Judge cites Antonin Scalia while blocking Trump asylum ban
Share and Follow

Donald Trump speaks at the annual Road to Majority conference in Washington, DC, June 22, 2024. (Allison Bailey/NurPhoto via AP). Right: In this Oct. 18, 2011 file photo, U.S. Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia looks into the balcony before addressing the Chicago-Kent College Law justice in Chicago (AP Photo/Charles Rex Arbogast, File).

A federal judge in Washington, D.C., blocked President Donald Trump”s subordinates in the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) from implementing the executive’s Inauguration Day proclamation, which declared that an “invasion” and emergency necessitated an asylum ban at the southern border.

U.S. District Judge Randolph Moss ruled Wednesday in a lengthy opinion that Trump exceeded his authority and acted “contrary to law” by sidestepping the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA) to “prohibit covered aliens from applying for asylum or implement new limitations on asylum that have not been adopted by regulation.”

Moss, a Barack Obama appointee, cited the late conservative Justice Antonin Scalia several times to push back on the Trump administration’s arguments that there was no judicial review of the president’s proclamation available to seven individual plaintiffs who remain in the U.S. — identified only by the initials A.M., Z.A., T.A., A.T., B.R., M.A., and G.A — and three plaintiff nonprofit legal groups: the Refugee and Immigrant Center for Education and Legal Services; Las Americas Immigrant Advocacy Center; and the Florence Immigrant & Refugee Rights Project.

The judge pointed out that he was not enjoining the president but rather those in DHS attempting to implement the proclamation through guidance against asylum or “withholding of removal” relief. Moss said he was following the “approach” to judicial review of a presidential action that Scalia “endorsed.”

“On Defendants’ telling, no matter what the Court does, the Proclamation will remain in effect and, even if the implementing guidance is enjoined or vacated, the Proclamation will continue to preclude immigration officials from considering Plaintiffs’ requests for asylum or withholding of removal,” Moss said. “Justice Scalia spoke directly to this issue in his concurring opinion in Franklin v. Massachusetts.”

Love true crime? Sign up for our newsletter, The Law&Crime Docket, to get the latest real-life crime stories delivered right to your inbox.

In that concurrence, Scalia wrote that “[r]eview of the legality of Presidential action can ordinarily be obtained in a suit seeking to enjoin the officers who attempt to enforce the President’s directive.”

Later in Moss’ opinion, he reiterated that there wasn’t “merit” to the argument that Trump’s proclamations “lie beyond the scope of review even, when the relief is limited to enjoining the actions of subordinate government officials.” He pointed a second time to Scalia’s concurrence.

The judge said the administration’s assertion that flouting the INA was done out of necessity flies in the face of the Framers’ understanding and “undermines respect for the rule of law[.]”

“[N]othing in the INA or the Constitution grants the President or his delegees the sweeping authority asserted in the Proclamation and implementing guidance. An appeal to necessity cannot fill that void,” Moss said.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like

Son Abandons Father to Perish in Bathtub During House Fire, Police Say

Inset: Clinton Hadley (St. Tammany Parish Sheriff’s Office). Background: The 1900 block…

Legal Experts Debate Trump’s Effort to Remove Deportation Safeguards

Donald Trump, left, shakes hands with Kristi Noem at a campaign rally…

Lawyers Confounded by Judge’s Order Containing ‘Inaccuracies’

Left: Mississippi Attorney General Lynn Fitch waits to speak at a Trump…

Police Report: Man Allegedly Planted Bomb in Former Landlord’s Lawn Mower

Background: The area of 7900 State Route 22 in Salem Township, Pennsylvania…

UPDATE: Barricaded Suspect Fatally Shot by Deputy

ASO Captain Chris Sims speaks about the ongoing incident Staff report GAINESVILLE,…

Man Allegedly Asleep While Boy Tragically Drowns in Florida Hotel Pool: Police

Inset: Sharef Omar Smith (Brevard County Sheriff”s Office). Background: Quality Inn hotel…

Understanding the DOJ Misconduct Allegations Against Judge Boasberg

Left: Chief U.S. District Judge James Boasberg (U.S. District Courts). Right: U.S.…

Pathology with Dr. Priya | A Zone 7 Series | Truth in the Tissues

Welcome to Pathology with Dr. Priya | A Zone 7 Series, a…