patterson was accused of more lies on her eighth and final day in the witness box at the Supreme Court in Morwell in regional Victoria.

The 50-year-old was asked about her evidence that she dehydrated dried mushrooms she had bought from an Asian grocer before adding them to the beef Wellingtons.

She agreed she never said this to anyone at the time and didn’t mention putting the fungi into the dehydrator when she earlier admitted adding them to the lunch.

“I suggest this is another lie you made up on the spot,” Rogers said, accusing Patterson of hedging her bets to try to make it sound like there were multiple possible sources for the death cap mushrooms.

“Incorrect,” the accused killer responded.

The prosecutor also suggested Patterson lied about taking diarrhoea treatment following the lunch after the 50-year-old earlier claimed one reason she went to hospital was because she thought they would have something stronger.

Crown Prosecutor Nanette Rogers SC . (Photo by Jason South) (Nine)

Patterson agreed she did not tell medical staff at the hospital she had taken the medication, maintaining no one asked.

“If you were looking for something stronger, you would’ve told medical staff you had already taken Imodium and it didn’t work,” Rogers said.

“I don’t agree,” Patterson responded.

She was also questioned about her evidence that she had to stop by the side of a road and go to the toilet in the bushes while driving her son to a flying lesson, something the boy denied during his testimony.

“I suggest he did not recall you stopping by the bushes on the side of the road because it did not happen … I suggest this is another lie you told the jury about how you managed the trip to Tyabb,” Rogers said.

“Disagree,” Patterson said.

The mother-of-two said she had served her children reheated beef Wellington with the mushroom and pastry scraped off while she had a bowl of cereal the night after the deadly lunch.

But Rogers referred to her children’s evidence, in which they suggested their mother had the same meal of leftovers the night after the fatal lunch.

Erin Patterson's defence barrister Colin Mandy SC.
Erin Patterson’s defence barrister Colin Mandy SC. (Justin McManus)

One of Patterson’s children said she “ate the same as us”, but Patterson told the court they were incorrect and denied eating the leftover food.

She also denied that she “deliberately concealed” one of her phones, referred to at the trial as phone A, from police when they searched her house.

Patterson said she switched from phone A to another, referred to as phone B, because the former was “not cutting it anymore”.

But the prosecution pointed to records that showed regular use from a SIM card in phone A until days after the mushroom lunch.

Patterson said she conducted a factory reset of phone B because she wanted to use it and that was the phone she gave police.

“I suggest to you that there was nothing wrong with phone A and this is another lie,” Dr Rogers said.

“Disagree,” Patterson responded.

Under defence barrister Colin Mandy SC’s re-examination, Patterson became emotional as she talked about her daughter’s ballet lessons and son’s flying lesson.

With all evidence in the trial concluded, Justice Christopher Beale told jurors about discussions they could expect before dismissing them for the day.

LISTEN NOW: The Mushroom Trial Say Grace is the latest podcast from Nine and The Age. Join journalists Penelope Liersch and Erin Pearson as they take listeners inside the case that’s grabbed global headlines. You can listen on Apple here and Spotify here.
Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Graham Richardson arriving  at Hotel Realm for the Labor Fundraiser.

Remembering Labor Icon Graham Richardson: A Legacy of Influence and Leadership at 76

Graham Richardson, a significant figure in Australian politics as a former Labor…
Former chief of staff at NAB Rosemary Rogers has been jailed for a maximum of eight years.

Ex-NAB Employee Sentenced to Eight Years for $5.5 Million Fraud Scheme

A former bank executive who embezzled funds to support a lavish lifestyle,…

Brace for Impact: Severe Storms and Torrential Rain Set to Disrupt Australian Weekend Plans

Australians on the east coast are being warned to expect a wet…

Sussan Ley Responds to Criticism: ‘Ask Her’ About Leadership Dispute

Opposition leader Sussan Ley has responded after a Liberal senator said she…
Sophia Begg is one of Australia's most recognisable young influencers and co-founder of fashion brand All For Mimi.

Young Entrepreneur Highlights Common Pitfalls Job Seekers Should Avoid

Exclusive Insight: Launching today, nine.com.au introduces a captivating series spotlighting some of…

Palestinian Militant Group Releases Body of Israeli Hostage Amid Rising Tensions

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s office said a coffin carrying the remains…
James Bond film director Lee Tamahori who also worked with Alec Baldwin and Melanie Griffith dies at 75 after long illness

Renowned James Bond Director Lee Tamahori Passes Away at 75: A Legacy in Film with Stars Alec Baldwin and Melanie Griffith

Renowned film director Lee Tamahori has passed away at his residence in…
Carly McNamara was "saddened" when Human Too by The 1975 vanished from streaming platforms this week.

Examine Your Collection: This CD’s Value Has Significantly Increased

Exclusive: Carly McNamara was taken aback when she logged into Spotify, only…