Share and Follow
Consumer advocacy group Choice has unveiled its 20th annual Shonky Awards list of products, services and companies it deems dishonest or unreliable.
Among those in the ‘winners’ circle, the Commonwealth Bank earned the dubious honour for the fourth time, making it “the most awarded Australian company in Shonkys history”, according to Choice.
The bank was included this year for “refusing to refund millions of low-income customers $270 million in fees that never should’ve been charged”, Choice CEO Ashley de Silva said.

CommBank has found itself in hot water after it was revealed that 2.2 million of its customers were collectively overcharged by $270 million in unjust fees, according to de Silva. This substantial figure highlights a significant issue within the banking sector’s treatment of its clientele.

At the time, the Commonwealth Bank said it would not refund the $270 million, arguing that fees had been disclosed to customers and charged in accordance with terms and conditions.
In a statement to SBS News responding to the Shonkys listing, a Commonwealth spokesperson said the bank had committed to “making goodwill adjustments where appropriate to customers who have incurred unusually high fees”.
“For eligible concession customers, we have paused certain fees, including overdraw and monthly account-keeping fees,” the spokesperson said.

The bank made $25 million in goodwill payments to approximately 87,000 First Nations concession customer accounts following a 2024 ASIC report, they said.

An ‘unsafe haven’

Other recipients this year included the online shopping platform Temu, with Choice citing poor customer service, difficulty securing refunds, and being “an unsafe haven for dodgy sales tactics and fast fashion”.
But de Silva said safety was “perhaps the biggest issue” at Temu.

In 2024, Choice randomly tested 15 products from Temu, all of which failed at least one requirement of Australian regulations designed to keep children safe.

A silhouetted hand holding a phone with the Temu app open, in front of an orange wall that has the Temu logo on it.

While Temu is popular for its wide range of products and low prices, it’s been criticised for poor customer service, among other issues. Source: Getty / Bloomberg / Raul Ariano

All 15 products were removed from sale. But Temu has “continued to make headlines for safety issues”, de Silva said, referencing an incident last year where a Queensland child suffered burns after a hoodie purchased from Temu she was wearing went up in flames when “rogue sparks” from a firepit landed on it.

“The ACCC found the hoodie wasn’t compliant with mandatory safety standards, as it had no fire warning label of any sort. Four months later, Temu recalled the hoodie, but the damage had already been done.”
In a statement to SBS News, Temu said consumer safety was a “top priority” for the company, and while it did not manufacture products, it took “platform responsibility seriously” and acted swiftly to remove listings when there were safety concerns.

A spokesperson for the platform said items were “promptly removed” after safety issues were raised by Choice, and it had further strengthened oversight.

The spokesperson said the company had invested significantly in measures such as vetting sellers, pre-listing checks and monitoring by both automated systems and human review.

Energy retailers’ ‘sneaky’ tactics

Energy retailers were also in Choice’s sights this year, receiving a Shonky Award for “sneaky pricing tactics designed to confuse customers”.
De Silva said the group had seen a number of retailers roll out new, cheaper plans with the exact same name as existing plans — leading many consumers to believe they were already on the best plan.
“CHOICE research estimated energy customers could have collectively saved about $65 million per year if retailers had made it clear that the new plan with the same name was cheaper than the existing one,” de Silva said.

The Australian Energy Council, the peak body for energy retailers, said retailers’ marketing practices and how they described their offers were heavily regulated by the Australian Energy Regulator (AER) and monitored by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC).

“Retailers are required to maintain compliance with these regulations, which have been recently amended to make it easier for customers to compare offers,” a spokesperson told SBS News.
“The Better Bills guidelines, overseen by the AER, determine what wording retailers must use on bills when notifying customers of the best offer available,” they said.
“The ACCC had been aware of this issue for some time, and retailers had been in lengthy discussions with the AER on changing the wording on bills to ensure it was easier for customers to understand.
The AER subsequently allowed changes to the ‘better offer’ message earlier this year, so when a better offer that has the same name as a current plan is used, a statement will also appear on the bill to clarify and explain it.”

