Share and Follow

The Suffolk County District Attorney’s office identified a Jane Doe found near the Gilgo Four as Karen Vergata, 34.

During an Aug. 4 press conference, D.A. Raymond Tierney shared that Vergata was working as an escort in midtown Manhattan when she disappeared around February 14, 1996. At the time, no one reported the 34-year-old missing.

According to Tierney, the feet and legs of Jane Doe No. 7 were found on the bayside shore of Fire Island April 20, 1996. Then, 15 years later, on April 11, 2011 — the same day the Jane Doe known as “Peaches” was discovered on Jones Beach — authorities found a skull in Tobay Beach in Nassau County. Her torso has never been found.

RELATED: “I Will Get Great Pleasure in Tearing Her Apart,” Aspiring Actor Writes in Chilling Note Before Murder

After the formation of the Gilgo Beach Task Force, the Suffolk County Crime Lab began the process of identifying the victim in coordination with the FBI. Once they were able to create a DNA profile, they reached out to Vergata’s family members last October to obtain another DNA sample, leading to the confirmation of her identity. 

News of her identification was kept a secret amid the confidential investigation.

Though the remains of Jane Doe were found in the same vicinity as other Gilgo Beach murder victims — including an unidentified Asian male, Peaches, and Peaches’ infant child — Tierney said they won’t be naming a suspect and noted that Gilgo Beach murder suspect Rex Heuermann has not been charged in connection to the those other murders.

He added that the investigation remains confidential and ongoing.

RELATED: “My Children Cry Themselves to Sleep”: Wife of Accused Gilgo Beach Serial Killer Speaks Out about Police Raid

Heuermann’s lawyer pleaded not guilty on his behalf in the murders of Amber Costello, Melissa Barthelemy, and Megan Waterman. He is a prime suspect in the murder of Maureen Brainard-Barnes.

At the press conference, a reporter asked Tierney about belts used to bind Brainard-Barnes’ legs and ankles, but the D.A. declined to comment on the case.

This week, Tierney told Newsday that authorities are in the process of testing hair found on one of the belts, according to the New York Post. Additionally, he confirmed that the leather belts had the initials “WH” and “HM” engraved and are a part of the evidence that has been presented to a grand jury.

“Yes, there was ‘WH’ or ‘HM’ on the belt. The last name is Heuermann. There are ancestors with WH, so assign to that what you will,” Tierney said.

According to the Post, Heuermann’s grandfather William Heuermann died in 1964.

Though there has been speculation that Heuermann had an accomplice, Tierney told the outlet, “We have no evidence that this defendant conspired or acted with any other person.”

Heuermann is scheduled to appear in court for a pretrial conference hearing on Sept. 27.

Vergata is just one of the 11 decedents who were found dead in two Long Island counties from 2010 to 2011. While Heuermann is charged in connection to the deaths of Costello, Barthelemy, and Waterman, and is a suspect in the death of Brainard-Barnes, police are still investigating what happened to Shannan Gilbert, Jessica Taylor, Valerie Mack, Peaches, Peaches’ infant daughter, and an unidentified Asian male.

Authorities have previously indicated that they do not believe Shannan Gilbert’s murder is tied to the deaths of the Gilgo Four. 

Share and Follow
You May Also Like

Florida Sisters Arrested for Alleged Shoplifting Spree at Target Store

Inset left to right: Hala Kamel and Afnane Kamel (Polk County Sheriff”s…

Tragic Shooting: 17-Year-Old Girl Fatally Shot Outside House Party, Authorities Report

Inset: Deshawn Suggs (Bexar County Sheriff”s Office). Background: The intersection of Luckey…

Tragic Incident: Man Accused of Fatally Stabbing Wife Amid Infidelity Dispute

Inset, left to right: Brian Jutson Sr. (Brazos County Jail) and Sherry…

Las Vegas Woman and Brother Accused in Chilling Plot Against Her Husband: What Drove Their Scheme?

Every crime scene and its victim unravel a complex narrative. This was…

Tragic Loss: Drunk Driver Claims Lives of 5-Year-Old Louisiana Boy and Grandmother at School Bus Stop

A tragic incident in Louisiana has led to the arrest of a…

Authorities Report Suspect Sought Gas Money Prior to Alleged Shooting

Inset (from left to right): Elian Araujo, Hugo Carlin, and Misael Jiminez…

Tragic Justice: Mother Sentenced in Heartbreaking Case of Daughter’s Fatal Beating

Left: Amanda Mitchell (New River Valley Regional Jail). Right: Harper Mitchell (Obituary).…

Unmasking the Dark Trade: Kohberger, ‘Murderabilia,’ and the Ethical Dilemma of Profiting from Crime

In today’s interconnected world, crime extends far beyond the confines of the…