Judge declares Trump's use of Alien Enemies Act 'unlawful'
Share and Follow

President Donald Trump attends a meeting with the Fraternal Order of Police in the State Dinning Room of the White House, Thursday, June 5, 2025, in Washington (AP Photo/Alex Brandon).

Chalk up two losses in one week for President Donald Trump at the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit in the long-running defamation case brought — and won — by writer E. Jean Carroll.

On Wednesday, a three-judge panel rebuked efforts to have the public pay for Trump”s appeal of the $83 million judgment in Carroll’s favor – rejecting a claim under the Westfall Act, a law which can force the U.S. Department of Justice to step into the shoes of government officials sued for torts committed within the scope of their official duties.

On Thursday, the 45th and 47th president filed a joint motion with the DOJ asking the New York City-based court to put the case in abeyance – effectively requesting a full-on pause in all ongoing proceedings until the Westfall Act decision is fully appealed.

On Friday, the appellate court nixed that request as well.

Love true crime? Sign up for our newsletter, The Law&Crime Docket, to get the latest real-life crime stories delivered right to your inbox.

The Wednesday decision by Senior U.S. Circuit Judge Denny Chin, a Barack Obama appointee, and U.S. Circuit Judges Sarah Merriam and Maria Araújo Kahn, both Joe Biden appointees, was particularly terse.

And therein was the rub for the 45th and 47th president.

The court’s four-sentence order “did not contain any reasoning” but instead noted it “will issue an opinion detailing its reasoning in due course” while keeping oral arguments in the broader appeal slated for June 24, Trump’s 14-page abeyance motion complained.

To hear the government and the president tell it, while oral arguments were scheduled months ago, the conclusory order on the Westfall Act issue coming just days before the hearing is unfair and prejudicial.

“The United States and President Trump are entitled to immediate review of the panel’s erroneous Westfall Act decision by this Court en banc and, if necessary, by the Supreme Court,” the joint abeyance motion argued. “By not publishing its reasoning, the panel has effectively denied the United States and President Trump the opportunity to seek immediate appellate review of the basis of its decision, including prior to oral argument of the appeal at which the United States should be the defendant.”

Another major argument raised in the motion was the public interest – seeking to vindicate the general idea of immunity for government officials. Generally, Trump and the DOJ said, the idea behind immunity is “to safeguard the public interest in having responsible governmental employees faithfully carry out their duties without fear of protracted litigation in unfounded damage suits.”

‘This is especially true when the federal employee is the President,” the motion goes on. “Staying proceedings here to resolve important immunity questions raised by the President is certainly in the public interest.”

Share and Follow
You May Also Like

Shocking Domestic Violence Incident: Husband Allegedly Pushes Wife Down Stairs, Resulting in Severe Injury

Share A man in Pennsylvania is facing serious charges after allegedly pushing…

Constitutional Law Analyst Raises Concerns Over Potentially Flawed Secret ICE Memo Revealed by Trump Administration Whistleblowers

President Donald Trump listens as Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem speaks during…

Furious Over Neighbors’ Marijuana Use, Man Sets Apartment Ablaze: A Shocking Tale of Frustration

Inset: Keith Luko (Milwaukee Police Department). Background: The apartment building Luko allegedly…

Detroit Neurosurgeon Murder Suspect Unexpectedly Admits Guilt

This week, a man from Michigan, accused of the murder of a…

Tragic Incident: Firefighter Murders Wife with Axe After Discovering Diary Secrets

A firefighter from California has been arrested, accused of killing his wife…

Trump Moves to Legally Challenge Mar-a-Lago Report: Potential Permanent Gag on Jack Smith Looms

Left inset: Judge Aileen Cannon (U.S. District Court). Right inset: Jack Smith…

Extradition Shocker: Tepe Murder Suspect Returns to Ohio with Star Attorney in Tow

Michael McKee, accused of a double homicide, has been extradited to Ohio…

Shocking High-Speed Crash: Chevy Hits VW at Over 100 MPH in 35 MPH Zone, Leaving Cars Entangled

Inset: Dayton Milligan (Milwaukee County Jail). Background: The intersection of North 76th…