
Wild Orchid singer Stefanie Fair has been awarded $70,000 after Tennessee Highway Patrol troopers allegedly arrested and charged her with DUI despite her being completely sober.
Fair, 53, who performed alongside Fergie in the 1990s girl group, is expected to receive the payment within the next few weeks. The Tennessee Board of Claims approved the settlement stemming from the June 2024 incident, a spokesman for the state attorney general’s office told WSMV4, which first reported the agreement Tuesday.
According to WSMV4, THP Trooper Keith Velez stopped Fair in Nashville for failing to change lanes while driving.
Velez said he noticed a “very distinct odor of alcohol that comes from either the person or inside the vehicle.” Fair, however, told him she had not been drinking, according to body-camera footage obtained by the outlet.
“She almost f–king hit me when I was wrapping up a traffic stop,” Velez told another trooper who arrived at the scene. “I just come up to the car, and it just reeks of alcohol.”
Fair apologized for failing to move over but appeared confused when Velez said he smelled alcohol.
“On my life, I don’t drink alcohol,” she told the trooper.
The singer, who also appeared on the Bravo reality show “There Goes the Motherhood,” was administered a field sobriety test and continued to insist that she had consumed nothing. Fair is married to former A&M Records president Ron Fair.
Velez said the test indicated that Fair showed signs of intoxication and arrested her on suspicion of DUI.
Her blood test later showed no alcohol or drugs in her system, and prosecutors dismissed the charge.
“When he said he could smell it, I knew it was corrupt. This is completely wrong,” Fair told WSMV4.
The arrest left her deeply shaken.
“If this could happen to me completely sober …” she told the outlet. “It was just like, very scary.”
Fair’s attorney, Ben Raybin, said sober drivers in Tennessee have no way to recover their expenses after DUI charges are dismissed, leaving a lawsuit as their only recourse.
“I think that the state has recognized that a lot of these arrests are just completely legally unsupportable,” Raybin told the outlet, adding that “if they went to a jury trial, a jury would find against them.”
Fair is not the first sober driver to secure a settlement over an allegedly wrongful DUI arrest.
Her payout follows a $75,000 settlement the THP paid to Thomas Manis, who was arrested in Monroe County in East Tennessee in December 2023, according to WSMV4.
Manis was the first sober driver to sue the agency and reach a settlement.