DNA Solves Murder of 18-Year-Old Ohio Woman in 1981
Share and Follow

An Ohio man has been identified as the killer of an 18-year-old woman who was beaten to death with an oven grate in 1981.

James Vanest, who was 26 at the time he lived upstairs from Debra Lee Miller in a Mansfield apartment building, was shot to death in November after barricading himself in a hotel from law enforcement attempting to serve an indictment against him on gun charges, The Associated Press reported.

Mansfield Police Chief Jason Bammann said prosecutors were preparing to take the murder case before a grand jury after developing a “firm DNA profile” of Vanest when invsetigators reopened the case to take advantage of advances in DNA technology.

Vanest had been questioned at the time of the murder but was never named a suspect as the initial investigation became mired in allegations of possible police misconduct.

Miller’s death was one of several in the Mansfield area that was examined for possible links to city police officers. A special investigation determined no officers were tied to the deaths in 1989, but the report from that investigation raised questions about officers’ sexual involvement with Miller. The investigation prompted the retirement of the city police chief in 1990.

Police questioned Vanest again in November 2021, at which time he admitted lying to the original investigators. Bamman said the new investigators thought he might be trying to concoct an explanation for how his DNA was found in Miller’s apartment.

But when detectives sought another interview early last year, Vanest declined and requested an attorney. Then he abruptly sold his house, bought a truck and trailer, and fled to West Virginia.

But he left several firearms behind at the Ohio house, and when police stopped him in West Virginia, they found two more guns. He was arrested on state weapons charges and released on bond.

At that point, the federal Bureau of Alcohol Firearms and Explosives indicted him on federal gun charges. On November 18, US Marshals and a local SWAT team tried to serve him with that indictment.

“It is our understanding that when confronted by Marshals and the Canton Regional SWAT team, Mr. Vanest pointed a gun at them and barricaded himself inside the hotel,” Bammann said. “After a short shootout, one Canton SWAT member was shot in the arm, and Mr. Vanest was fatally shot.”

Bamman said the department now considers the Miller case closed.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like

Police Report: Man Allegedly Attacks Ex’s Friend During Bar Encounter

Inset: Robert S. Goodletson (Brown County Sheriff’s Office). Background: The Hammer Inn…

Mother Confesses to Toddler’s Death to ‘Make Room’ for Another Child

Inset: Matthew Maison (Justice for Matthew Facebook Group). Background, left to right:…

Suspect Requests Reduced Bail Due to Impending Fatherhood, Authorities Report

Background: The Youngstown Municipal Courthouse in Youngstown, Ohio (Google Maps). Inset: James…

Father Sentenced for Murdering Wife and Taking Children to School Before Arrest

Farel Torres being arrested after fatally stabbing his girlfriend in Florida (Office…

Judge Faces Reprimand for Allegedly Aiding in ICE Evasion: Legal Drama Unfolds

Inset: Newton District Court Judge Shelley Joseph (WBZ). Background: Newton District Courthouse…

Shocking Abuse Case: Five Arrested for Allegedly Chaining Woman in Yard for Months Over Personal Grudge

In Austin, Texas, a woman was reportedly held captive, mistreated, and deprived…

Shocking Crime: Man Charged with Stabbing Girlfriend After Breakup

Background: Bruce Maiben appears in Essex County court in Salem, Massachusetts (WBZ/YouTube).…

Tragic Family Incident: Daughter Admits to Parents’ Shooting in Disturbing Confession

Inset left: Mia Bailey (Washington County Sheriff’s Office). Inset middle: Joseph Bailey…