Share and Follow

Jurors have acquitted a man diagnosed with "sexsomnia" of rape after being told to determine their verdict based on existing sex crime laws rather than laws they wished were in force.

Timothy Malcolm Rowland, 40, was today found not guilty of having non-consensual sex with a woman at his Sydney apartment on August 26, 2022, after the pair spent a night out together.

The 40-year-old told the the seven-day jury trial that he was experiencing an episode of sexsomnia, a medical condition where people exhibit sexual behaviour during sleep.

READ MORE: Jet carrying 64 people collides with helicopter, crashes into river

The not guilty verdict came hours after jurors sent a series of questions to Judge John Pickering at Sydney's Downing Centre District Court.

One inquiry of concern to the judge regarded the consequences of committing crimes while a person was unconscious.

"This is a really dangerous logic," the judge said.

A jury should not be determining a case based on laws it wished were in place but instead on the current laws, he warned.

Doing this would be unfair on any accused, he said.

Someone could not be found guilty of a crime they did unconsciously, Judge Pickering said.

"We're not about to punish people for acts that they have no lawful control over."

READ MORE: What we know so far about the Washington DC plane crash

There were no current laws, rules or regulations about having sexsomnia or doing something while having the medical condition, the judge said.

"'No laws about that exist. There are no criminal offences about that that exist. And it's not for you to create the law."

Rowland and the woman went drinking at a cocktail bar in inner-city Darlinghurst on the night of the alleged rape, returning to his apartment about 1am, the jury heard during the trial.

Once there, they drank some more and took a naked bath together before the woman fell asleep in Rowland's bed, the parties agreed.

About 6am, the woman allegedly woke to find Rowland having sex with her before she pushed him off, jumped out of the bed and left the apartment.

There was no dispute during the trial that Rowland had sexsomnia.

But the issue before the jury was whether he was having an episode at the time of the alleged rape or whether he was awake.

It was also not in dispute that the woman was asleep when Rowland began having sex with her.

READ MORE: Underworld figure 'The Punisher' farewelled in gold casket

Earlier today, the jury asked what sort of evidence there could be to prove someone was awake.

And if there was insufficient evidence, why was the case prosecuted and why did it come before a jury, it asked.

Judge Pickering said it was none of his business why the Director of Public Prosecutions had decided to pursue the case in court.

It was also not the jury's responsibility to wonder about these things.

Instead, he urged them to look at the evidence before them and determine whether the rape had been proved beyond reasonable doubt.

Determining a verdict was a "cold-analytical process" which should not be concerned with how the alleged victim or the community may feel, he said.

Support is available from the National Sexual Assault, Domestic and Family Violence Counselling Service at 1800RESPECT (1800 737 732).

DOWNLOAD THE 9NEWS APP: Stay across all the latest in breaking news, sport, politics and the weather via our news app and get notifications sent straight to your smartphone. Available on the Apple App Store and Google Play.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Agriculture Minister Tara Moriarty said: "There's been over 7000 submissions over the last couple of years about what we can do to strengthen animal welfare laws.

NSW Considers Legislation to Prohibit Leaving Dogs in Hot Cars

The NSW government is proposing law changes to criminalise leaving dogs in…
Sinkhole in Heidelberg

Unseen Threat: Suburban Australia Faces Hidden Sinkhole Challenges

Climate change could be driving the emergence of sinkholes across Australia, experts…
The intended flight path for PK-THT.

Urgent Search Launched: Indonesian Plane with 11 Passengers Mysteriously Disappears

An Indonesian passenger aircraft carrying 11 people has gone missing just before…
Nort non-alcoholic beer co-founder Jaz Wearon

Brewery Owner Jaz’s Bold Initiative Yields Significant Success

Jaz Wearin and her husband Grant began Modus Operandi in 2014 on…

US Department of Justice Launches Investigation into Minnesota Governor over Alleged ICE Obstruction

The US justice department has opened a criminal investigation into Minnesota officials,…

Revolutionary Coffee Trend Combines the Art of Tea and Indulgence of Dessert

Coffee in Australia is undergoing a flavour revolution, as cafés experiment with…

Explosive Discovery: 41-Year-Old Man Arrested in Canberra Pipe Bomb Case

The motive of a man accused of making and scattering explosives along…
Donald Trump has threatened tariffs on any country that opposes his Greenland annexation plans.

Iran Acknowledges Heavy Protest Casualties, Labels Trump as ‘Criminal’ in Bold Statement

Iran’s Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei branded US President Donald Trump a…