HomeCrimeGainesville Man Arrested After Allegedly Touching Juvenile Neighbor Who Asked to Use...

Gainesville Man Arrested After Allegedly Touching Juvenile Neighbor Who Asked to Use His Bathroom

GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Bennie Williams III, 52, faces charges of lewd or lascivious molestation involving a victim younger than 16 after he allegedly touched a neighboring girl beneath her underwear.

According to a Gainesville Police Department detective, the 15-year-old girl went to Williams’s home on September 21 after arguing with a family member. She knew another relative was there and waited on Williams’s porch until she needed to use the bathroom. Williams let her inside, and she used a bathroom connected to his bedroom.

The girl told investigators that Williams entered the bathroom through a second door leading from his bedroom, closed it behind him and said he had noticed the way she “looks at him” when she walks past his house.

She said Williams pulled down his pants and exposed himself, making her feel uncomfortable. Although he pulled his pants back up, he allegedly approached her as she tried to leave. Williams reportedly stopped her by grabbing both of her arms.

Williams allegedly told the girl he needed to shave and asked whether she felt comfortable. When she said she did not, he reportedly replied that he wanted her to feel at ease before rubbing her legs and moving upward, eventually touching her through her underwear while she was backed against the sink. He allegedly told her that he and his wife “do” this in the same way. The girl said she was shocked and felt unable to move or respond.

A short time later, Williams reportedly offered to get her a drink. When he left the bathroom, the girl ran home and took a large kitchen knife. She and another juvenile then returned to Williams’s house, knocked on the door and knocked several potted plants off the front porch. The girl said she wanted to hurt Williams because he had physically and emotionally harmed her. Williams reportedly came outside to retrieve the plants, but the girl knocked them over again, prompting him to return inside.

The detective also reported that Williams had visited the girl’s home earlier that day while the adults were away. He allegedly asked to borrow a phone charger and use the bathroom, then sat on a female child’s bed and said he wanted both juveniles to “feel comfortable” around him. Investigators found no indication that he touched either child inappropriately during that visit.

A family member reportedly confirmed that the girl had been at Williams’s home when the alleged incident occurred. The relative also said Williams left the kitchen after the girl arrived and was not in that room during the alleged assault. According to the family member, Williams later claimed the girl had run out of his house because she had stolen his phone.

The same family member confirmed that the girl returned carrying a knife and said Williams had touched her inappropriately. The relative also saw the girl throw the potted plants onto the ground and said Williams exited through the back door and had not been seen afterward.

Another family member told investigators that the girl entered her own home through a window, picked up a knife and then left again.

The detective said the girl asked a neighbor to call 911 because she did not have access to a phone. Investigators found no evidence that she took Williams’s phone.

The detective also observed that Williams’s potted plants had been knocked over, supporting part of the girl’s account. Police attempted to reach Williams at his residence and by phone for approximately a week before seeking an arrest warrant.

Williams, who told Justice Support Services that he has worked as a barber for 30 years, was charged with lewd or lascivious molestation of a victim between 12 and 16 years old and false imprisonment. He has four prior nonviolent felony convictions and 17 misdemeanor convictions, including one violent offense. He was also on probation for domestic battery and was booked on a March 2026 warrant alleging a probation violation.

Judge Meshon Rawls ordered Williams held without bail while the court considers a motion from the State Attorney’s Office seeking to keep him jailed without bail through trial. If the motion is denied, the judge will set bail at that hearing.