Mushroom jury verdict step closer as judge wraps up
Share and Follow

Jurors in mushroom cook Erin Patterson’s triple-murder trial will soon begin their deliberations after more than four days of judge’s directions.

Victorian Supreme Court Justice Christopher Beale is expected to finish his closing statements to the jury on Monday morning.

The 14 jurors will then be balloted down to 12, who will be tasked with deciding whether Patterson is guilty or not guilty of three counts of murder and one count of attempted murder.

Erin Patterson has denied she intentionally poisoned her guests. (Jason South)

Patterson denies intentionally poisoning her former in-laws Don and Gail Patterson, Gail’s sister Heather and Heather’s husband Ian Wilkinson with meals laced with death cap mushrooms.

Don, Gail and Heather all died after consuming the beef Wellington lunch on July 29, 2023, served by Patterson at her home in regional Victoria, while Ian survived.

During his four days of directions, known as a charge, Justice Beale outlined the evidence in the case and the arguments from both sides.

On Friday, he turned to Patterson’s alleged incriminating conduct and cautioned jurors on how they should consider her admitted lies.

They include claims she never foraged for wild mushrooms, never had a dehydrator and was diagnosed with cancer.

Justice Beale noted jurors could use those lies to assess Patterson’s credibility but they did not mean she was guilty of murder.

The jury should instead consider all of the evidence in the prosecution case before they reach their verdicts, the judge said.

As Justice Beale excused the jury for the week on Friday afternoon, he told them to enjoy their weekend and keep conversations about the case to the jury room.

“Don’t let anybody get into your ear over the weekend,” he said.

“Have a media blackout. You’ve been doing a great job, keep going.”

Once the deliberations begin, the 12 jurors will be sequestered so they will have to stay together until they reach a unanimous verdict on all charges.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like

Local Hero Ahmed Al-Ahmed Questions Eligibility for $2.5 Million Donation at Bondi

Ahmed Al-Ahmed, the tobacco shop owner who was wounded after disarming one…
The fines amount to the largest combined penalties ASIC has ever secured against a single entity.

Federal Court Calls for Higher Penalty: ANZ’s $240 Million Fine Deemed Insufficient

The Federal Court has imposed an additional $10 million penalty on ANZ,…

Australia Strengthens Gun Control: PM Albanese Unveils National Buyback as NSW Enacts New Restrictions

Prime Minister Anthony Albanese has announced that the government will introduce legislation…
Special Envoy to Combat Antisemitism Jillian Segal holds a press conference at Commonwealth Parliamentary Offices in Sydney. Thursday July 10th, 2025.

Unveiling the Stalled Strategy: The PM’s Controversial Antisemitism Plan Awaiting Action

The federal government has faced escalating criticism over how it has responded…

How a Tennant Creek Residence is Pioneering the Future of Remote Housing Solutions

A single house nearing completion in Tennant Creek is drawing national attention…
Bureau of Meterology accidentally sends tsunami warning

False Tsunami Alert Sparks Panic Across Australia: Authorities Clarify Mistake

The Bureau of Meteorology has apologised after a tsunami warning was sent…

Newly Revealed Epstein Documents Include Clinton, Mick Jagger, and Michael Jackson, but Trump Not Mentioned

The United States Department of Justice (DOJ) has released more than 300,000…
Donald Trump and Jeffrey Epstein together.

Unveiled Secrets: US Justice Department Releases Explosive Jeffrey Epstein Files

The exact number of files set to be released under a congressional…