Yolanda Tinajero, whose brother Arturo Benavides was killed in the 2019 El Paso Walmart shooting, attends a hearing for Patrick Crusius, during which she hugged him.
Share and Follow

Instead she told him that she forgave him, and wished she could give him a hug.

The judge, in a surprising turn in an El Paso courtroom, allowed her to do just that.

Yolanda Tinajero, whose brother Arturo Benavides was killed in the 2019 El Paso Walmart shooting, attends a hearing for Patrick Crusius, during which she hugged him.
Yolanda Tinajero, whose brother Arturo Benavides was killed in the 2019 El Paso Walmart shooting, attends a hearing for Patrick Crusius, during which she hugged him. (AP)

Their brief embrace — while Patrick Crusius was still shackled — was among many emotionally charged moments during two days of impact statements given by victims’ family members and survivors.

Some described their pain and devastation while others assured him the community had met his hatred with love and unity.

Later, another person also hugged the man who pleaded guilty in one of the deadliest mass shootings in the US.

Crusius, a white community college dropout, had posted online a screed about a Hispanic invasion of Texas before opening fire with an AK-style rifle at the store near the US-Mexico border on August 3, 2019.

Crusius didn’t address the families and survivors at his plea hearing on Monday.

“We would have opened our doors to you to share a meal, breakfast lunch or dinner, Mexican-style, so then your ugly thoughts of us that have been instilled in you would have turned around,” Tinajero told him.

Adriana Zandri, widow of Ivan Manzano killed during the Walmart mass shooting, hugs defendant Patrick Crusius during a plea hearing in El Paso, Texas.
Adriana Zandri, widow of Ivan Manzano killed during the Walmart mass shooting, hugs defendant Patrick Crusius during a plea hearing in El Paso, Texas. (AP)

Tinajero said her brother, 60-year-old Arturo Benavides, was a “kind, sweet-hearted person,” whose wife of over 30 years is broken-hearted over her loss.

“Now she lives alone in their home full of memories that she can’t forget,” she said.

“I feel in my heart, to hug you very tight so you could feel my forgiveness, especially my loss, but I know it’s not allowed,” Tinajero said.

“I want you to see and feel all of us who have been impacted by your actions.”

A police booking photo for El Paso gunman Patrick Crusius. (AP/AAP)

Later, the judge asked her: “Ma’am, would it truly bring you peace and comfort if you could hug him?”

Her daughter, Melissa Tinajero, told reporters: “I don’t know how she was able to do it. I could not do that. But she showed him something he could not show his victims.”

‘A survivor, not a victim’

Stephanie Melendez told Crusius that she did not want to address him but rather read a letter to her father, 63-year-old David Johnson, who was killed when he shielded his wife and nine-year-old granddaughter from the gunfire.

Texas state police cars block the access to the Walmart store in the aftermath of the mass shooting in El Paso, Texas.
Texas state police cars block the access to the Walmart store in the aftermath of the mass shooting in El Paso, Texas. (AP)

Melendez thanked her father for making her study, giving her a curfew and telling her when she was 16 that she needed to get a job.

“You made me into the strong woman I am today,” she said.

Her daughter, Kaitlyn Melendez, now 14, told Crusius: “I am a survivor, not a victim.”

“I’m going to walk out these doors and move forward with my life and not let you haunt me anymore.”

Dean Reckard, whose 63-year-old mother Margie Reckard was among those killed, expressed anger and forgiveness as he addressed Crusius.

“You’re a disgrace to humanity and to your family,” Reckard said, adding that he hopes Crusius wakes up each morning wishing he were dead.

But Reckard also said he forgave the gunman who will spend the rest of his life behind bars.

Patrick Crusius in court during a plea hearing for the 2019 Walmart shooting in El Paso, Texas.
Patrick Crusius in court during a plea hearing for the 2019 Walmart shooting in El Paso, Texas. (AP)

“In order to be forgiving, you have to forgive others,” he said. “That’s the only reason I forgive you. May God have mercy on your soul.”

