Germani Jewellers owner Michel Germani.
Share and Follow

While CCTV captured two men before and after a brazen staged robbery at a high-end city jewellery store, one man notably absent from the footage has contested his alleged involvement in court.

Germani Jewellers’ store at Sydney‘s Hilton Hotel was robbed over 11 minutes by two men one night in January 2023.

Its owner Michel Germani, 67, owed more than $184,000 in rent to the hotel and formed a plan to recoup funds before the store was shut down, prosecutor Cate Dodds previously told a NSW District Court jury.

Germani Jewellers owner Michel Germani.
Germani Jewellers owner Michel Germani. (A Current Affair)

Mounir Helou, 59, and Andrea David Cusumano, 59, are jointly on trial accused of being in on the scheme.

Cusumano is accused of making a phone call arranging an after-hours appointment so that the sham robbery could take place.

As their trial stretched into its seventh week today, Cusumano’s barrister Peter Stitz called the case against his client “outstandingly bad”, denying he was involved.

The 59-year-old was not present at two meetings planned with Germani, Helou and others before the robbery and was not there to split up the spoils afterwards.

“If he’s on it and knows what’s going on, one, he’d be in there and, two, he’d be getting his slice,” Stitz told the jury.

The barrister took aim at the reliability of the crown prosecution’s “star witness”, a second robber present with Helou at the Germani Jewellery store.

That man – who cannot be named for legal reasons – told police he was taking a gram of methamphetamine, also known as ice, daily at the time of the sham heist and was not sleeping.

“I was scattered and not really myself during this time,” he wrote in a statement to police.

Germani Jewellers' store at Sydney's Hilton Hotel.
Germani Jewellers’ store at Sydney’s Hilton Hotel. (Nine)

In cross-examination, he admitted taking “excessive” amounts of ice which sometimes affected his memory.

The barrister accused the thief of simply guessing Cusumano had made the phone call as alleged.

The robber had been told by Giulia Penna, who was also involved in the plot the 59-year-old had rung Germani Jewellery to make the appointment.

“Is that why I and Mr Cusumano are here? Because Penna told (the man) that we made the call and he believed it?” Stitz told the jury.

“Because he didn’t see it. There’s no evidence that he heard it.”

Cusumano was in Penna’s van when the robbers went to Bunnings to buy cable ties and gloves before the store heist.

The witness told the court that while waiting for Helou to buy the items, he had texted Penna instead of speaking, despite her sitting in front of him in the driver’s seat.

Stitz said this was because he did not want Cusumano in the front passenger seat to find out what was going on.

“Why else would you send a text message to somebody who’s two feet in front of you?” he asked.

The witness described Cusumano as “a bit simple” and “just sort of there”.

Stitz said the obvious result of this for the jury was to acquit his client of the single charge of committing the staged robbery for financial advantage.

“The crown case, you might think, might be something that John West might reject,” he said.

“In fact could you be even sure what fish we’re talking about?”

Germani and Helou have admitted that the robbery was fake but have claimed employee Lana Al-Khoury also knew of the plan and consented to being tied up.

They have each pleaded not guilty to one count of aggravated robbery with corporal violence, while Germani alone has pleaded not guilty to one count of detaining without consent.

Germani made an insurance claim for $2.8 million in jewellery “stolen” but it was refused.

The trial continues tomorrow.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like

Jim Chalmers, the Treasurer, expresses deep concern over Trump’s warnings about tariffs on pharmaceuticals and copper.

Key Points Donald Trump has warned countries can expect 50 per cent…
Mt Hotham locals woke to more than 10cm of fresh snow this morning after temperatures plunged to almost minus four degrees.

“Fierce Cold Front Bringing 40cm of Snow to Alpine Regions”

Australia’s alpine resorts are predicting the best July snow conditions in years,…

Qantas Airlines Reveals Almost Six Million Records Compromised in Cyberattack

Millions of records — covering names, email address, phone numbers and even…

Man’s life hanging in the balance after hit and run following altercation

One man is fighting for his life and another will face court…
Storm weather. Torrential rain

What temperature do you trust – feels like or actual? Let’s break it down

Between ‘bomb cyclones’ and polar blasts, many Aussies have been shivering through…
High Street in Melbourne.

Residents are greatly concerned about plans for a 24-hour McDonald’s on the trendiest street

The Melbourne street voted the world’s coolest is about to become the…
Police allege he then took 53 right-footed shoes only, not pairs, before putting them in his trolley and leaving the centre.

Detectives puzzled by man who stole 53 right shoes from store

A man allegedly stole 53 right shoes from a business in Queensland,…
US President Donald Trump during a meeting with African leaders in the State Dining Room of the White House in Washington, DC, US, on Wednesday, July 9, 2025. Trump is meeting the leaders of five African nations that will potentially offer American businesses opportunities in critical minerals and other natural resources. Photographer: Will Oliver/EPA/Bloomberg

Criticism arises as Trump commends Liberian president’s fluency in English

But the African leader was educated in Liberia, where English is the…