During Deal or No Deal Island’s first two seasons, the reality show became one of Peacock’s best shows. While Joe Manganiello being such a great host helps make DONDI a must-see, Dickson Wong being a weasel and Seychelle Cordero being so blunt also make the show great. Since reality show newbies help make the show great, DONDI shouldn’t go to an all-legends format. However, the fact that Dr. Will Kirby increased the show’s ratings proves that more legends should be cast in the future.

After watching Dr. Will confront David Genat and feud with Parvati Shallow, the next question to consider is which reality show legends should join DONDI next. If the following reality show legends starred in Deal or No Deal Island Season 3, they would make the show incredible.

Dr. Will Kirby Needs To Play Deal Or No Deal Island Again

Since Dr. Will Kirby competed during Deal or No Deal Island Season 2, this may seem like a cop out to start out with. However, anyone who watched Deal or No Deal Island Season 2 should recognize that Dr. Will’s DONDI tenure during the second season was incredibly entertaining.

After Kate Chastain was awesome during the second season of The Traitors, she returned during the next season. Since it could be argued that Dr. Will had the most entertaining single-season reality show run during his DONDI return, bringing him back should be a no-brainer.

There isn’t enough room to detail every part of Dr. Will’s DONDI tenure that made his time on the show so great here. That said, a different TheThings article explains Dr. Will’s incredible time on the show in greater detail and why every reality show casting team should be calling him.

Cirie Fields Competing On Deal Or No Deal Island Would Be Fascinating

Easily one of the most celebrated Survivor players ever, Cirie Fields is widely considered to be the best ever to never win that show. After playing Survivor many times, Cirie went on to compete on Big Brother and The Traitors. During the first season of The Traitors, Cirie won a reality show for the first time.

Based on everything that Cirie has accomplished on reality TV, it would be amazing to see how she would do on Deal or No Deal Island. However, it may be what Cirie has failed at that would make her competing on DONDI even more fascinating.

Socially speaking, Cirie has always been one of the most talented reality show stars ever. Incredibly likable as a human being, virtually everyone who competes on a reality show with Cirie wants to work with her.

However, Cirie has always struggled during the physical parts of reality shows. Since the excursions are such a big part of Deal or No Deal Island, it would be fascinating to see how Cirie would deal with that.

Would Cirie’s social skills allow her to be protected by her DONDI allies? Would Cirie struggling during excursions send her out of the game quickly? There is no way to know what would happen unless Cirie competes on Deal or No Deal Island and fans want answers.

Chris “CT” Tamburello Would Be Physically Dominant On Deal Or No Deal Island

Originally made famous thanks to The Challenge, fans of that MTV reality show will know that Chris “C.T.” Tamburello was an absolute beast. In fact, C.T. was so physically impressive on that show that MTV’s YouTube channel uploaded a montage of his most impressive moments.

On top of being a challenge beast, C.T. also proved that he has social and strategic skills.

Most recently, C.T. put how likable and smart he could be on display when he competed during The Traitors Season 2 and won alongside his top ally in the game, Trishelle Cannatella.

Since Deal or No Deal Island’s excursions are so important to the game, it would be amazing to see if C.T. could dominate.

Additionally, fans of the MTV reality show legend will no doubt enjoy seeing if he could build the social relationships needed to ultimately win DONDI.

Tony Vlachos Could Change Deal Or No Deal Island And Make It Better

During Deal or No Deal Island Season 2, fans saw how Dr. Will Kirby’s chaotic energy put the other players on edge. However, since Dr. Will relished being a villain, he set himself apart from the other players. While that was a brilliant move for Dr. Will that led to a lot of success, it also allowed his fellow competitors to feel like they were distant from him.

If Tony Vlachos joined the cast of Deal or No Deal Island, he would bring his over-the-top energy with him too. However, unlike Dr. Will, Tony almost certainly wouldn’t set himself apart from his fellow competitors.

As a result, any of Tony’s potential DONDI castmates who wanted to have a chance to win would have a choice to make.

During the first two seasons of Deal or No Deal Island, players have gone through the game with as much honesty as someone can on a reality competition show. However, if any of Tony’s competitors wanted to have a chance to beat him, they would likely have to get down into the mud with him.

It would be fascinating to see how Deal or No Deal Island would change if the players embraced the backstabbing strategy of other competition reality shows.

Janelle Pierzina Should Compete And Win On Deal Or No Deal Island

When Janelle Pierzina was introduced to the world during Big Brother 6, it quickly became clear that she was a special reality show star.

Widely regarded as one of the most athletic reality show stars of all-time, Janelle quickly proved how amazing she was during challenges.

In most cases, reality show stars who are great at challenges solely rely on that skill. However, Janelle and the next reality show star this article will mention didn’t rest on their laurels.

Fiercely intelligent, Jannelle has proven again and again that she has strategic skills that even dwarf many of the people mentioned in this article. On top of that, Janelle is cold-blooded enough to destroy a competitor’s game to their face without betraying any internal conflict. If Janelle took all those skills to Deal or No Deal Island, it is hard to see how she or the show’s fans could lose.