57

Credit Instagram

Craig Conover confirmed he was dating someone new on Thursday’s episode of Watch What Happens Live. And just hours later, it seems the identity of his mystery woman has been revealed.

After the 36-year-old Southern Charm cast member revealed he was “seeing someone” and was “really happy” months after his messy split from Paige DeSorbo, 32, a blind item was sent in to Deux Moi, sharing that Craig was supposedly referring to 27-year-old Natalie Buffett, who he reportedly brought with him to the WWHL taping.

Along with a subject line with the title, “Craig’s New Pillow Princess,” an insider told the Instagram account, “Craig Conover is dating Natalie Buffett. She was in the audience of his WWHL taping.”

Although Craig hasn’t confirmed anything quite yet, followers of Deux Moi had a lot to say about the potential pairing.

“She’s stunning,” one person wrote.

“Good for him she’s gorg,” another agreed.

Craig Conover’s rumored girlfriend Natalie Buffett

Then, a third noted that Craig “liked her recent picture” as someone else pointed out that she’d dated “a lot of pro athletes” and may be “looking for a change.”

“She was in Charleston six days ago, too,” shared another IG user.

As fans did some digging into Natalie’s social media activity, photos of her were shared by a Bravo fan page on X, formerly known as Twitter.

“This is who Craig is dating,” Queen of Bravo announced on March 28.

This is who Craig is dating 👀 #SouthernCharm pic.twitter.com/3PxYxMhPJU

— Queens of Bravo (@queensofbravo) March 28, 2025

In a look at Natalie’s Instagram page, it can be confirmed that she is followed by Craig, and oddly, Shannon Beador, 61, of The Real Housewives of Orange County, both of whom have “liked” her photos in recent weeks.

In addition to her Bravo ties, Natalie has found herself in the spotlight more than once due to her past high-profile romances with athletes, including Dallas Cowboys quarterback Dak Prescott, 31, and Detroit Tigers pitcher Jack Flaherty, 29.

Dak Prescott’s ex-girlfriend, Natalie Buffett, dating Tigers pitcher Jack Flaherty pic.twitter.com/yAEfpNGGya

— New York Post (@nypost) December 26, 2023

Part two of the Southern Charm season 10 reunion airs next Thursday, April 3, at 8/7c on Bravo.