Share and Follow
A decades-old theory that First Nations peoples hunted Australia’s megafauna to extinction might not stack up, according to new research.
Australia was once inhabited by giant kangaroos, sheep-sized echidna, and enormous creatures that resembled two-metre-tall, three-metre-long wombats.
Roughly 40,000 years ago, they disappeared.
New research published on Wednesday in the Royal Society Open Science journal debunks one of these pieces of evidence: The fossilised tibia of a now-extinct giant kangaroo found in Western Australia around the time of the World War One.
Late-20th-century studies on the bone and other charred deposits found in Mammoth Cave in Leeuwin-Naturaliste National Park determined that a cut on the bone was evidence of human “butchery” — proof that Indigenous people had hunted megafauna.
But researchers have analysed the tibia with new technology and determined that the cut on its surface, while still likely human-made, had happened “long after death”, possibly even after it was already fossilised.
The research team argued that rather than hunting and killing megafauna, Indigenous peoples were fossil collectors, transporting bones and teeth from deceased animals across Australia.

Researchers have made a compelling case that the First Peoples of Australia valued fossils, collecting and transporting them over long distances, likely thousands of years before Europeans set foot on the continent. This groundbreaking assertion adds a new layer to our understanding of early Australian history.

A skeleton of a large animal lit by yellow lights in a cave.

The findings challenge long-held beliefs about human interaction with Australia’s prehistoric megafauna. Professor Mike Archer, a palaeontologist and fossil specialist from the University of New South Wales, reflected on the limitations of past technologies in studying these ancient relics. He was also a contributor to a previous study on a significant bone find.

Archer pointed out, “If ancient humans were indeed responsible for overhunting Australia’s megafauna to extinction, we would expect to uncover numerous pieces of evidence showing hunting or butchering activities in the fossil record. Instead, the only tangible evidence we had was a single bone, and now we have substantial proof that the incisions on it were not made while the creature was alive.”

Archer was the lead researcher on the new study, and said he thought the “previously-held assumption” that First Nations people were “killing and slaughtering Australia’s megafauna to extinction” had been so easily adopted because it reflected the behaviour of European settlers.
“When Europeans arrived to new continents, they removed the local biodiversity and brought in the alien animals they valued. Those are the things that European people have always done and it’s been a disaster,” he told SBS News.
“The truth is, the 17 animals that have gone extinct since 1788 were doing just fine before the Europeans arrived.”
The group of researchers from across Australia’s institutions used modern 3D-scanning technology to look inside the bone and found it was highly improbable that the cut was made when it was “fresh”.
The team concluded there was no hard evidence to support the claim that “First Peoples killed or butchered any individual of any of the now extinct megafaunal species in Australia”.
“This is not to say that it did not happen, just that there is now no hard evidence to support that it did,” they wrote.
Archer said while he “didn’t doubt” that some animals were eaten by Indigenous peoples, there was “absolutely no evidence” to support the idea that they did so irresponsibly.
“First Nations people have been blamed for irresponsibly killing these megafauna, without a shred of hard evidence to back it up,” Archer said.
“There’s no merit, no benefit in over-killing food resources. So if the Indigenous people didn’t kill the megafauna, who did? Climate change is more plausible.”

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Eight minutes to put 11 in hospital: What's known about UK train stabbing

UK Train Stabbing Rampage: 11 Hospitalized in Just 8 Minutes – Here’s What We Know

The police have not yet pressed charges in connection with the incident,…
Tonga coach defends handling of player who suffered three head knocks and required medical attention

Tonga Coach Stands Firm Amid Controversy Over Player’s Triple Head Injury Management

<!– <!– <!– <!– Tonga’s head coach, Kristian Woolf, has come to…
Hearing to probe whether Grace Tame's abuser is fit to face harassment allegations

Grace Tame’s Abuser Faces Crucial Fitness Hearing Amid Harassment Allegations Investigation

The individual who sexually assaulted Grace Tame, a former recipient of the…
Red Cross vehicles carrying the bodies of three people believed to be deceased Israeli hostages handed over by Hamas

Breaking News: Israel Recovers Alleged Remains of Three Hostages from Gaza – Impact and Implications

Israel on Sunday received the remains of what Hamas said are three…
The City of Sydney Council said its rangers have seized two dogs believed to be involved in the attack and are holding them at Sutherland Animal Shelter as investigations are underway.

Tragic Mauling in Sydney: Two Dogs Seized as Man Battles for Survival

In a harrowing incident in Sydney, a 55-year-old man is in a…

Optus Executives Face Intense Scrutiny Over 17-Hour Emergency Call Outage Response Delays

Optus executives have come under fire for delays in passing on critical…

Nationals Reject Net Zero: A Bold Shift Away from Climate Commitments

The Nationals have set up a possible showdown with their political ally…
Shock CCTV shows moment man is snatched off the street in Sydney

Chilling CCTV Footage Captures Shocking Abduction in Sydney Street: A Must-See Video

Shocking CCTV has emerged of the moment a man was abducted on…