New Year’s Day is supposed to symbolize fresh beginnings. For Christina Karlsen, however, the 1991 holiday became the final day of her life.
Christina was taking a bath when a fire erupted inside the rural Murphys, California, home she shared with her husband, Karl Karlsen, and their three children. The flames trapped her in the small bathroom.
Unable to escape through a boarded-up window, Christina died in the blaze—a haunting case later revisited on Oxygen’s Dateline: Secrets Uncovered.
Investigators initially determined that the fire was accidental. But 17 years later, after Christina and Karl’s son Levi died in what appeared to be another tragic accident, authorities began to question whether both deaths had been deliberately arranged.
Who Was Christina Karlsen?
Christina and Karl’s relationship began in 1981, when Karl, then an Air Force airman, was stationed in North Dakota.
“She told me she’d met a guy,” Christina’s sister, Colette Bousson, recalled. “And she was happy.”
Not long afterward, Christina—described by friends and family as warm and naturally encouraging—learned she was pregnant. The couple decided to marry and build a life together.
The family eventually settled in Seneca County, New York. With three children, Christina devoted herself to motherhood.
“She’d be on the floor playing with them, or teaching them or instructing them or coddling them,” Karl’s brother Mike Karlsen said. “And it wasn’t just her kids. It was all of our kids. Whoever was in the group, she was a mother hen that gathered all the kids up.”
What Happened to Christina Karlsen?
Karl eventually moved the family to Murphys, California, where he planned to work for a heating and air conditioning company owned by Christina’s father.
At the same time, Christina was working to renovate their home at the top of a mountain road.
But the 30-year-old mother would never have the chance to enjoy the results. On Jan. 1, 1991, a devastating fire swept through the family’s house.
“It was just consuming the house,” firefighter Rich Winn recalled. “We felt the smoke and the heat.”
Karl told Dateline that he was in the garage when he heard Christina screaming. He rushed toward the burning house and pulled their son Levi and two daughters out through the windows.
“Both girls get a hold of me,” he said. “We fall back, tumble on the ground, get back up, run them to the truck.”
Christina, who had been in the bathtub, remained trapped inside. She died from smoke inhalation.
Only four days later, Karl packed up the family and moved them back to Seneca Falls, New York.
Fire Investigator Had Suspicions About Christina Karlsen’s Death
After the fire, state investigator Carl Kent was called to examine the scene. He immediately noticed a strong kerosene odor in the hallway outside the bathroom, while the burn patterns indicated that the fire may have started there.
“She wouldn’t have been able to escape out the doorway,” Kent said, “because there was so much fire right in that area.”
Karl said that, just days before the blaze, the family’s pets had knocked over a container of kerosene near the bathroom door.
Kent considered the fire’s origin suspicious. However, his supervisors told him there was not enough money for him to travel to New York and interview Karl.
The fire was ultimately classified as accidental, but Kent kept his investigative files.
Fire Burns Down Karl Karlsen’s Barn, Killing Three Horses
After returning to New York, Karl married Cindy Best, whom he met while line dancing.
The couple had a son, Alex, and supported themselves by raising Belgian draft horses.
During that period, Karl’s relationship with Levi had become strained.
“I think Levi bucked the system a little bit,” Mike recalled. “He was a typical teenage boy who knew all the answers.”
By age 17, Levi had left school and moved out of the family home.
Then, in November 2002, another tragedy struck. A nighttime fire destroyed the family barn, trapping three Belgian draft horses inside.
Mike said Karl did not appear to be “overwhelmed with emotion.”
Within days, the barn’s remains had been demolished and removed. Karl received nearly $115,000 in insurance proceeds.
Although some relatives questioned how the fire began, a brief investigation concluded that it had been accidental.
What Happened to Levi Karlsen?
By November 2008, Levi had earned his GED, become the father of two daughters and found steady employment.
On Nov. 20, 2008, Levi went to Karl’s home to work on an old pickup truck in the barn. Karl and Cindy left for a funeral. When they returned, Karl found his 23-year-old son dead beneath the truck.
“The truck fell on my stepson,” Cindy told a 911 operator in a panic. “His chest is crushed… he’s probably been under there for hours.”
Cindy said Karl appeared “very distraught.”
“He was actually like throwing himself up against the wall,” she recalled. “And he was on the ground.”
Karl received $700,000 in life insurance benefits as the policy’s named beneficiary. The policy had been issued only 17 days before Levi died.
Karl Karlsen’s Wife Cindy Best Hires Private Investigator
Karl used some of the insurance money to launch a business raising gourmet ducks for restaurants.
By then, however, Cindy had begun to suspect that something was wrong. She attributed her growing uneasiness about her husband to her “intuition.”
“These thoughts kept coming up,” she said. “[I] kept sinking more into a depression.”
Cindy remembered that Karl had been alone with Levi in the barn before they left for the funeral on the day Levi died.
She hired a private investigator, who began examining Karl’s history. In February 2012, one of Cindy’s friends contacted the Seneca County Sheriff’s Office, prompting the agency to open its own investigation.
Lt. John Cleere said authorities learned about Karl’s substantial insurance payouts and discovered that two additional policies had been purchased on Levi’s daughters.
Karl Karlsen Admits to Role in Son Levi’s Death
Frightened, Cindy left Karl and took Alex with her. She also tried to assist investigators by secretly recording a conversation in which she confronted Karl about Levi’s death. Although he denied pushing the truck onto Levi, he acknowledged that he had “taken advantage of the situation once it happened.”
Investigators believed they had enough information to bring Karl in for questioning.
After hours of interrogation, Karl admitted that the truck had fallen on Levi before he and Cindy left for the funeral.
“I made a decision to walk out on my son and not get him out from underneath the truck,” he told investigators. “I panicked.”
He later acknowledged that he might have caused the truck to tip by opening its door.
“When I did, it tipped,” he said. “And it just [expletive] fell over.”
Karl was arrested and taken into custody.
“I would never think anybody could do that to their son,” Mike told Dateline. “I couldn’t see how anybody would do it to a perfect stranger or a wild animal.”
One day before his trial was scheduled to begin, Karl pleaded guilty to second-degree murder on Nov. 6, 2013. He was sentenced to 15 years to life in prison.
Karl Karlsen Charged in Connection to Wife Christina Karlsen’s Death
Karl’s conviction prompted California investigators to reopen Christina’s case, with the support of his adult children.
Kent turned over his original case files, while investigators interviewed witnesses and reviewed the evidence again.
They concluded that Karl had intentionally set the fire to kill his wife and collect an insurance payment. In August 2014, he was charged with first-degree murder in Calaveras County.
Karl was convicted in February 2020 and sentenced to life in prison.
Karl Karlsen Continues to Proclaim His Innocence
Even after being imprisoned, Karl continued to deny killing Christina or Levi during an interview with Dateline: Secrets Uncovered. He claimed Levi was still alive when he left him in the barn and said he confessed only because he was exhausted and needed his pain medication. He also maintained that he did not know how the California fire had started.
He described the tragedies that had struck his family as a run of bad luck.
“If I told you everything,” he said, “you wouldn’t believe what’s happened to me.”