Thousands of people attended Margie Reckard’s funeral after her partner of 22 years, Antonio Basco, invited the public to the service, saying he felt alone after her death.

Liliana Munoz of Ciudad Juárez, Mexico, said in court on Monday that she was shopping for snacks when Crusius opened fire, forever changing her life physically, economically and emotionally.

In her statement, she said she used to be a “happy, dancing person,” but now is afraid every morning when she awakes.

People join hands and pray during the Hope Border Institute prayer vigil Sunday, Aug. 4, 2019 in El Paso, Texas, a day after a mass shooting at a Walmart store
People join hands and pray during the Hope Border Institute prayer vigil Sunday, Aug. 4, 2019 in El Paso, Texas, a day after a mass shooting at a Walmart store. (Mark Lambie/The El Paso Times via AP) (AP)

Since she was shot, she has had to use a cane to walk and wears a leg brace to keep her left foot from dragging.

“It left me sad, bitter,” said the 41-year-old mother.

She also granted Crusius forgiveness.

‘You brought us together’

Javier Rodriguez was 15 and starting his sophomore year in high school when he was shot and killed at a bank in Walmart.

On Tuesday, his father Francisco Rodriguez shouted at Crusius: “Look at me, I’m talking to you.”

$200 billion lost in three minutes over something that didn’t happen

He told Crusius that he and his family have to go to the cemetery to commemorate his son’s birthday.

“I wish I could just get five minutes with you — me and you — and get all of this, get it over with,” he said.

But Rodriguez also referred to comments made about Crusius’ impact on El Paso during his sentencing.

“Like the judge said yesterday, you came down to El Paso with the intention of tearing us apart, but all you did, you brought us together,” he said.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like

Unveiling Hidden Truths: The Complex Challenges of Whistleblowing in Australia

Australians looking to expose wrongdoing need to navigate a complex legal minefield,…
Chinese President Xi Jinping, also chairman of the Central Military Commission (CMC), front row second from left, poses with other military officers after promoting to generals, back row, from left, Yang Zhibin of the Eastern Theater Command and Han Shengyan commander of Central Theater Command in Beijing on Monday, Dec. 22, 2025. (Li Gang/Xinhua via AP)

Chinese Military Conducts Strategic Drills Near Taiwan to Deter External Intervention

China’s military launched joint drills involving air, navy, and rocket units around…
Rural firefighters are "heartbroken and gutted" after thousands of dollars' worth of life-saving equipment was stolen while crews were deployed to a rescue on the NSW Mid North Coast.

Rural Firefighters Devastated by $30,000 Equipment Theft, Urgent Call for Community Support

Rural firefighters are devastated after approximately $30,000 worth of essential equipment was…
Prime Minister rejects royal commission plea from Bondi shooting victims' families

Prime Minister Denies Bondi Shooting Victims’ Families’ Request for Royal Commission

In a poignant letter, 11 out of the 15 families affected by…
Premier promises 'answers' as Bondi royal commission stoush heats up

Premier Vows to Uncover Truth Amidst Rising Tensions in Bondi Royal Commission

NSW Premier Chris Minns has promised the state’s royal commission into the…
My friends and I spent $10,000 on a place for New Year's Eve... when we turned up to the Gold Coast, the owner had no idea who we were

Gold Coast New Year’s Eve Rental Nightmare: Friends Spend $10,000 Only to Find Booking Doesn’t Exist

A group of ten friends, led by a young tourist, found themselves…
Aussie cricket great calls for one of the game's oldest traditions to be SCRAPPED after Boxing Day Test disaster

Aussie Cricket Legend Urges End to Historic Tradition After Boxing Day Test Debacle

Ex-Australian cricketer and coach Darren Lehmann has suggested eliminating the traditional coin…
A bus has crashed into the side of a medical centre after a collision with a car in Sydney's north-west.

Bus Driver Remarkably Survives Collision with Medical Center

A bus driver is lucky to be alive after crashing into a…