Mandy Moore and Taylor Goldsmith fell head over heels for each other, and their quiet love story slowly captured all of our hearts.

The This Is Us alum didn’t stop believing in love after she finalized her divorce from Ryan Adams. Moore and Adams called it quits in January 2015 following nearly six years of marriage. She and Goldsmith met through Instagram in May 2015 after she outed herself as a fan of his band, Dawes, by posting the cover of one of their albums. When Goldsmith noticed his famous new fan, the two began DMing and bonded over their shared love of music.

The twosome got engaged in September 2017, and it was only fitting that Moore said they were planning a low-key wedding. “I don’t think I’m going to have a big, old affair,” Moore told Us one month later. “I think it will be small, and quiet, and private.”

In November 2018, Moore and Goldsmith exchanged vows at sunset in the actress’ backyard in front of friends and family, including This Is Us costars Milo Ventimiglia, Chrissy Metz and Sterling K. Brown.

Scroll to relive more of the couple’s most romantic moments: