Scheana Shay was an OG cast member of Vanderpump Rules who came to be known as “the other woman” in Season 1. She famously had an affair with RHOBH’s Brandi Glanville’s husband, Eddie Cibrian.

Scheana’s love life was on full display while appearing on the hit Bravo show. Her first husband proposed to her at Lisa Vanderpump’s stunning home, Villa Rosa, but the two were married for less than three years. In between her first and second marriages, fans would watch Scheana fall head-over-heels with other men, including her SUR restaurant co-workers.

Here’s a list of all the men Scheana has dated before settling down with her current husband, Brock Davies.

5 Scheana Shay Was In An Affair With Actor Eddie Cibrian

Vanderpump Rules started off with a bang when they had Real Housewives star Brandi Glanville confront SUR restaurant worker Scheana Shay, who had an affair with her husband, Eddie Cibrian, back in 2006. However, Eddie was also hooking up with singer LeAnn Rimes, who he would end up marrying in 2011.

In 2010, LeAnn admitted to the affair which led to the
end of her marriage
to Dean Sheremet. “I did one of the most selfish things that I possibly could do, in hurting someone else. I take responsibility for everything I’ve done. I hate that people got hurt, but I don’t regret the outcome,” she told
People.

Scheana has continued to deny that she knew Eddie was married when she was involved with him. In 2020, she tweeted, “He wrecked his own home. I was a single 21 year old who met a cute actor in LA.”

4 Scheana Wed Her First Husband, Mike Shay, in 2014

In Season 2 of VPR, fans watched Scheana in a very committed relationship with music producer Mike Shay. Later in the season, he got down on one knee and proposed to Scheana outside of Villa Rosa. The following season, the pair married in a magical wedding ceremony and Scheana famously wore a wedding dress that featured a crop top.

In Season 4, viewers watched Mike share that he had been struggling with substance abuse and the couple were dealing with trust issues. It would ultimately affect their marriage, and on camera, Scheana told her husband that she wanted a divorce the very next season.

In 2017, Scheana told The Daily Dish:

“Shay and I did split amicably. We put out a joint statement. It just wasn’t working anymore on either end. We just decided instead of going for a legal separation or trying to continue therapy, we both agreed it wasn’t right. And, hopefully one day we can be friends. You never know what the future holds. But it just was a situation that needed to end before the holidays, before the new year.”

Their divorce was finalized in Season 6, with Scheana already in another relationship.

3 Scheana Reconnected With Rob Valletta After Her Divorce

After her separation from Mike, Scheana found herself reconnecting with a past lover named Rob Valletta. She was head-over-heels with Rob and her co-stars were ultimately getting annoyed by just how much she was bragging about him, like the fact that Rob could hand a television on the wall in seven minutes.

However, Rob never seemed fully committed to Scheana. During an outing with Jax Taylor and Tom Sandoval at his home in Big Bear, he shared that he couldn’t use the L-word yet. Meanwhile, Scheana was ready to make Rob her next husband.

Rob broke up with Scheana in 2017, but five years later, he joined his ex on her Scheananigans podcast, where he stated that he wasn’t emotionally available during the time they dated.

“I just didn’t do the work. You’re dealing with someone who was immature emotionally, immature communication-wise, immature as a man. I can’t look back and change anything, I can just move forward and say, ‘OK, hey, like, expect better,” he said.

2 Scheana Had A Friends With Benefits Relationship With Adam Spott

Scheana had a complicated relationship with SUR barback Adam Spitt. While she always called him her “best friend,” the two were more than that. When Adam didn’t want to become exclusive with Scheana, she moved on with a model, (to make Adam jealous) and it seemed to upset Adam in Season 7.

Scheana has hooked up with several reality stars, which include
Summer House’s
Carl Radke,
Southern Charm’s
Shep Rose, and
Shahs of Sunset’s
Nema Vand.

Scheana sleeping with a model bruised Adam’s ego, but nonetheless, he still didn’t have strong feelings for her. However, Scheana continued to try and almost convince Adam that they should date. There was an entire thing about a penguin that blew up in the “Good as Gold” singer’s face. (Scheana adopted a penguin for Adam that cost her $1,000).

“And we still haven’t seen the f–king thing. I was like, ‘Please, can we just go meet her?’ Adam’s like, ‘We’re not doing couple-y things together anymore because we’re not a couple.’ I’m like, ‘It’s just a best friend thing,'” Scheana said. “Like, why can’t we just go to the f–king aquarium and meet this goddamn penguin? All I wanted for Christmas was just to go and meet this f–king penguin.”

1 Scheana Married Her Second Husband, Brock Davies, In 2022

At the Season 8 reunion, Scheana revealed that she was in a new relationship with Australian Brock Davies. This one seemed to be the one as they have been going strong ever since.

In 2021, the couple welcomed a daughter named Summer Moon, Scheana’s first child, and Brock’s third. Brock was previously married and welcomed two children named Winter and Eli. However, their relationship is strained. “It is a very difficult situation. Based on my actions and my past and what my actions have caused for these kids — especially when they were younger — there was obviously trauma there that needed to be mended,” Brock said in an episode of the Scheananigans podcast.

Scheana was in a throuple with singer John Mayer.

In August 2022, Scheana would, again, have her wedding televised on the Bravo show. But, it was later learned that Scheana and Brock secretly wed a year earlier.

“We wanted to celebrate our love privately. We share a child together, we live together, so with the green card and all that, I was like, ‘Let’s get it going. I want to marry you.’ It was nice to have that little secret for us because we didn’t get married for anyone other than us,” Scheana said during the Season 10 reunion.