Share and Follow
Paul Morigi/Getty Images
Katie Miller seems to be carving out a niche for herself within the Fox News environment, which leads us to speculate about her potential aspirations for a more permanent role. Katie undoubtedly possesses attributes that could make her an appealing candidate for Fox News. Her presence on the network has become more frequent, and she has embraced the network’s signature style. Notably, Katie has adopted the popular low-maintenance hair extensions favored in MAGA circles, though some might argue they aren’t quite as striking or blonde as those typically seen on Fox News anchors. Her background as a former MAGA staffer and ongoing insider positions her alongside other former Trump administration figures like Kayleigh McEnany and Kellyanne Conway. All things considered, one might suspect that her podcast serves as a strategic portfolio aimed at securing her dream job.
katiemiller/Instagram
However, despite her insider connections and relevant experience, Katie Miller faces criticism for her relatively modest following. With fewer than 60,000 subscribers at the time of writing, this number is surprisingly low given the high-profile guests featured on her podcast. Some critics suggest this could partly be due to her overshadowing her husband, Stephen Miller, in the “Most Unlikeable MAGA Star” category. Katie brands herself as the exclusive conservative, health-conscious working mom in the podcasting world, but in reality, she is one of many creators in the “womanosphere,” which might explain her limited subscriber base. Moreover, reviews suggest her podcast lacks distinctiveness and excitement, failing to captivate its audience.
Critiques from media outlets like Salon aren’t flattering, describing the show as one that “appears to be lulling viewers to sleep.” The debut episode was deemed underwhelming, with its most notable revelation being Stephen Miller’s affinity for mayonnaise. Similarly, Slate labeled “The Katie Miller Podcast” as “painfully dull,” lacking any impactful moments. They criticized the missed opportunity in having access to key MAGA figures only to engage them with mundane questions. Perhaps this exposure to the network is meant to hone her skills for a potential future as a Fox News host. After all, practice makes perfect.
Katie Miller’s podcast isn’t exactly a smash hit
Katie Miller may have a bunch of high-up contacts and a relevant professional background for Fox News, but as many of her detractors continue to point out, her actual following is on the smaller side. We’re talking under 60,000 subscribers at the time of writing which, considering her guests’ caliber, is surprising — and only part of it seems to stem from the fact that Katie Miller threatens her husband’s “Most Unlikeable MAGA Star” title. Despite proudly positioning herself as the only conservative, health-conscious working mom with a podcast, Katie is actually just one of many “womanosphere” content creators, which may account for her lack of subscribers. Even worse, the general consensus is that on top of not exactly differentiating herself, her show is kind of boring.
Salon wasn’t exactly complimentary, noting that the show, “appears to be lulling viewers to sleep.” They similarly argued that the premiere episode, “was a big nothingburger,” particularly since, “The biggest news that came out of it was that Stephen Miller eats a lot of mayonnaise.” Yikes. Likewise, Slate described “The Katie Miller Podcast” as “Eye-wateringly boring — void of a single revelatory moment.” They also lamented the wasted opportunity of being in such close proximity to some of MAGA’s biggest stars, but choosing instead to, “ask them the most banal questions imaginable.” Perhaps, then, some work is needed before Katie goes full-on Fox News host. Maybe that’s why she’s being brought on to the network so frequently. Practice makes perfect, after all.