Dad who killed daughter and her cat to plead guilty: Lawyer
Share and Follow

Background: Delbert Cornish appears in Canyon County, Idaho, court in October 2025 (KIVI/YouTube). Inset: Hope “Onyx” Cornish and her cat (GoFundMe).

An Idaho man facing charges of murdering his adopted daughter and subsequently concealing her body with a pride flag is set to enter a guilty plea, his attorney announced during a court session in Canyon County on Tuesday.

Delbert Cornish, aged 51, is accused of the first-degree murder of 18-year-old Hope “Onyx” Cornish, who died in August. Last month, charges against him escalated from aggravated assault to assault with intent to commit murder, alongside a new allegation of animal cruelty, according to reports from Law&Crime.

Currently, it remains uncertain if Cornish has negotiated any plea agreement with the prosecution regarding the murder charge.

On Tuesday, the defendant returned to court, this time with a shaved head. As Delbert Cornish sat, his lawyer rose, telling the presiding judge that “at this time, Mr. Cornish would like to change his plea to guilty,” per courtroom video shot by Boise-based ABC affiliate KIVI.

Crystal Thompson, Hope’s mother, recounted her reaction upon seeing Cornish in court to the outlet, saying, “It felt like my blood ran cold. I started shaking and was overwhelmed with a sense of despair.”

Thompson, who reportedly dated Delbert Cornish for several years, further shared, “He glanced at me briefly before looking away, avoiding eye contact thereafter. He must confront the consequences of his actions, and it feels unjust.”

On Aug. 18, a “horrific act of family violence” occurred, as authorities would later recount. At a home on the 1600 block of Blaine Street in Caldwell, a suburb of Boise, Delbert Cornish took several shots of alcohol around 9 a.m., according to court documents obtained by local outlets. He then entered his daughter’s bedroom and reportedly shot her in the side of the head.

The defendant then kissed her on the cheek and shot her cat “for the same reasons, because no one would take care of it after they were all dead,” a probable cause affidavit says. Delbert Cornish is said to have then covered Hope Cornish’s body with a large pride flag “as a way to honor her, because it was something that meant a lot to her.”

Delbert Cornish

Background: The 1600 block of Blaine Street in Caldwell, Idaho (Google Maps). Inset: Delbert Cornish (Canyon County Sheriff’s Office).

He had been planning to kill his daughter, two sons, and himself for nearly a year, ever since he bought a black 9 mm Hi-Point handgun in September or October 2024, law enforcement said. And on that August day, as the hours passed after the shooting, Delbert Cornish allegedly waited for his youngest son Lucian Cornish — who is reported to have been either 14 or 15 years old — to come home from school.

When the teen arrived, Delbert Cornish reportedly asked him how school was before telling him “he had killed his sister.” The defendant also tried to convince the boy to “check on his sister,” but the son refused, the affidavit states.

“Delbert then went to the couch [and] grabbed a gun,” at which point his son said he wanted to leave, the court document adds. But the defendant did not intend to let that happen, authorities maintain. He allegedly “shot at the ground,” blocked the doorway, and pointed the gun at his son’s chest.

They fought over the gun, according to Lucian Cornish, with the son eventually winning control over it and running away to call 911.

When law enforcement officials arrived at the home after 4 p.m., they found the magazine, the handgun, and a “large note written on the wall” that appeared to be a possible murder-suicide note. It reportedly included statements such as “I’m a man of my word my kids died by my hand. I’m tired of them being made fun of,” and “I’m going! My kids are going with me.”

Police found Hope Cornish and her cat dead. The defendant was arrested about 70 miles southeast heading to his ex-girlfriend’s home, local NBC affiliate KTVB reported.

Delbert Cornish confessed to killing his daughter and “began to cry” when an officer said they had found his daughter’s body, according to the affidavit. “I’m not gonna lie, I did it dude,” the defendant allegedly said, unprompted.

The court document also suggests a possible motive for the defendant’s alleged crimes.

“Delbert admitted to me that he is an alcoholic who struggles with depression,” it states. “Delbert explained he wanted to kill his children along with himself because he believed nobody … would take care of them once he was dead, and that they would not be able to carry on in life without him.”

A change of plea hearing is reportedly scheduled for Nov. 12. Lucian Cornish has been by his mother’s side as they seek “justice” for Hope Cornish’s killing, and as the mother told KIVI, they plan to be there when Delbert Cornish learns his fate.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like

Police Report: Mother Allegedly Assaults 7-Year-Old Over Disrespectful Behavior

Left: Jennifer Revis. Right: Ryan Revis (Blackford County Jail). An unsettling case…

Miraculous Survival: Man Walks 20 Minutes with Butcher Knife Lodged in Head

Inset: Tariq Thomas (Woodbury County Jail). Background: The home on South Lyons…

Unbelievable Bank Blunder: Man Caught Sending Meth Through Drive-Thru Tube

Jason Smith (Monroe County Sheriff”s Office). In a rather unconventional turn of…

Prosecutors Pursue Death Penalty for Florida Man Charged with Murdering and Incinerating Two Children

The Florida State Attorney’s Office revealed on Friday its intention to pursue…

Hawthorne Resident Arrested for Indecent Exposure: Community Concerns Rise

By Staff Writer HAWTHORNE, Fla. – In a bizarre incident yesterday, 36-year-old…

Beauty Queen Receives Verdict in Dorm Room Toddler Homicide Case

Background: Trinity Poague reacts after she”s found guilty of murdering her boyfriend’s…

Tragic Discovery: Arkansas Mother and Twins Found Dead Just One Day After Divorce from Abusive Ex-Husband

In a tragic turn of events, an Arkansas mother who was in…

Manhunt Intensifies: Louisiana Murder Suspect Escapes St. Landry Parish Jail

Authorities in Louisiana are on high alert as one inmate remains at…