The spokesperson said the energy council had not seen any modelling to support Choice’s $65 million figure or an explanation of how the group arrived at it.

A man in a blue shirt, a man in a white shirt and black blazer, and a woman in a red top. They are standing in front of several white column that have displays.

It’s the 20th year Choice has run its Shonky Awards. Source: Supplied

Private health insurer HCF also received a Shonky Award this year for what Choice described as a “price rise in disguise”.

The group said HCF had closed its Premium Gold policy to new members and instead released a “nearly identical” policy called Optimal Gold with a 34.6 per cent price increase.

It argued HCF had done this to bypass the government approval process for health insurance premium increases on existing policies.

In a statement to SBS News, HCF said: “To help keep Gold-level protection accessible, equitable, and sustainable, HCF updated its product and pricing structure for new Gold policy sales in February 2025.”
“These changes apply only to new sales and are in full compliance with industry standards and regulations.”

The insurer added that challenges with the sustainability of Gold-level coverage reflected broader pressures within the sectors, driven by “higher costs from complex claims, particularly in mental health”.

A plug-in heater that ‘doesn’t plug in’

While most of Choice’s scorn this year was for companies and services, it did highlight one individual product: a mini electric heater called the Handy Heater Turbo 800.
De Silva said it was a “plug-in heater that doesn’t plug in”, as it wouldn’t fit directly into an Australian power point without an adaptor.
“The travel adaptor that came with the heater also wasn’t compliant, leaving pins exposed when plugged into an Australian power point.
“Other safety issues included a lack of any kind of thermal protection device, insecure wiring, and a heating element directly mounted onto thermoplastic — a material that becomes soft when heated.”
Choice’s testing also revealed the heater didn’t produce “anywhere near as much heat as its advertising suggests”, de Silva said.
SBS News sought comment from the distributor of the Handy Heater Turbo 800 but did not hear back before publication.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Foodies abuzz as the Michelin Guide arrives in Oceania for the very first time: 'The anonymous inspectors are already on the ground'

Michelin Guide Debuts in Oceania: Anonymous Inspectors Set to Transform Culinary Scene

The Michelin Guide, celebrated for its prestigious star ratings awarded to top-tier…
SIR CLIVE WOODWARD: Why this England line-up is so disappointing, from the Marcus Smith muddle to the unnecessary changes all over the pitch - and the worrying impact it could have on our World Cup chances

Clive Woodward Criticizes England’s Rugby Line-Up Shake-Up: Concerns Rise Over World Cup Prospects

One of my favorite sayings is: “Any fool can criticize, and many…
Police on scene at a bridge collapse in Lithgow after it was struck by a truck.

Tragic Bridge Collapse in NSW Claims Life of Rail Worker After Truck Collision

A tragic incident unfolded in New South Wales’ Central West when a…
Insiders spill why model and Fishbowl founder have called off their expensive divorce... Plus, REAL reason $40k-a-year Moriah College expelled boys after camp incident: THE GROUP CHAT

Exclusive: Inside Scoop on Model and Fishbowl Founder’s Divorce U-Turn & Shocking Moriah College Expulsion Over Group Chat Scandal

Welcome to The Group Chat with Lucy Manly, where Australia’s most trusted…

Racist Remarks Force Beloved Educator Rachel to Leave Her ‘Perfect Career

This story contains language that may be offensive. Rachel Bos loved being…
The Age, News, 12/06/2025, photo by Justin McManus. Ash Gordon murder trail Supreme ct. Dr Ash Gordon during a home invasion in Doncaster. Parents Glen and Catherine Gordon along with other family members arriving at court.

Heart-Wrenching Confrontation: Family Faces Teen Killer in Emotional Courtroom Showdown

On a summer day meant for a family lunch, Ashley Gordon’s relatives…
Bonnyrigg

Sydney Bank Employee Arrested in $10 Million Fraud Case Tied to Major Syndicate

A bank employee has been charged over his alleged role in what…
Three pedestrians have been rushed to hospital in serious condition after a car crash in Sydney's west.

Tragic Sydney Car Crash Leaves Three Pedestrians Critically Injured in Western Suburbs

Three individuals are in critical condition after a car veered off the…