Ex-judges shred Trump DOJ for judge's ICE obstruction case
Share and Follow

Background: Milwaukee County Judge Hannah Dugan in court (WTMJ/YouTube). Inset: Surveillance video shows Milwaukee County Judge Hannah Dugan speaking with ICE agents before Eduardo Flores-Ruiz’s detainment (WDJT/YouTube).

Wisconsin Judge Hannah Dugan, recently found guilty of obstructing ICE agents during an immigration operation, has opted to step down amidst mounting pressure for her impeachment and removal from office following her conviction.

The 66-year-old judge revealed her decision to resign on Saturday, citing her intention to continue challenging the legal system and contesting her guilty verdict to protect “our independent judiciary,” as she expressed in her announcement.

In a letter addressed to Wisconsin Governor Tony Evers, which was first reported by local ABC station WISN, Dugan stated, “I am embroiled in unprecedented federal legal proceedings that pose significant and complex challenges to judicial independence.”

She continued, “This fight is not only for myself but also for maintaining an independent judiciary. However, the citizens of Wisconsin deserve a judge who can serve uninterrupted in Milwaukee County Branch 31, rather than becoming embroiled in a partisan battle within the state legislature.”

Governor Evers’ spokesperson issued a statement to the Wisconsin Law Journal over the weekend, indicating that efforts to find Dugan’s replacement would commence immediately.

“As with any appointment, the governor will work to fill the vacancy without delay,” the rep said.

Dugan, 66, was indicted last year for allegedly helping an undocumented immigrant evade federal officers shortly after he appeared in her Milwaukee County Circuit courtroom in connection with a domestic abuse case. A federal jury found Dugan guilty in December of one count of obstructing or impeding a proceeding before a department or agency of the United States, a felony. Jurors, however, found her innocent of one count of concealing an individual to prevent his discovery and arrest, a misdemeanor.

Steve Biskupic, one of Dugan’s defense attorneys — and a former U.S. Attorney — told WISN late last month that her legal team plans to ask U.S. District Judge Lynn Adelman, a Bill Clinton appointee, to set aside Dugan’s guilty verdict. Her lawyers filed a notice on Dec. 23 saying they will officially ask for a new trial.

“Defendant Hannah C. Dugan, by counsel, has moved for a judgment of acquittal,” the notice said.

“The judge has given us plenty of time, until the end of January, to explore this, to educate him,” Biskupic told WISN, noting how Dugan’s team will be calling on Adelman to toss the jury’s split verdict after jurors came forward in the press and said they got contradictory answers from Adelman while asking him questions about the case.

Specifically, the jury reportedly asked whether Dugan needed to know who Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents were looking for that day in order to convict her. For the misdemeanor concealing charge, the jurors said Adelman told them yes. But for the felony charge, jurors claimed he told them no.

“If it came back the same, we all would have found her not guilty, I am sure of it,” a juror told the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel after Dugan’s conviction. “The jury followed Adelman’s instructions faithfully,” another juror said.

In response, Biskupic told WISN, “Obviously, the constitutional system that she’s devoted her life to is that we rely upon the jury system. Now you make arguments that the jury was improperly instructed, especially on those questions, that’s all fair game for anybody in a case, and so whether you say I accept the verdict or not, of course it’s the verdict, and that is where the case is going to be going forward. And that’s where some of the challenge will be.”

After being found guilty, state Republicans called on Dugan to be removed from the bench. She was suspended without pay following her indictment.

During her trial, federal prosecutors alleged Dugan impeded ICE agents during the courthouse immigration bust in Milwaukee by helping a Mexican national named Eduardo Flores-Ruiz, who is facing misdemeanor battery charges, leave through a jury door after a hearing in his criminal case. Dugan was accused of telling ICE agents they needed to obtain a judicial warrant to take Flores-Ruiz into custody. Later, a deputy working in the courthouse provided information to federal investigators.

The incident occurred on April 18, and Dugan was charged in a criminal complaint less than a week later and was formally indicted in late May.

“While we are disappointed in today’s outcome, the failure of the prosecution to secure convictions on both counts demonstrates the opportunity we have to clear Judge Dugan’s name and show she did nothing wrong in this matter,” Dugan’s defense said in a statement after the verdict. “We have planned for this potential outcome and our defense of Judge Dugan is just beginning. This trial required considerable resources to prepare for and public support for Judge Dugan’s defense fund is critical as we prepare for the next phase of this defense.”

Obstruction carries a potential maximum sentence of five years in federal prison, according to federal law. But such an outcome is exceedingly unlikely due to Dugan’s lack of a criminal record and the facts of the case itself. The sought-after criminal defendant was eventually detained and then deported in November.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like

Ohio Police Release Crucial Video of Potential Suspect in Couple’s Homicide Case

Authorities are appealing to the public to help identify a person of…

Kilmar Abrego Garcia Challenges Trump-Era Deportation with Strategic Legal Maneuver

Inset: Kilmar Abrego Garcia in an undated photo (CASA). Background: President Donald…

DOJ and FBI Face Lawsuit Seeking Disclosure of Top Officials’ Communications on Trump Pardons and Alleged Power Misuse

Left: In this Jan. 6, 2021, file photo violent insurrectionists loyal to…

Gainesville Woman Faces Charges for Deliberately Ramming Car into Elderly Driver’s Vehicle

Reported by Staff GAINESVILLE, Fla. – In a troubling incident that unfolded…

Man Makes Ominous Threat After Being Ejected from Pub, Police Report

Inset: Luis Armondo Diaz Mendez (Bexar County Jail). Background: The pub where…

Defiant Killer Receives Sentencing in Dramatic Hearing for House Party Shooting

Inset: Christopher Valdez (Fresno Police Department). Background: The apartment complex where Valdez…

Witness Emerges as Lawsuit is Filed in the Death of Texas A&M Student Brianna Aguilera

A lawsuit has been filed by the family of Brianna Aguilera, a…

Rapid Changes in South Carolina’s Personal Injury Law: What You Need to Know

The field of personal injury law is anything but static; it evolves…